Tuesday, 12 October 2021
Bills
Education and Training Reform Amendment (Senior Secondary Pathways Reforms and Other Matters) Bill 2021
-
Commencement
-
Announcements
-
Bills
-
Business of the house
-
Petitions
-
Documents
-
Bills
-
Motions
-
Bills
-
Questions without notice and ministers statements
-
Business of the house
-
Members statements
-
Constituency questions
-
Adjournment
Education and Training Reform Amendment (Senior Secondary Pathways Reforms and Other Matters) Bill 2021
Second reading
Debate resumed on motion of Mr MERLINO:
That this bill be now read a second time.
Mr HODGETT (Croydon) (09:31): I rise to lead the debate on the Education and Training Reform Amendment (Senior Secondary Pathways Reforms and Other Matters) Bill 2021, and I state at the outset that we are supporting this bill. I have shown a great interest in this. It is an exciting bill, but I think, given I am a parent of seven children, with my last going through school, I perhaps should declare a conflict of interest here that I am certainly looking at these sorts of pathways. You know, I did get deeply involved in this legislation, and I will thank a couple of people in a moment. But I should give a shout-out too to Ranges TEC and Ric Thorpe and all of the people out there—Ric is a director at Ranges TEC; I think he has been a director there since 2017—and MECS of course, Mount Evelyn Christian School. Ranges TEC is a campus of MECS, especially designed for that hands-on learning which gives pathways into trades, TAFE and all the wider workforce. I had the pleasure of visiting both MECS and Ranges TEC some time ago, and some of the work that they are doing there and the passion and dedication of those people there are truly things to be admired. I think they will watch this bill with interest and see how those changes transition into these new arrangements.
But before I begin, I do want to just start off a bit differently today. Before I get into the details of the bill, I want to commence with a couple of thankyous and in particular one to the parliamentary library information services. There are a number of people that I would like to put my thanks on record to in appreciation of those who have greatly assisted me to examine this bill, to consult widely and to form a view and a recommendation to support it. I think sometimes as members of this place we do not necessarily take for granted but we perhaps do not acknowledge the work that the parliamentary library information services do. We all know that when bills are introduced to the Parliament the library prepares info links with key resources for every bill. It is very useful. I have found it particularly useful with all the bills that I am responsible for as the Shadow Minister for Education, and particularly for this one. Members would be familiar that those info links have a copy of the bill, relevant legislation, related documents, any media in relation to the topic and organisations and websites. I do want to put on record my thanks to the parliamentary library for the research they did, because that information was valuable. I consulted and referred to it a number of times as I tried to get my head around the workings of this bill, and I very much appreciate all the work the library staff do in supporting members here from both sides of the house and from both chambers.
I should also put on record my thanks to the departmental reps. Fortunately I had a bit more time to actually prepare a bill briefing and to consult widely with stakeholders, and the department reps as always were very giving of their time and advice in answering questions. We had a number of members from this side attend the bill briefing: Melina Bath, Matt Bach and Bev McArthur from the other place; and the member for Eildon and the member for South-West Coast from this house. I think we all appreciated the time that those departmental reps gave in answering the questions we asked as we wanted to analyse the bill and get into greater detail. Also just a shout-out again in appreciation to Paul Frame and Ben Craven from the minister’s office who put together that bill briefing which enabled us to smoothly consider the bill, consult with stakeholders, have questions answered, consult widely and form a view and a position on the bill to come back through our party room processes and eventually arrive here today to debate this bill in the house. Thank you to Paul and thank you to Ben from the minister’s office.
Just before I get into the details of the bill, there are a couple of reports that are highly relevant to this bill that I want to make mention of and quote a few things from to set the scene. This is a government document, but I think some of the comments in it are welcome. This is Senior Secondary Pathways Reform Taskforce: Senior Secondary Reform Overview. For any members that might want to make a contribution to this debate I highly recommend they have a look at these reports. They are full of information.
I think we all agree in this place that setting every Victorian student up for the future is something we all want to support. We want every Victorian senior secondary experience to be a positive one, an enjoyable one, a rewarding one. The report states:
Senior secondary education is about developing and realising every student’s potential. Our VCE is world class and the Victorian Certificate of Applied Learning (VCAL) has provided a steppingstone to great jobs in growing industries.
I will come back and touch on that a bit further in my contribution.
We need to ensure students build the skills and capabilities to thrive in further education and training, move into a rewarding career and live a great life.
Within senior secondary education, vocational and applied learning builds critical and creative thinking, communication skills, teamwork and collaboration, curiosity and innovation—
all great things.
It provides students with real-world knowledge, including about the workplace and practical and transferable skills.
Just before entering the chamber I was fortunate to catch the Minister for Education in the hallway and talk about our position on this bill.
Ms Allan interjected.
Mr HODGETT: No, we had a great conversation about the merits of this bill. Again, we are all supporting setting every Victorian up for the future. We all get this feedback. Whether it be university, whether it be high school or whether it be applied learning, a lot of people from business and industry talk about people being job ready and having the skills to come out of the learning environment and to apply those skills straightaway. We can always improve there and we can always get better at that. Feedback is consistent from industry and from the different work sectors about getting students job ready, where they can leave that learning environment and go straight into the applied learning. We are fully supportive of that.
We know from the background here that in 2019 the Victorian government commissioned John Firth, a former CEO of the Victorian Curriculum and Assessment Authority, to conduct a review titled Review into Vocational and Applied Learning Pathways in Senior Secondary Schooling, which is known as the Firth review, and I will come back to that. The Firth review found that we need to do more to make vocational and applied learning in schools high quality, highly regarded, relevant to the needs of students and employers, and available to all. Again I emphasise we all want to see senior secondary students receive a great education, learn about the world of work and develop strong life skills so they can make informed choices about further study, jobs and their futures. This will enable young people to contribute and benefit from the growth in the Victorian economy and prepare them for active and fulfilling lives within the community. Again I refer all members in this place to the senior secondary pathways reform task force report, particularly the sections that talk about excellent senior secondary education for all students, setting students up for the future and skills for the modern economy. It is a great document, and I recommend all those who have a keen interest in education outcomes have a read and familiarise themselves with this document.
At the very end of my contribution I will summarise the changes here in layman’s terms so people can understand, but in this document on page 3 there is a very good time line from 2020 right through to 2025 when we have the introduction of a fully integrated senior secondary certificate. So for people that want to know how this will work and be implemented and transition over the next five years, that is an excellent part of that document, as is the section on supporting all students to stay engaged in education and training. We do not want people dropping out of the system because they have not got the right pathways to follow.
I had this discussion with a number of people. I am all for people doing maths/science courses. I am all for people pursuing VCE and getting an ATAR score. But we also recognise that not everyone wants to do that, and we want to keep students or support them in staying engaged in education and training. So it is important that we support all of them to be engaged in school and to accomplish their goals, and these sorts of pathways give students other options where they might not want to pursue the others for various reasons. The document also has a great section on providing students with the skills employees need. I did mention that, and I re-emphasise that. We hear this constantly about having people job ready, being able to apply their skills and learning as soon as they get into the workforce, and I think in lifting these standards and supporting this bill we have got the opportunity to see that delivered into the future.
There are a number of key recommendations in the report, but the main ones I think are about lifting the quality and consistency of vocational and applied learning for Victorian students. We are fully supportive of that. We want to see more efficient delivery so all students can access vocational and applied learning, and we want to see stronger support to schools reinforced by stronger accountability for delivery.
The other one I mentioned was the actual final report of the Review into Vocational and Applied Learning Pathways in Senior Secondary Schooling—again, a very interesting report to read. I think from memory there were something like 38 or so recommendations. I just want to put on record a quote from John Firth, who is the author of the report, because it sums up what all of us think about and support for our educators. In his message from the review, John Firth said:
I was, yet again in my long experience in Victorian education, mightily impressed by the capacity of so many teachers, school leaders, support staff, VET trainers and others who work with young people in a wide variety of settings throughout the state.
And I am fully supportive of that. We owe a lot to our educators and the terrific work they do, the challenges they face, and I think John Firth in his report sums that up very well.
Having spent the first part of my contribution talking about those reports and thanking a few people, let us get to the details of the bill, make a few comments on the purpose, the main provisions and some areas we had a look at and just summarise why we are supporting the bill and then the framework for how this will be implemented. A key purpose of the bill is to amend the Education and Training Reform Act 2006 to introduce a new Victorian pathways certificate, the VPC, and vocational major within the Victorian certificate of education, the VCE, into Victoria’s senior secondary education system. This new certificate framework will replace the Victorian certificate of applied learning—VCAL. The bill also amends the Education and Training Reform Act to enable the Victorian Registration and Qualifications Authority (VRQA) to extend the transition period of superseded training products beyond 12 months. The main purpose of the bill is to amend the Education and Training Reform Act 2006. As is outlined in the bill, there is (a), (b), (c) and (d), and I will just put those on record:
to provide for new foundation secondary courses and foundation secondary qualifications …
to provide for transitional arrangements regarding the Victorian Pathways Certificate and the vocational major within the VCE …
the purpose of the bill is actually very simple and straightforward, but a large part of the bill is about all those transition arrangements, and that is the part that can be a bit difficult to get your head around, but I have confidence that that will be done right—
to enable the Victorian Registration and Qualifications Authority to extend the 12 month period regarding an RTO’s management of the transition from superseded training packages; and
to provide VCAT with power to review a decision of the Victorian Registration and Qualifications Authority to extend the 12 month period regarding an RTO’s management of the transition from superseded training packages.
By way of background, and I have touched on it a little bit already, in November 2019 the Firth report was commissioned to make recommendations for review with two key aims: to ensure all Victorian secondary school students have access to high-quality vocational and applied learning options and to look to ways to improve transitions for students between school, post-secondary education and work. This review into vocational and applied learning pathways in senior secondary schooling was undertaken by the former CEO of the Victorian Curriculum and Assessment Authority, John Firth—hence the Firth review, and I have made reference to that and encourage people to have a good look at that report. In November 2020 the Victorian government received the final report of the Firth review and accepted in principle all the recommendations of the review. The recommendations provide the framework for the senior secondary pathways reform agenda, which aims to improve the skills and work readiness of young people. Again we are back to that work readiness that we all know is so important so that people can get out and apply their learning, get into the jobs and not have to be re-taught or retrained on the work site.
The introduction of the new vocational major within the VCE and VPC will acquit recommendations 1 to 10 from the Firth review. Students will be able to enrol in a vocational major within the VCE from 2023, and this will replace the existing VCAL at the intermediate and senior levels as we move towards a single, integrated senior secondary certificate by 2025. I will come back to the timetable, but again, as I have mentioned, there is a good example of a timetable on the websites because people have a lot of interest in this and what is going to happen over 2020, 2021, 2022, 2023 and 2025 as we get there. Again for those who want to know how this will be implemented and transitioned, I encourage them to have a good look at that timetable.
I wanted to talk about the main provisions. There are a couple of things to get through here, but the bill sets out the details for the introduction of the new certificate framework. The bill inserts new definitions of ‘VPC’, ‘foundation secondary course’ and ‘foundation secondary qualifications’ to make provision for the VPC. The new definitions are consistent with the current definitions in the Education and Training Reform Act 2006, but specifically this bill introduces new definitions of a foundation secondary course and foundation secondary qualifications to follow the Victorian pathways certificate, the VPC. It allows the Victorian Registration and Qualifications Authority, the VRQA, to register the VPC on the state register and register providers to deliver the course, and the Victorian Curriculum and Assessment Authority, the VCAA—lots of terms and acronyms in the department—to award the qualification. It enables the supported transition of providers and students to the new certificate scheme in time for it to commence in 2023 and creates offences for providing or offering to provide the new type of course or awarding or offering to award the new type of qualification without registration.
Again, just out of personal interest, that was an area we a had a bit of discussion on at the bill briefing. Fortunately I do not think there are many offences, or certainly the department reps could not alert us to many offences there, but that provision is there in case it is needed. It allows the VRQA to extend the transition period of superseded training packages beyond 12 months where it is satisfied that there would be a disadvantage to students if the extension were not granted or where exceptional circumstances exist. Again, that is to do with those transitional arrangements in implementing these changes. It provides the Victorian Civil and Administrative Tribunal, VCAT, with the power to review a decision of the VRQA to extend the transition period of superseded training packages beyond 12 months. Finally, the bill amends the Education and Training Reform Act to give the VRQA power to extend the transition period for superseded courses beyond the current 12-month period, either on application or on the VRQA’s own initiative. These powers are consistent with those of the Australian Skills Quality Authority and the Western Australian Training Accreditation Council and will ensure that students of VRQA-regulated registered training organisations are not unfairly disadvantaged relative to students of ASQA- and WATAC-regulated RTOs. I hope Hansard was able to get all that—the acronyms. Look, there are a lot of acronyms and things, but the bill explains all those and what they are. Again, it takes a bit of time just to get your head around how that will work.
There are a couple of areas that we examined in detail, that we had a closer look at and scrutinised. Questions were certainly raised about the preparation, the transition arrangements and the readiness of students to enrol in a vocational major within the VCE from 2023. We know that, particularly over the last couple of years under the disruptions of the coronavirus pandemic, a lot of schooling has been disrupted and students have had uncertainty and disruptions to their schooling, so we wanted to try to assure ourselves. I am sure they will be ready, but going forward how can there be some confidence and certainty that students will be able to enrol? 2023 is not that far away, so at the bill briefing we did ask some questions about that. At the bill briefing the department representative stated that there was still considerable work being undertaken in this area, as I expect there would be. Students, as I said, need the certainty, they need to have confidence in a smooth implementation and transition process. We will watch that with interest because we think these changes are terrific; they are great. They are going to support and lift the whole applied learning status, so we want them to work, and it will be really important over that time line, from now right through to 2025, that we get all this right.
The reforms also aim to improve the skills and work readiness of young people by lifting the quality and perception of vocational training outcomes, and we strongly support that. You know, people will have their own views on the value of ATAR and VCE and people choosing other pathways. I have got a diesel mechanic in the family, a carpenter and one still to head through the school pathways. They have had great pathways through; they got into trades and got really great careers and jobs. Other children have pursued the VCE option. So choice is valuable. We are fully supportive of these reforms that aim to improve the skills and work readiness of young people by lifting that quality and perception of vocational training. Anything we can do on this side of the house to support that we will get behind, because we think that is very, very important. We do know, however, that the proof of the pudding is in the eating. We want to see this, how it is delivered and if it achieves all it is aiming to achieve. We will watch and see, but we are certainly supporting it.
As always with these things it is important to gauge the views of stakeholders, and we were able to do that. We have a long list of stakeholders in the education database that we write out to, and we appreciate their views. We ask for their views and opinions and we get feedback—not from all, but it is an important process when bills come to this house. We members do not have all the ideas or the thoughts on those. We like to get out and engage with the industry, engage with the education providers in the sector and engage with business and ask their opinions on this legislation. Pleasingly, we received no opposition to the bill from any of the stakeholders and, as I said, that is an important process for us to go through. That is why we are supporting the bill: for everything I have said in my contribution to this debate, for our engagement with stakeholders and for the importance we place on education and having options and choices and pathways for our students. The bill responds to the recommendations of a review where major stakeholders supported changes to improve the quality and consistency of vocational and applied learning for secondary school students. Again, as I said at the outset and I continue to say, we all want our schools to provide quality education and access to high-quality programs, and we will always support that. We support senior secondary pathways that aim to improve the skills and work readiness of young people, therefore we are supporting a vocational pathway that provides students with the skills they need to progress on to further training and/or indeed jobs in the workforce.
I want to conclude by talking about both the time line and, in layman’s terms, how this practically works. I do again thank Paul Frame. I had a look at this bill. We thought it might come on last sitting week and it did not, so it allowed us an extra week. But we sort of set it aside for that week, and so when I turned my attention back to it again, I was just getting my head around it and collecting my thoughts around how it would operate. I did touch base with Paul Frame yesterday, and Paul was terrific in getting me the information that was required. I do not think he has got carriage of this bill for the minister’s office, but he was terrific in getting that back.
I did want to place on record how this will work so that people are clear in their minds about what the changes are and how they will be implemented. But first, if I can just touch on the time line. 2020, as I said, saw the release of the Firth review recommendations. 2021 saw the design and development of new certificates and curriculum. 2022 will see the release of final certificate designs and there will be a new curriculum in early 2022. 2023 will see the first enrolments in the vocational specialisation and foundation pathways certificate, and then as we get to 2025 all Victorian schools will deliver the fully integrated senior secondary certificate. It does sound like a long period of time but, as we all know, a few years will pass very quickly and, before you know it, it will be 2025 and these changes will be implemented.
To summarise, the VCE remains the name of the high school certificate. The new certificate framework includes two new senior secondary options. We have the Victorian pathway certificate—the VPC that I have been referring to—which is basically year 10 foundation level. Those that then go on will do the vocational major in the VCE. Some will opt just to complete the VPC, but that is that pathway, if you like. The VPC will replace foundation VCAL and is designed to support students to transition either to the VCE or to entry-level VET or employment. The VPC provides an additional pathway option for vulnerable students at risk of leaving education and students with additional needs.
Again I go back to the point I made earlier in my contribution: for people that do not want to pursue the VCE or a maths/science course or university for whatever reasons, rather than dropping out of the system, this gives them a strong pathway of options to follow. I talked about a few examples where people complete a level of school and go and join the family business or pursue other forms of employment that do not require the ATAR, do not require VCE and do not necessarily require some of those subjects, and I think we need to support those students to remain in and engage in the education system to deliver better outcomes and not necessarily drop off.
As I said, the VPC will replace the foundation VCAL and is designed to support students to transition either to the VCE or to entry-level VET or employment. The VPC provides an additional pathway option for vulnerable students at risk of leaving education and students with additional needs. The vocation major within the VCE is a new two-year vocational pathway program that will replace intermediate and senior VCAL and will be embedded in the VCE system.
In summary, or to finish my contribution, applied learning is valuable. We all know that. We all recognise that. We want to see the status, if you like, of applied learning. We are all for lifting that status and getting behind that. As I have continually said, not everyone wants to pursue a particular path, so this gives other options. The focus and emphasis here are very much on skills and work readiness, which we are supportive of, so the Education and Training Reform Amendment (Senior Secondary Pathways Reforms and Other Matters) Bill 2021 is an important bill.
I finish by saying again that I have really enjoyed the process of reading the Firth report and the other document that I mentioned, with the support of the valuable information that the library were able to provide and given my own experiences with MECS, the Mount Evelyn Christian School, and with Ranges TEC—and I mentioned Ric Thorpe and all the terrific work that he does there in Lilydale, in the member for Evelyn’s electorate. I have visited there, and they do some terrific work. As these changes are implemented over the next few years and we transition into these new arrangements, I look forward to going back and visiting organisations like Ranges TEC and many, many others across Victoria and seeing the terrific outcomes that education pathways has provided in supporting our kids in education.
Ms ADDISON (Wendouree) (10:01): I too am pleased to rise and speak on the Education and Training Reform Amendment (Senior Secondary Pathways Reforms and Other Matters) Bill 2021 as we continue in our commitment to making Victoria the Education State and transforming Victoria’s education system. I wish to thank the Minister for Education and the Minister for Training and Skills in the other place for the work that has gone into the development of this significant bill. Thank you to the hardworking ministerial officers, especially Alice Jordan-Baird and Liam Attoe, for the great job they do, as well as the Department of Education and Training for the work that has gone into the preparation of this bill.
I would like to thank the Minister for Education for the massive investment being made in schools across the electorate of Wendouree, including Ballarat High School, Ballarat Specialist School, Mount Rowan college, St Patrick’s College and Delacombe, Forest Street, Black Hill, Alfredton, Macarthur Street, Newington, Dana Street and Caledonian primary schools. Across Ballarat we have so many excellent schools, and this is because of the outstanding leadership of our principals and the high-quality teachers and support staff—thank you for going above and beyond our expectations to keep our school communities connected and our students engaged during remote learning.
I would also like to just make quick mention of Alfredton Primary School and their community. It was required to close yesterday after someone with a positive case of COVID attended the school on Thursday. These are challenging times not only for our teachers and our students but for our broader school community. I hope that everyone at Alfredton Primary School is going well, and I wish them all the best for the remainder of term 4.
I am very pleased that the opposition is supporting this bill, and I thank the member for Croydon for his detailed explanation of the bill. Thank you very much for that. We know that Victoria’s economy is rapidly changing and that many of the occupations that will be required in the future do not even exist yet. We need to futureproof our kids by ensuring students of today develop and build the skills and capabilities to fulfil the jobs of tomorrow. I want students to thrive in their learning environment so they can embrace education and training opportunities that will lead to fulfilling careers that they can enjoy and gain satisfaction from, and I am sure the member for Bayswater agrees with me very much.
Mr Taylor: Absolutely.
Ms ADDISON: Thank you. I believe the introduction of this bill will help facilitate this. Last year the Minister for Education announced that VCAL will be merged with the VCE. By introducing the Education and Training Reform Amendment (Senior Secondary Pathways Reforms and Other Matters) Bill 2021 we are creating a single Victorian certificate of education, which will make it easier for students to get a range of skills, both vocational and academic. I welcome that senior school secondary providers and other education sector stakeholders, including the Catholic Education Commission of Victoria, Independent Schools Victoria and the Victorian Association of State Secondary Principals, are supportive of the proposed senior secondary pathways reforms in this bill.
Senior secondary education is about developing and realising every student’s potential, and our Victorian certificate of education, the VCE, is world class. The changes being proposed in this bill will ensure that students who are able to complete the VCE do so. I am showing my age, but I am proud to share that I was a member of the very first cohort to undertake and complete the VCE in 1992—and it has served me well to date. A number of changes have occurred since the origin, including the introduction of the Victorian certificate of applied learning in 2003 by Labor Minister for Education and Training Lynne Kosky. Lynne considered the introduction of VCAL as one of her greatest achievements, as it was a hands-on alternative to the Victorian certificate of education. Over the last 18 years VCAL has provided a stepping stone for many students into further education and training as well as jobs in industry.
I worked for Lynne in the Altona electorate office in 1998. She was an incredible role model and a generous and supportive mentor. As someone who grew up in the western suburbs, Lynne attended the University of Melbourne, trained to be a social worker and worked as a community education officer in Sunshine. Lynne knew the transformative power of education from her own lived experience. In a speech made to this place 9 February 2006 during her time as Minister for Education and Training, the Honourable Lynne Kosky said:
Of all the factors that have the potential to increase an individual’s opportunities, education and training is the most enabling. It allows individuals to equip themselves to live fulfilling, productive and satisfying lives.
Minister Kosky went on to say:
A quality education and training system does not respond only to contemporary needs and issues; it should also identify and anticipate future needs and challenges.
It is a fundamental community and social glue, while being a bridge to a more prosperous and harmonious future.
And I must say that I agree.
Lynne was so proud when I went on to become a teacher, as she valued education and the teaching profession so highly. As Minister for Education and Training, Lynne strongly supported legislative reform for vocational training, and 18 years after VCAL was first introduced, I am proud that we are continuing to ensure that Victoria’s education system meets the academic and vocational needs and expectations of our community in the 21st century.
This bill will replace VCAL with the Victorian pathways certificate, the VPC, and the Victorian certificate of education vocational major. The bill enables a new certificate scheme by providing for a separate VPC which will replace foundation VCAL, and for the intermediate and senior VCAL to be integrated into the VCE. There will be a clear delineation between the VCE and the VPC. As a secondary school teacher for over a decade, a parent of two school-age children and the wife of a tradesperson, I am very pleased that Victorian students will be able to access vocational specialisation streams within the VCE from 2023. Importantly, these changes will enhance the education skills development of Victorian students by enabling access to an increased range of curriculum options, including a combination of subjects that are currently restricted to our VCE or VCAL students.
By establishing a single senior secondary certificate incorporating VCAL into VCE, we are preparing our senior students for success beyond the school gate by creating opportunities for them to shape their own future, determine their next chapter and follow their dreams. I think it is very important that we remind ourselves of the Liberal-Nationals approach to vocational education and training when they were last in power. In 2012 the Victorian Liberal-Nationals coalition, under the leadership of Premier Ted Baillieu, made large funding cuts of $300 million to the Victorian TAFE public education system, a major deliverer of VCAL courses for young and mature-age students, and cut funding to secondary school VCAL programs. This resulted in students being unable to access many courses and job losses for VCAL providers for secondary schools.
I am proud that the Andrews Labor government has not only rebuilt our TAFE sector but introduced free TAFE. This initiative is not only delivering a modern, skilled workforce but changing lives. I must say that I was very pleased to hear the shadow minister committing his ongoing support to vocational training in Victoria. That is really pleasing to hear.
To our senior secondary students who have faced a very challenging and disrupted final two years due to the global pandemic, I would like to express my absolute admiration to you. I wish all our year 12 students, who have navigated their final years like no other cohort, all the best for their final assessments and exams. And as someone who taught some of these students when they were in years 7 and 8, I have a very strong vested interest in their wellbeing and success. I could not be prouder of our students across Ballarat and Victoria. Your best times are still to come, and the future is whatever you want to make it.
In concluding, the Education and Training Reform Amendment (Senior Secondary Pathways Reforms and Other Matters) Bill 2021 will give all students the learning opportunities to develop the skills and capabilities needed to achieve positive outcomes in further education and vocational training that will lead to sustainable employment and fulfilled careers. I welcome this bill, I commend it to the house and I am so pleased that we are going to have a next generation of amazingly supported and educated young people entering our workforce and building an even better, stronger Victoria.
Ms BRITNELL (South-West Coast) (10:11): I rise to speak on the Education and Training Reform Amendment (Senior Secondary Pathways Reforms and Other Matters) Bill 2021, which basically is a bill that is going to provide transitional arrangements regarding the Victorian pathways certificate and vocational major within the VCE and enable the Victorian Registration and Qualifications Authority to extend the 12-month training period regarding a registered training organisation’s management for the transition from superseded training packages. It is a bill that we very much support, and you have heard it outlined in a detailed manner by my colleague the Shadow Minister for Education, the member for Croydon. I would like to take this opportunity to discuss some of the issues in the education system which I think this bill is trying to address, and I endorse that approach and I absolutely embrace this opportunity.
The Firth review, which the minister referred to in his second-reading speech, identifies that one of the principles that this change in the legislation will address is lifting the quality and perception of vocational education. I want to highlight that point because I think what we have got is something in society that we seriously need to address, and I hope this bill begins to address that. I think for the last at least four decades we have been going down a pathway of not celebrating the diversity of skills our children have when they are in an education facility. We have been very academically leaning, and we have been encouraging our kids to strive—and that is all very well—but at the expense, I think, of recognising that striving also includes the professions that require skills as well as academia to be successful in. So what I am saying is that over the last 40 years I think we have gone away from celebrating and valuing people whose skills are around using their hands or being able to have great interaction with other people, supporting and helping them. We have used our education system as a platform to just make people think—children in particular, and parents—that unless you are academic, unless you are going to do very well in VCE and unless you are heading over to university institutions, you are not successful. And that is a real worry, because what we are doing is making those children who are not able to absorb information in a written form and then regurgitate that information, showing that they understand it in an exam technique format, feel like failures. That is what I am seeing: our children who are not highly successful in academia are falling out of the system and sometimes feeling like failures. So this opportunity that we have here to embrace VCAL and to embrace vocational education and highlight it as equal to the academia of getting an ATAR score is highly important, and I cannot push this enough.
I remember when I was young, and of my two brothers and my sister and I—it was a family of four—the boys were deemed dumb and the girls were deemed smart because boys often mature later. Now, I do not know whether that is a fact or not, but it certainly seems like my experience. My brothers both became very successful, having left school, one in year 9at 15 and the other in year 10 or 11—year 11, I think. They were very much unable to cope from a reading and writing perspective too well. They would probably hate me saying that. Both went on to become very successful. I remember my brother at 19 said, ‘I want to be a policeman’. He started learning to spell properly. He asked for my help. I used to ride my bike and he used to run beside me and I would say, ‘Spell hospital; spell whatever’, and help him along. He is a very successful detective today. So is my other brother, who ran a business and left school at 15, as I said.
Now, I remember my eldest son coming home and saying to me at about the age of 15—and please excuse my French, because these are his words, not mine—‘Mum, if you don’t go to university, you’re a dumbass’. Yes, I know, he should not have even said that to his mother at such an age, but he did. I remember thinking, ‘Where did that come from?’. It certainly did not come from his parents, it did not come from our family unit, but it is the culture. Now, I absolutely am very proud of all people who do well in what they choose to do in life. I always talk about the bus driver that got my kids home and to school safely every day, the most important person in my life. We should be celebrating these professions, and when kids in school want to become a bus driver or a personal care attendant and look after an ageing community in an aged-care facility, for example, or become that barista that you say hello to every morning that makes your day because they are bright and they are sparky and they are happy and they start your day off well, these people are incredibly important too.
I ran a farm for a very long time and spent a lot of time trying to encourage people into the profession of agriculture—and it is a profession, and it is a really important profession, to actually create food that is of a high quality and a high standard. People who want to become farmers often are very intelligent and very capable at recognising grass species and soil types, and you learn as you go. I mean, I just did endless education, and it was relevant, so it was interesting. And that is the theme we have got to give our kids that understanding of: you will love what you learn. If you want to become a bus driver, you need skills to make sure you understand the road rules, to make sure you understand safety, to make sure you have a rapport with children. These are skills that we need to make sure we embrace. The schools through vocational education and training processes can really embrace this, but I think the culture we have in the schools—and I am not denigrating the teachers in any way, shape or form—is simply the culture as a society we have been going down the line of, so I hope this provides a fantastic opportunity to really change that, and I hope the government uses this opportunity to address that culture.
We have addressed diversity in the workplace. We have addressed bullying in the workplace. We have addressed family violence through campaigns. I actually think we need a campaign to embrace vocational education and training and show those children that do not want to go on to academia that they are valued and they are valuable, so our system then actually creates an environment of equality for all types of diverse learning skills. In our region we have tried to embrace this opportunity through many things, like the Hands On Learning program that the Warrnambool College have, led by Leon Carey, a great tradesman in our area who is very community minded. Then at Brauer College we have got Bruce Miller, who also runs a similar program. They actually grab those kids who are falling out of the system and actually getting into a little bit of trouble sometimes because they are not engaged properly because what they like to do is not understood. They have created a program where they can build stuff, repair stuff, help our community by doing things like tables and chairs for community areas at the beach or the parks. These kids love it, but trying to get funding for those programs out of the Department of Education and Training has been nigh impossible. That tells me that the government have not really understood that we need to embrace that diversity of skills. So I hope we will also see these programs that have been created to fill that void, to fill that gap and to help these kids stay engaged really be embraced and funded properly.
The other program that has come about from the community recognising this problem is the program that is funded and called the Neil Porter foundation. It is run by a young man, Matt Porter, whose father was a teacher who it is named after, who really did recognise the importance of this sort of work. It is funded a lot and supported incredibly by David Hetherington from Pacific Materials Handling and many other companies such as Midfield Meat, and Dean McKenna has been a big promoter of this program. They are going into the school, getting the kids and showing them the industries that you can get into and the careers. It is really helping because the government are not funding careers teachers in such a way that they can focus on career planning and promotion. It is sort of a secondary role that they have as a teacher, and then that is tacked on as a career teacher. I hope the government takes the opportunity to run a campaign to promote vocational education and the value of it and the value of the students who take that on, because I tell you what, I cannot fix my own toilet, I cannot tile my own roof and I cannot look after my elderly mum all the time. I need people in the community with those skills, which are very valued. So I commend all the people in my community who have also recognised this as a challenge. Let us get behind our kids and tell them all how valued they are because everybody has a role to play. Those ones we lose out of the system that end up sitting on the couch, that never go through the milestones of work—it is our responsibility, it is our fault and we can do better.
Now, I just want to finish by saying that does not mean I do not value the importance of academia, and I did talk about it being part of equality. We are about 15 days away from the end of the year 12 school year, and that means the English exam on 27 October is quite soon. So I want to take this opportunity to congratulate them all, who have done so well—good luck with your exam. It is not the be-all and end-all; it does not define you. Good luck.
Ms HORNE (Williamstown—Minister for Ports and Freight, Minister for Consumer Affairs, Gaming and Liquor Regulation, Minister for Fishing and Boating) (10:21): It gives me great pleasure to rise to speak on the Education and Training Reform Amendment (Senior Secondary Pathways Reforms and Other Matters) Bill 2021, and I would like to particularly congratulate the Minister for Education and the Minister for Higher Education in the other place for bringing on such a critical piece of legislation that really builds on what this government’s legacy has been in focusing on education from the inception of this government until now.
As you would be aware, the Andrews Labor government is absolutely committed to improving our state’s education system and retaining our reputation as the Education State, and this bill before Parliament puts us further down the path to achieving that. As you would be aware, my pathway to choosing to become a member of Parliament was absolutely based in being passionate about education. I am the daughter of two teachers. Both were high school teachers and taught in the public education system, and they have really instilled in me the values that I hope I demonstrate today and are so important to public education—of public service, of contribution and of responsibility. As I said, they are values that I try and live every day of my life, and I hope I instil them in my children as well.
I sent both of my kids to the local public school, and I will always stand up for our students in Victoria to secure better opportunities and educational outcomes. As I mentioned, before I entered Parliament the catalyst for deciding to stand for preselection and then ultimately becoming elected was about community activism in our space. As you would be aware, under the Kennett government Footscray High was closed down and sold off, and that left a dearth of opportunities for kids in the western suburbs to attend a local public high school. In fact at that time our kids in the inner west had further to travel to their local public high school than any other children in metropolitan Melbourne. So working with the then Shadow Minister for Education, now the Minister for Education, working with the then member for Footscray, Marsha Thomson, and also the then member for Williamstown, Wade Noonan, and being president of a local community group called SKYHigh, very conveniently named for Seddon, Kingsville and Yarraville, we built a campaign of community activism that had hundreds and hundreds of parents in their local area to lobby for a new public high school.
But not only was it a new public high school, it ended up becoming, thanks to the Andrews Labor government, the first of its type of school in Victoria and I think in fact in Australia—the Footscray Learning Precinct. Now, the Footscray Learning Precinct has pulled together all three tiers of education. We have partnered with Maribyrnong City Council to deliver early learning programs. We have then got a seamless transition that goes into our primary school system and our secondary school system. Then there are opportunities to partner with Victoria University—again, a massive legacy. My friend and colleague the member for Wendouree pointed out that it was part of Lynne Kosky’s view to be able to have that seamless transition for kids in the western suburbs to move from that early learning through to tertiary education and have that continuum along the way. As I said, never before has this been done, and it is incredibly exciting to have been part of that journey and also to be seeing my kids and so many of my children’s peers flourish in that environment.
I would like to give a particular shout-out to the executive principal, Frank Vetere, who has overseen the development of this school. I think it will be a fantastic legacy for both Marsha Thomson and also Wade Noonan to have seen something like this come to fruition, because that is what this government is all about. It is about saying that every student in every school deserves to have high-quality education, including vocational and applied learning options. And the Education State reflects our focus on excellence and equity by reducing that disadvantage in Victorian schools and equipping students with skills necessary to succeed in their careers and lives.
I would like to pick up on the point that the member for South-West Coast actually made earlier in her contribution on this, which was around having an education system that values kids of all abilities, not necessarily just those who choose to tread an academic path. As I mentioned before in my contribution, my parents were public high school teachers. But they also, when they left the high school system, went and became teachers in the TAFE system in New South Wales. So having those values that really recognise the contribution that kids who are not necessarily academic can make—that they should not be stigmatised for not being academic but can choose another path and go on to make enormous contributions in so many other parts of what we need—is so critical. My parents were the first in their families to actually get a tertiary education, and that was done through teachers scholarships at the time. I think we have seen a continuum in my family of valuing education and being able to see how kids of all ages and all abilities can flourish under an education system that supports them and supports the different pathways that they go down.
Since 2018–19 this government has invested $315.5 million in reforming the senior secondary school system, which sets our kids up for the future. An important part of this was the $109 million to transform career education in Victorian government schools to help students make better career and pathway decisions and meet those demands of a changing, globalised job market. As I said, career education has never been more important than it is today for our young people. Since being elected in 2018 it has been one of my biggest joys to be able to advocate for local schools to get their fair share, and each state budget has achieved just that. For all stages of their school lives, kids in Williamstown have access to world-class facilities. These include a $600 000 Building Blocks capacity grant for the One Tree Altona North children’s centre; $3.8 million to upgrade Altona North Primary School’s learning and meeting spaces; $10.2 million for Wembley Primary School to modernise their main building and have new learning spaces; a $2.3 million investment package for sporting facilities at Bayside P–12 College; $6.7 million for Bayside P–12 College for upgraded labs and classrooms, including the maths and science blocks; $1.3 million to upgrade the year 12 study centre at Williamstown High School; a whopping $29 million for the construction of the Seddon junior secondary campus at the Footscray Learning Precinct; and so much more.
Ms Vallence: On a point of order, Deputy Speaker, I appreciate this has been a wideranging debate, but I would ask for you to bring the member back to the bill. It is not a budget reply; it is a speech on the Education and Training Reform Amendment (Senior Secondary Pathways Reforms and Other Matters) Bill. Could you bring her back to the bill?
The DEPUTY SPEAKER: Can the Minister for Consumer Affairs, Gambling and Liquor Regulation speak to the bill, please.
Ms HORNE: Well, thank you very much, Deputy Speaker. Look, I do feel it is important to recognise the massive contribution that the schools make in my electorate in providing children with a pathway for the future.
Mr TAYLOR (Bayswater) (10:31): It is with great pleasure that I rise in this house to speak on the Education and Training Reform Amendment (Senior Secondary Pathways Reforms and Other Matters) Bill 2021—that is a mouthful. It is always a great pleasure to rise in this place to talk about all things education. I am very proud to be a part of this Andrews Labor government, continually supporting the education sector and our educators, providing record investment and reforming where we can and where we see need for improvement. There was obviously work done by the Firth inquiry, and some of those key recommendations are discussed in this legislation.
Of course it would be remiss of me to not also start by saying a very big thankyou and giving acknowledgement not just to both ministers in this place and the other place but also to their hardworking staff and to the incredible people at the department, who have no doubt done a mountain of work. My sincere thanks to all of those involved in this incredibly important piece of reform that we are getting on with here today.
I note that there are some differences in politics and between parties—in this place we see that all exposed more often than we would like, but that is the reality of it—but it is very good and heartening to see wideranging support for this reform here today. It also reminds me that it was not too long ago when I was doing my VCE. It would have been great to have some of the options that are being discussed here—not just for me, perhaps, but also for many of my friends. It was only—what am I, 29 now—12 years ago, and for the member for Nepean it was probably a little bit later than it was for me. I can relate from a personal perspective to some of the reforms that this will result in, and I know they will be welcomed. Certainly from talking to—
Mr Fowles: Quit flaunting your youth over us.
Mr TAYLOR: Flaunting my youth, member for Burwood. I am 29 and my hair is out of control and receding at a rapid rate, so I am not sure many would agree with my supposed youth. But from talking to a number of principals and stakeholders across my community, I know this has certainly been welcomed. Obviously there is significant work ahead for them, for the department and for everyone involved, but it is certainly welcome all the same. It will mean young people right across this state can continue to get absolutely the best education in what we proudly call the Education State.
With a moment of indulgence I want to also pay tribute in this place—it has been some time since I have had the opportunity to speak on an education-related bill, such is the way of the world at the moment with COVID and Parliament et cetera—and put on record a sincere thankyou to our schools, to our school communities and to all of the young people all the way from kinder through to senior learning and TAFE and everything else in between. It has been an incredibly challenging period, we know, for some sectors of our workforce. Our frontline workers have done an amazing job, and I have always said healthcare workers and educators are two roles I would not want for quids. A really big thankyou to our principals and to our teachers and the families involved in our primary and secondary schools, because they have pivoted backwards and forwards, to and fro, and have done an incredible job of making sure that our kids still get a first-class education. And rightfully so—everyone deserves a right to a first-class education in this state, and that is in large part due to the significant and amazing work of every single educator and school principal and everyone else in between who has supported that work.
Of course we have seen some of the results. Look, I do not really subscribe to the idea that test results mean everything, but in some of the NAPLAN testing we saw some amazing results come out, and that is a great testament to the kids and to their families and to our educators in this state. I would like to say a massive thankyou to them. I am looking forward to having them back in school, with all kids moving back into school by early November, I believe from recollection, but transitioning this month. I know that there are so many looking forward to getting back into the classroom, seeing their mates. It is an incredibly exciting period as we get our community vaccinated and make sure that we mitigate as many of the concerns and risks as we can in our school environments, which we know can be, I guess, an exposure risk. But we are making sure we are hitting those targets and listening to the health and science on this to get our kids and our staff and everyone in between back into the classrooms as safely as possible.
I would just like to note as well that there is a school that has also taken the next step in helping get us back into the classrooms and helping to vaccinate the community in my local patch: Fairhills High School.
Mr Fregon interjected.
Mr TAYLOR: The member for Mount Waverley will know all about that.
Ms Vallence: On a point of order, Deputy Speaker, I appreciate that it is a wideranging debate and we are all in violent agreement about the education opportunities for our kids—
The DEPUTY SPEAKER: Can you state your point of order? Is it on relevance?
Ms Vallence: but the status of vaccination of our kids does not feature as part of this bill. I would ask that you bring the member back to the topic of and clauses within the bill.
The DEPUTY SPEAKER: It has been a wideranging debate, but the member for Bayswater did ask for the indulgence of the house to discuss teachers and the support for COVID measures, so I will ask him now to come back to the bill.
Mr TAYLOR: Thank you, Deputy Speaker. It certainly goes to the heart of some of the reforms here to be talking about one of my secondary schools in our local community. Fairhills High, as the member for Mount Waverley will be well aware, is an extremely well-established, much-loved and respected secondary school community in the part of the world that I represent very proudly. They recently helped to put together a vaccine pop-up over the weekend. Hundreds of people came down for their first and second AstraZeneca and Pfizer doses, so I just want to put on record my thanks to them. Principal Ian Van Schie came down and did a live video. He was remarkable. I of course was also remarkable. For those people who are reading Hansard and cannot quite tell if that was a joke, I will state that for the record. People can think I am a bit too confident as it is. Thank you so much to Fairhills High and to Ian and all of them for assisting in getting not just secondary students back in to do their certificates in person but also all of us back into the classrooms and back to doing the things that we love.
Of course we are here talking about, as I said, a really, really significant piece of reform. We know, as others have discussed in this place, it is very well supported by it seems all in this place, which is great to see. This bill will expand the powers of the Victorian Registration and Qualifications Authority, otherwise known as the VRQA, and the Victorian Curriculum and Assessment Authority, the VCAA, in the Education and Training Reform Act 2006 to create a new category of foundation secondary course and foundation secondary qualifications to accommodate the new Victorian pathways certificate and facilitate the transition to a new senior secondary education certificate framework, including a new vocational major within the Victorian certificate of education. It will also give the VRQA the power to extend transition periods for superseded training products, consistent with the powers of the Australian Skills Quality Authority and apparently the Western Australian Training Accreditation Council. There you go. You learn something new every day.
As I said, we are very proud to be the Education State, leading the way here in Victoria. We know that we want every single student in every school to have access to high-quality vocational and applied learning options. As we emerge from the pandemic and as our economy undergoes rapid change, the ability to provide a great education and relevant high-quality training for our workforce will be extremely critical to Victoria’s economic recovery and our future prosperity. That is why it is vitally important that our senior secondary system is best positioned to help students build the skills and capabilities to thrive in further education and training and move into rewarding careers.
One of the things that this bill that we are discussing here reminds me of is that there was this idea back when I was in school that everyone must study, must go on to university. I think we are slowly changing. In today’s world we are much better at understanding that not everyone has one single distinct pathway, and this legislation helps to address that. Locally, through the Bayswater education plan we are working with four great local primary schools—Bayswater Primary School, Bayswater North Primary School, Bayswater South Primary School, Bayswater West Primary School—and Bayswater Secondary College, and we have done some of this important work, working with industry, working with stakeholders through our massive jobs precinct. We are doing some of the early work here, which is in part discussed in this legislation, to link in secondary students to start that pathway—even in primary schools—linking them in with industry, with stakeholders, providing alternate pathways to make sure that kids can get the skills today for the jobs of tomorrow that they want.
This is incredibly important legislation. I am very proud to talk here on this government’s proud reform agenda, backing in education, making us truly the Education State.
Mr HIBBINS (Prahran) (10:41): I rise today to speak on the Education and Training Reform Amendment (Senior Secondary Pathways and Other Matters) Bill 2021, a bill which the Greens will be supporting. This bill is primarily making changes to the Education and Training Reform Act 2006, based on the recommendations of the Firth Review intoVocational and Applied Learning Pathways in Senior Secondary Schooling. These changes will see the current VCAL qualifications being brought into VCE as a vocational major as well as introduce the Victorian pathways certificate to replace the VCAL foundation course. There are also some technical changes that allow the Victorian Registrations and Qualifications Authority to register the VPC and provisions to support students and providers in the transition period. There are provisions also for the VRQA to extend the transition period of superseded training packages and for VCAT to review these extension decisions. The bill will also make it an offence to deliver these new courses without registration. The aim of these reforms is to improve the relevance and quality of vocational pathways as well as reduce the stigma that is associated with the VCAL programs, and certainly I very much support these objectives.
The Firth review found that there was inconsistency in the delivery and standard of VCAL across the state and that the program needed to be strengthened and broadened. It specifically recommended embedding vocational pathways into VCE to ensure that all students are provided with the same standard of education. Certainly whilst we need to make sure that we have the same standard of education for all our students, it is important that we do not just simply have a one-size-fits-all education system and that our schools cater for the widest range of students with varying interests, skills and pathways. We cannot just dress our students the same, teach them the same and expect them all to turn out the same. We need to make sure that we have an education system that caters for students and all the differences that they bring to their schooling.
I have heard from a range of stakeholders about these reforms, some of whom are really strongly supportive of the scheme and are looking forward to implementing the changes and others who certainly welcome the reform but are hesitant about some of the specifics and about the speed at which these changes are being implemented. There is some concern that removing the intermediate VCAL qualification will reduce job prospects for those who do not complete the two-year vocational major and instead leave with the enhanced certificate of attainment. It has also been raised with me that it is possible that only offering a two-year course could increase the year 10 dropout rates as some students may be reluctant to commit to a two-year program and would previously have chosen a single intermediate year and then decided to either continue their studies or move into work or further training.
I have also heard about how important it is for these reforms to safeguard applied learning principles. There is some concern about the curriculum design and that trying to fit vocational studies into a VCE-type template might not suit a number of students who choose this pathway, so it is crucial that young people continue to be consulted about the course offerings and the designs.
I have also heard concerns about the requirement that all educators who deliver the VPC and vocational major must be registered with the Victorian Institute of Teaching. Whilst I appreciate that appropriately qualified teachers are very important, some educators in the TAFE sector may have training and assessment qualifications rather than teaching degrees and there is a risk some wonderful mid- or late-career vocational teachers may not be able to deliver the vocational majors as they do not have the time or capacity to go back for a teaching degree.
Finally, it has been highlighted to me that it is vitally important that all education settings are given adequate time and resources to make sure that these reforms are successful across the entire state. Multiple people use the term ‘poor cousin’ to describe how VCAL has been regarded within the sector and how it has been underfunded and undervalued. These reforms provide a really great opportunity to give vocational and applied learning the space and resources required to ensure that students are provided with the best training and skills available to enter the modern workforce or proceed to further training, so let us make sure that this scheme is implemented carefully and that all schools and education providers, no matter where they are located across the state, are supported with time and resources to make the transition in a way that ensures its success for learners in Victoria.
Just more broadly on education, it is really important that students across our state are provided with high-quality education no matter where they live, what their background is or what their socio-economic status is and that teachers and schools have sufficient resources to deliver this. As many of us have struggled to provide home learning to our children this pandemic has really reminded us of just how valuable our teachers are, and we need to offer more than just thanks for or platitudes about their hard work in educating our young people. We need to thank teachers with higher wages, with properly resourced classrooms and with better conditions. That is how we can really demonstrate our thanks to them for their incredible work throughout the best part of the last two years. As we move beyond this pandemic and look to continue the recovery our society will need to embark on, what better value than investing in education by employing more teachers and more support staff so that all students—particularly those who are disadvantaged or vulnerable—have adequate support and opportunities for them to succeed at school.
I have said this before, and I will repeat it for the benefit of the chamber: Victoria’s public schools are underfunded by the tune of around a billion dollars a year—a billion dollars a year less than the Gonski school resource standard, so now is the perfect time for state and federal governments to increase funding to public schools. We have got one of the lowest per-student funding rates across the entire country and we will not reach parity with other states until late into this decade. This just is not good enough, so I would urge both the state and federal governments to revisit their school funding deal that leaves our public schools around a billion dollars short of what is required and invest even more in our public schools.
Further to our public schools, TAFE of course has always played an important role in delivering vocational training and applied learning. I am a former TAFE student myself—good old Frankston TAFE—and it is fair to say I certainly would not be here today if it was not for a quality, affordable TAFE system. I have got great memories of my time at Frankston TAFE, and I certainly would not be here today without it. We have got to continue to support our public TAFE system, make sure that its funding is guaranteed and not continue with this highly contested marketisation of our training system that has been such an abject failure. Whilst I really support the free TAFE courses being offered by the government, I think we need to go further and make it all free. You know, public education, from kinder to public schooling to TAFE, should be free. It should be quality and it should be free, and I think that is the goal and that is the vision that we should be aiming for here in Victoria and in fact right across country. With that, the Greens will be supporting this bill.
Mr FOWLES (Burwood) (10:50): It is my pleasure to rise and make a contribution around the somewhat verbosely titled, as others have alluded to, Education and Training Reform Amendment (Senior Secondary Pathways Reforms and Other Matters) Bill 2021. I would like to begin by thanking the Minister for Education’s office and the minister for his and their hard work on bringing this bill to the chamber and, going back, on initiating the Firth review and making sure—I guess, with the previous status of VCAL as a bit of a poor sibling of the VCE—that we move on from that situation and progress our education system to make sure that those who seek a more vocational secondary school certificate rank, pari passu, are part of the same system as those who have a more academic focus. It is a very important goal of this legislation and it is a very important goal of the government to make sure that students of all abilities with wide ranges of interests can access all of the options and all the educational support that they need.
I note with thanks the member for Croydon’s speech on this bill. He noted that there was no opposition from any of the stakeholders. He said the changes are terrific, they are great. He said that they strongly support them, and it is refreshing to have a situation in this place where opposition shadows come in and do not just ‘not oppose’ but in fact offer full-throated support to legislation. I thank the member for Croydon for his mature approach to this and his very sensible and constructive engagement on this particular topic.
Many members over the course of this debate have taken the opportunity to talk about matters in their own electorates. I will take the same opportunity. No doubt that will incur the wrath of the Shadow Minister for Industry at the table, but I will wait for the point of order and we will work through that tedium and then get on with the job. It is important to note that, when we think about vocational training and the breadth of offers, there is a school in my electorate in particular, Ashwood High, that has been able to do a fantastic job at broadening the number of subjects available to students there and making sure that those more vocational type subjects, the subjects that will sit in the VCAL framework until this reform is implemented, are available to students there.
I am in an unusual position. In my family one of my sons has, I think, a slightly unusual mix of being very academic but also very, very keen on studying agriculture, which, whilst far from unprecedented, is certainly an unusual combination. It is the case that there are some shortfalls in the current arrangements in terms of addressing his educational needs, and whilst these reforms will be implemented when he enters year 12, they are important reforms and reforms that would make a big difference to his educational journey. So I am very pleased that the government has taken on this very, very important area and has actually looked to make sure that there are options that we offer those kids who might be academic or might not to study things that sit outside that sort of conventional academic matrix: English, history, geography—you know, those conventional liberal arts type subjects—and the maths and science type subjects. Those who seek to have a more hands-on component to their secondary education are being accommodated in this bill.
What does the bill do? Well, it creates a new Victorian pathway certificate—and that is important; I will come to that in a moment—which I have referred to as this vocational major within the VCE. So that new framework will replace VCAL. Now, VCAL was a very important reform. It was a very good reform—it was a reform of the Bracks government back in 2002—and it was very important that we brought those vocationally minded kids, the ones who wanted to study those more hands-on type subjects, into the secondary school framework and gave them all of the opportunities that were being afforded to kids who were studying the more conventional academic route. Whilst I absolutely applaud the reform, it is now approaching 20 years old, and necessarily, given everything we have been through over the last 20 months, we have learned a lot about the delivery of education and the best way to do it.
I think because VCAL has serviced a narrower cohort it has attracted less attention and less resourcing and ultimately sits at something of a prestige deficit when compared with the VCE. This bill does away with that. It makes sure that irrespective of the type of subject you study within your VCE you still get a VCE and you get, as a result of further reforms in this bill, a statement of attainment that addresses all of those non-academic things you have studied as well as the academic ones. So I am pleased that the opposition is supporting this bill. I am pleased that they have taken that positive and constructive approach.
The genesis of the bill sits in the Firth review, and I thank Mr Firth for his work in addressing these things. He is a very senior specialist in this space, has a lot of domain expertise and has done a terrific job. This bill acquits, I think, from recollection, recommendations 1 and 10 of the Firth review, and we will have plenty more to say, no doubt, about other components of it. But by introducing the vocational major and the new Victorian foundation pathways certificate, which is now going to be known as just the Victorian pathways certificate, we really take a step forward in terms of the delivery of secondary education in this state and make sure that we are catering to students with all that breadth of ability.
The member for South-West Coast spoke very eloquently about the importance of those students who are less academically minded being catered for appropriately within the mainstream secondary education sector and not having to be educated at a different institution or via a different channel. And I think it is important, again, that we raise the prestige of those vocational courses within the VCE and make sure that they are delivered pari passu with the rest of the academic program contained in that certificate. I am pleased that the secondary school system remains a very clear focus of the government. It is something we have invested in very heavily. Despite the musings of the member for Prahran, we have invested very, very heavily in the education sector. It is part of Labor’s DNA to do so. I think the minister at the table, the Minister for Consumer Affairs, Gaming and Liquor Regulation, spoke beautifully about the importance of education and teaching both in her family experience growing up with parents as teachers but also in her lived experience with the shameful closure of Footscray High and the importance to that community of reinstating those educational options for those kids in the west. Of course it is only Labor that builds schools and does not close them down. It is only Labor that expands the educational footprint in Victoria rather than seeking to constrain it, and I am very pleased that this bill takes further steps towards that end.
This is a bill that will allow students who fully or partially complete vocational or applied learning type subjects to receive this enhanced statement of results. That is the statement that will provide a fuller picture of their strengths and capabilities, their achievements and the things that they have done as part of their Victorian certificate of education, because whilst the focus often is on that percentile ranking that pops out at the end of a VCE process, for many students that is not actually the primary consideration, and indeed for many students it is not really a consideration at all. What is more of interest to them, to their future study and decision-making and to future employers is what other things they have done on their educational journey, and I think it is absolutely terrific that we are making clear that those other things, those things that might not necessarily contribute to the computation of a percentile rank, are nonetheless available for that student to share with potential educators or employers and making clear that education is not solely about academic results, it is about a whole bunch of other things. They are things that Labor has always supported, has traditionally supported and will continue to support, because we understand the importance of vocational education, as evidenced by in particular our investment in free TAFE. But we understand the importance of vocational education in the secondary school setting. This is a bill that addresses that very real need, and it is my absolute pleasure to commend it to the house.
Ms EDWARDS (Bendigo West) (11:00): It is a pleasure to contribute to the debate on this important bill before the house today, the Education and Training Reform Amendment (Senior Secondary Pathways Reforms and Other Matters) Bill 2021. From the outset I would like to give a big shout-out to all of the principals, the teachers, the parents, the carers, the students and the school support staff in the school communities that I represent in Bendigo West, who have done an extraordinary job over the last 20 months in transitioning to home learning and back again and then back into home learning. It has been an extraordinary time, and I am just so proud that the schools in my electorate have done such an outstanding and amazing job.
This bill before the house today is a very important bill because it builds on this government’s—the Andrews Labor government’s—investment in and support for education across this state. I think when I look back over the last eight years that in the Education State of Victoria—which it now clearly is, which was our goal—the investment in and the improvements to education have just been unprecedented.
I note that the member for Wendouree mentioned that she was one of the first students in the intake of VCE students and was giving away her age somewhat. Well, just looking at this bill made me reflect on my time at school, and without giving away my age either, I did the HSC, so that is going back an awfully long way. Growing up in a small town like Maryborough, there were two options—you either went to the high school and did academic courses or you went to the tech school and you did hands-on trades courses. How things have changed since then. I reflect also on the pathways that my children have taken over the last couple of decades and the difference in the way that they have achieved their goals and gone on to their different careers. My eldest went to Dookie Agricultural College and got his degree there, my second child did a psychology degree at Latrobe Uni, my third went to TAFE and did a diploma in community services and disability and my youngest did an apprenticeship. I think when you reflect on the different pathways and opportunities available to students today, it is so, so different to what it was even just eight years ago.
We have increased funding for skills and training through our TAFE support. We have increased funding for apprentices. We have got better connection with industry and business for pathways, and in my electorate, we have the wonderful program called Passions and Pathways, which has been operating since 2012 and supported and funded by this government. It is run through the Goldfields Local Learning and Employment Network, and it is a partnership between the primary schools and workplaces which was conceived and nurtured right in Bendigo. And I know that the program has been a precedent for other very similar programs across the state. It is for year 6 students, and it is a partnership between the Goldfields Local Learning and Employment Network, as I mentioned, cross-sectoral primary schools, local governments and business. It gives students a taste of the world of work and fosters an appetite to succeed. The students engage with over 60 local businesses across the Bendigo region, and it gives those students an authentic experience of what they might like to do and what they aspire to do and reinforces the value of completing their education. The culture in our schools has changed so much over the last decade, and no one child has just one pathway to a future career. There are now so many opportunities for a broad range of subjects and skills that encourage students to think beyond what were traditional, and mostly academic, pathways.
This bill is really important because of one of the areas that I was really looking at—the support in this bill particularly for students with disability and additional needs and students with personal challenges. It is always challenging for students with disabilities and special needs to manoeuvre through the education system, to find that pathway that suits them. I know in my electorate Kalianna School has engaged heavily in the Victorian certificate of applied learning, in VCAL. Many of their year 12 and year 11 students take that VCAL pathway, and I know what a great benefit it is to those students to be able to do that. But this bill actually gives them opportunities to look for further opportunities and experience different ideas, different pathways. It recognises the skills and achievements of these students, who maybe are not ready to complete year 12 but can do the foundation pathways certificate, which is really important. Every year I get to attend the VCAL graduation for the Kalianna students, and it is such an exciting and proud moment for the teachers and the parents of those students, who achieve so much in that VCAL program.
The Firth review, which was commissioned by the government, made some significant recommendations. This came off the back of the need to make sure that all Victorian secondary students have access to high-quality vocational education and training and applied learning options. This bill, in implementing recommendations 1 and 10, will make sure that all the students have that access, that they will get the skills they need, and that, hopefully, will lead to further education and training—and ultimately the goal of course is for a great job and employment.
The Firth review also recommended that Victoria move to an integrated senior secondary certificate, with vocational education embedded in the VCE. In doing so, this certificate will replace the existing standalone VCAL certificate and thereby give all students the opportunity to develop both academic and practical skills.
There was significant consultation on this process. I heard the member for Croydon speaking about the time frame for the implementation, but this has also come off the back of extensive consultation over a two-year period during 2019 and 2020. That included consultation with students, families, teachers and with all of the schools, non-school senior secondary providers, peak bodies, industry and other key education stakeholders. Over the past year the department and the Victorian Curriculum and Assessment Authority have consulted widely with students and families and providers as well. This included more than 20 public consultations on various aspects of the process, including on the draft curriculum, the certificate name, the enhanced statement of results and the draft certificate designs. Throughout the consultation the department met directly with many organisations that would be impacted by these changes. The Victorian Curriculum and Assessment Authority held 11 targeted workshops with providers, including flexible learning providers, and over 3350 participants have attended a Victorian Curriculum and Assessment Authority webinar on certificate designs and the draft curriculum.
As I said, this bill builds on this government’s investment in and support for schools and training pathways. It is about ensuring that no matter where your child is from or what school they go to, they have the opportunity to make a choice—and that choice is between, obviously, learning a trade, a skill or further applied learning or choosing the academic path—but irrespective of what a child will choose, that they have the support, the encouragement and the investment from government to make sure that they have the best pathway for them. I think that our schools, our teachers and the principals across Victoria in our public sector, as well as in our independent and Catholic sectors, have a really good understanding now of what those pathways are. Reflecting on the Bendigo Education Plan, which I was pleased to chair, it is very clear that the schools in my electorate have a very good understanding of what opportunities are available to students, and this bill will make sure that those opportunities are extended. I commend the bill to the house.
Ms CONNOLLY (Tarneit) (11:10): I too rise to speak on the Education and Training Reform Amendment (Senior Secondary Pathways Reforms and Other Matters) Bill 2021. As someone who sits on the Scrutiny of Acts and Regulations Committee, that bill is quite a mouthful indeed, but probably rightly so, because this bill contains some really significant reforms. In essence this bill is all about providing greater opportunities for Victorian students. It is something that is really, really important to bring before this house, and it is something that I know my colleagues and indeed this government feel very strongly about.
Under our government, the Andrews Labor government, we have built Victoria as the Education State, and that is because we all strongly believe that our kids deserve the very best access to a high-quality education system. And I always say that with a smile because I have to reflect that each and every time I talk to my mum—and I talk to her on a daily basis—she will tell me that she has been speaking with her sister or her brother or other family members and she talks about how fantastic and how proud she is that she has got grandchildren who are in Victoria and being educated in our great Education State. It is quite funny because she always refers to Victoria as ‘the Education State’ even though my mum and all of her children—my siblings and I—were educated in New South Wales. She feels proud that her grandchildren will get an excellent, first-class education here in Victoria.
I have stood before this house on many occasions and indeed on a regular basis out in my electorate to talk about how no child’s opportunities should be defined by their postcode. Regardless of what side of the West Gate Bridge you happen to ride your bike around in the neighbourhood you grow up in, you should have the same opportunity as kids who are in other postcodes right across this state. And I say that kids in the outer west deserve just as great an education as those in the inner west and indeed in those wealthier, leafier eastern suburbs.
Now, if we are talking about the Education State, we often talk about the incredible infrastructure build that this government is getting on and delivering. You only have to look 30-odd kilometres west into Tarneit to see the record infrastructure investment that is happening right now in the outer west in my electorate of Tarneit. In the last four years alone we have seen four new schools open in my electorate, and we have got another five schools at the very least in the pipeline. What makes me very happy is to think that in this year’s budget we announced funding to go ahead and acquisition land for the much-needed but always very elusive high school in Tarneit. And I say to anyone in my electorate listening right now: this is not going to be a senior school, this is a years 7 to 12 high school, a proper high school, that we are going to get on and deliver in Tarneit. Also in this budget we announced funding for construction of a much-needed school in Truganina, another high school for years 7 to 12 for kids in Trug. This is really important because in upcoming years the population in Tarneit alone is set to go to 81 000 people. Tarneit and Truganina are two of the fastest growing suburbs in this state and sit within one of the largest growth corridors here in this country. The investment into schools like these high schools—and we are getting on and delivering so many new primary schools, with kinders attached, I might also add—is what investment by Labor governments looks like. That is what investment in the outer west by this government looks like.
Now, we talk about the importance of building new schools—and that is a conversation that I have on a daily basis—but it is also really important to go ahead and invest in the schools that already exist, and there are a lot in my electorate. There are also a lot of schools that are looking pretty tired or indeed in need of a major upgrade and face lift to get them to standard. It makes me very proud when I think about the importance of getting on and also looking after and investing in already existing schools. I think about two, and I do not have favourites, but they are schools that are very close to my heart because I have spent so much time there and spent a lot of time with the principals, who are like pit bulls in delivering better facilities and services for local kids. They are The Grange P–12 College and Hoppers Crossing Secondary College. Each of these schools has received very close to or just over $10 million worth of major upgrades that will change the facilities and infrastructure in Hoppers Crossing. That has been well overdue. That is what Labor governments do, and I know that kids are sitting in classrooms now that are already upgraded at The Grange or are sitting in classrooms that will very soon be upgraded at Hoppers Crossing. This is going to benefit kids who are at school right now, but it is also going to benefit generations of children who will go to those schools in the near future.
When I turn my mind to this bill, the contributions in this house have really talked about some of the significant changes that we are making to our VCE and VCAL systems—just listening back in my office, it was interesting. I think about when I was at school and the stigma attached to kids that were either going to do their HSC at the time or going through the pathway of TAFE and looking at getting a trade. There was a stigma attached to that. My brother went through that. He had two older sisters that went through HSC and went on to university, but he was not greatly academic. It was not a—I would not say ‘welcomed’—celebrated decision that he would go through and get the skills that he needed to get a trade and get a job in the workforce and not go on to university, and we know that is VCAL here. It should be a celebration. No child should feel that because they are not going to sit exams through the VCE and go on from high school somehow the VCAL system in Victoria is less important or will deliver less of an education, or more importantly, reduce their opportunity to get their job. Every child in Victoria should feel extremely proud of the type of education that they will receive.
The life span of VCE and VCAL systems is something that we on this side of the house can be very proud of. It was the Bracks government that moved Victoria away from the HSC model and introduced VCE and VCAL in 2002, and that is pretty close to 20 years ago. Since then it has made a significant contribution to getting many Victorian students through their education and providing them with the skills they need to go on to higher learning, whether that be at university or TAFE. What we know on this side of the house is that no education system is perfect, and I always think that the difference between good government and great government—and indeed this Andrews Labor government is a great government—is that great governments are always looking for ways to improve. They are always identifying the gaps in the system that need to be fixed and improving systems and processes and facilities and so on, and that is what this government is doing and that is what this bill is in fact delivering. It is why our government commissioned the Firth review to look at how we can improve our vocational education and provide even more opportunities for Victorians that do not actually involve any university, and it was an acknowledgement that those other opportunities, those other jobs, are just as important. Let us face it, we need those jobs to be filled if we want to get on and deliver many of the great programs and infrastructure projects that we have currently got underway in Victoria at the moment because of this great Andrews Labor government.
There are so many great things I could say about this bill. The one thing that I do know is that kids in the outer west, kids in my patch, are going to benefit from this. Moving the conversation away from the VCAL suddenly being this unwanted second cousin, if you like, compared to VCE and going on to university, is a really important narrative and it is a narrative that we need champions of. We need governments like ours to be that champion and lead the way for those children who will not go on to VCE, who have no intention of going to university and, let us face it, may not actually flourish at university and achieve what they want to achieve. VCAL will no longer be the second cousin. It will be right there sitting on equal footing with VCE, and I commend the bill to the house.
Mr FREGON (Mount Waverley) (11:20): I also rise to speak on the Education and Training Reform Amendment (Senior Secondary Pathways Reforms and Other Matters) Bill 2021. I get very excited when I see the Deputy Premier and Minister for Education introduce bills into this house, because it gives us another chance to talk about the continual and substantial Andrews Labor government commitment which has established Victoria as the Education State. It is probably fair to say that the Minister for Education could have dropped the mic quite a while ago with not only the capital investment but the significant education reform, but he does not. He continues in an astounding way, really. Every day it is another, ‘Hold my beer—I’ve got more to do’. This bill is another example, and it really goes to the heart of our commitment to have an education system in our state that not only can we be proud of and is developing all of our children but is allowing them to be the best version of themselves, and that is not always the same. In fact it is never the same. Every one of our kids is unique, and I have got my own insights in my own family on that, which I will come back to.
But I go back to my own period at high school. The member for Bayswater talked about Fairhills High School, who have stepped up and are providing some vaccination hubs outside of hours, which I thought was a fantastic initiative. I got my HSC back in 1986, and I was the last cohort to get an HSC. The minister at the table, the Minister for Tourism, Sport and Major Events, is with me in that cohort. I am guessing your Anderson score would have been a bit better than mine, Minister, but nonetheless I went through that period of high school doing maths/science. I had this thought as a young person that I would take over from my father and run the pharmacy. That is sort of what was expected, and of course I got my Anderson score in probably January or whenever it was of 1987 and there was a bit of a rude awakening there that that was not going to happen. So we found some other things to do, and for someone who did maths/science, now I get paid to speak for a living, so—I do not know—life is full of mysteries.
But at the time growing up through those years in the early 1980s, you know, Fairhills was a good school, and it is still a great school. There was a feeling as a young person that if somehow it went wrong and we had done the wrong thing or we got suspended or, heaven forbid, expelled, you would probably get sent to Ferntree Gully High. That was the next stage of where you would go—at least this was the perception of a 13- or 14-year-old young person—and then if it went really bad from there, you would probably get sent to the tech. So you would have gone to Ferntree Gully Technical School, and not only was that not right, but I think there is still a perception amongst some that the vocational pathways that are available to young people are somehow not the same as an academic pathway. The other members have spoken about that maths/science path. I did that path. I passed; I did okay.
I had a plumber come to my place a couple of years ago, as we had a leak in the front garden. I have been in IT for years and done analysis techniques to find problems; that is part of the job as an IT person. This plumber came, and there was a leak in the front garden—and no idea where, it was under the ground—and there was just water coming out everywhere. Within about an hour this guy had worked out exactly where the pipe was that was leaking and fixed it. Now, I could not have done that—not in an hour, anyway. I could have dug up the whole garden and eventually found something. Those vocational skills align with other skills of an academic nature. So whilst having two separate pathways, VCAL and VCE, has really worked for students who have done those, this reform allows that mix of complementary skills that do not necessarily fit the cookie cutter, and I think this is really exciting.
I go back to the last two years, where we have had our children at home doing remote learning, and I guess one of the light bulbs that went off early in the process last year was that all three of my children learn completely differently. My daughter is very, very academic, and she is doing very well—all my kids are doing well. But my two boys learn differently, and because they are in primary school we have been a bit more hands-on with them on a daily basis. They are both very bright kids, and we are obviously very proud of them, as everyone is proud of their kids. But Lindsay is more hands-on. His eyes will light up when he gets a task that could be academic in nature but is also a bit more hands-on. With the analytical skills, the problem-solving skills, he is very good. We bought some chairs for the house the other day, some computer chairs or something, and I said, ‘Well, if you want your chair’—because one of them was his—‘you’ve got to build it; you’ve got to put it together’. I presume I am not alone here, for other people who have kids. Half the time it is hard to get them to go and do tasks around the house and get off their devices. Well, the moment he started on this chair he was lost; he was just fully concentrating on the task at hand.
It got me thinking, ‘How do we open up not only my own son but our kids to other possibilities?’, and this bill I believe does that. This bill leads us to a place where kids who are doing academic classes can also see their own cohort having other possibilities. Someone mentioned horticulture a bit earlier; I am not sure which member it was. But if you take something like horticulture or like the plumber that I mentioned, there are obviously vocational skills that those people need to have a career in that area and need to go and do. But if you want to start your own business in those areas, there are financial skills, there are business skills and there are other skills that will enable you to be successful for the rest of your life.
Adopting the vocational areas of our education system within the VCE sends a very clear message to not only the students who will be partaking of this but also the parents that these are valid and celebrated skills. I have given a couple of examples, and we could think of millions of examples of why that is true. But I think this is a very important step, and as I stated, I commend the minister for taking this step. Since the Victorian certificate of applied learning, the VCAL, was introduced by the Bracks Labor government, it has made a significant contribution, and it has I guess progressed and evolved into what we are doing today. The people in my area who have done VCAL are leading fantastic contributions to our state.
This bill will enable future parents, I would suggest, to consider other options when discussing education with their kids as they grow older. I know I certainly will be interested to speak about these sorts of reforms with my son in a practical way as he grows and goes through his educational journey. I commend the bill to the house.
Mr SOUTHWICK (Caulfield) (11:30): It is my pleasure to rise and make some comments on a bill that ultimately is about bringing education forward to not distinguish between those that are embarking on a VCE–university pathway and those that are embarking certainly on more of a practical, VCAL, VET and trade-type pathway. What we need certainly going forward, particularly around the future jobs, is something that is quite seamless—not to be able to, if you like, paint in a light that one is better than the other. We certainly know in the job market that many of those trades, many of those skills, are so important. We have such a skill shortage here in Victoria, and we need to ensure that we promote the kinds of education programs that consider the options for young people as early as possible to get them to consider other trades and vocations going forward. So it is on that basis that we support any programs that actually highlight opportunities for young people in pursuing their own pathway that ultimately gives them options, opportunity and a job. That is why this is so important.
I want to highlight particularly some great things that are happening in my electorate of Caulfield and particularly, to start off with, Oakwood School. Oakwood School is part of the Caulfield Park community campus. It is a school that has many kids that have really struggled in other schools. They end up at the Caulfield campus of Oakwood to pursue more of a practical, hands-on education. Steve Kearney, who has been the principal there for some time, has embarked on some really interesting programs. These kids would not normally actually finish year 12; many of them would have dropped out. But with a very hands-on approach, these kids at Oakwood, at Caulfield community campus, have been able to embark on music, engineering, trades—a whole, vast range of programs. They have taken kids that have got themselves in trouble with, say, graffiti to turn that into graffiti art, and the same with music as well in terms of embarking on their own in music engineering or performance.
When I have visited the school on a number of occasions I have been very impressed by the hands-on nature of the school. Also, there is a relationship between that school and Ardoch youth foundation, which I was very involved with for a number of years, promoting youth at risk. Ardoch provide a number of programs and support for that school as well. So it is a great school. Again, this is a school that offers VCAL and that offers VET. Certainly it is not a VCE-focused school; it is more about the kind of practical, hands-on approach to schooling and pathways. I think that is the kind of model that we should be looking at to provide further opportunities for these types of kids, who would normally not undertake a traditional VCE program.
More broadly as well, and it is highlighted by Oakwood and a number of other schools, during the lockdown many of these kids have not been able to embark on some of the practical programs that these schools would normally offer. I really wanted to just take a minute to pay tribute to many of the parents and the kids that have really struggled doing this, whether it is the cooking-type programs, whether it is woodworking—the stuff that you cannot do in your bedroom but that you need to do in your classroom. I know Yeshivah-Beth Rivkah Colleges run a great cooking program, and Glen Eira College do a fantastic cooking and woodworking program and a furniture production program. Glen Eira College have been running a timber program, woodworking program, for years. If you go and have a look at some of the equipment there, it could almost feature in a museum—it is that old—but it is still applicable to today. The great ability for those kids to turn their hand to a trade like that is outstanding, but again, because of lockdowns, many of these kids have not been able to participate in those kinds of programs, and it is really disappointing that that has been the case.
As I said, that is one of the things we are really desperate to see—those kids getting back into the classroom. It really does highlight the issues around lockdown. You cannot do this stuff over Zoom. You cannot do this stuff over the internet. You need to actually be present. And in many instances a lot of these young kids have suffered greatly because they just have not been able to do it. So I know, and I am glad that we are talking about this, options for kids in terms of pathways are really, really important, but I think it is also important to highlight that many of these kids have been without any opportunity to do any of this for a very, very long time here in Victoria, and we want to get those kids back.
I also think there is a great opportunity to be able to, in line with some of these pathways, link these kids to a job and also have some of the training done within the actual workplace, which does currently happen. I want to highlight a couple of opportunities that are happening, again in my local electorate of Caulfield, particularly in the disability space. I have been a very strong advocate of recognising ability and disability and ensuring that there is an equal playing field when it comes to the disability sector. I want to highlight just a few. All Things Equal Cafe runs a food program. You go in there and you could be served in that cafe by somebody with a disability and somebody without a disability. They do not distinguish. They ultimately offer a lot of young people a job and some training, which is really, really good. It is a great program. It is a great cafe. Again, that cafe has not been able to open during lockdown. They do run coffees at the moment, but I know that All Things Equal Cafe in Carlisle Street, Balaclava, is desperate to get those kids back into the cafe.
With those kids, particularly high-functioning kids, kids with autism, many of their parents are really, really struggling at home. We saw last week an example of a Victorian mother that has an autistic child who, through schooling, has been literally punching holes in the wall because that child is locked up in their home and has not been able to get out and about in the classroom—in this case, into the cafe with a job. That is the unfortunate consequence of many lockdowns. That is why, again, it is so important when we look at this pandemic to consider the mental health consequences of the pandemic as well—to get those kids that are particularly in need of other stimulus into those other environments as well. All Things Equal Cafe does a fantastic job, and I cannot wait to see them open again with patrons inside enjoying a meal but importantly also those staff who they employ and they train.
Flying Fox, which runs camps, does a great job running camps, and Access also employs people and does a lot of volunteer training. That is a fantastic way to actually get in many of those young kids that are undergoing a higher education program but also to get some real training in working with kids with disability. They are two examples of programs that have been around a long time in my electorate that have done some fantastic work in the area as well.
I also want to highlight J-Air, which is a community radio station. I was talking with J-Air just the other day about the ability to bring some of the kids on a training program as well and them being the training provider. Bialik College, which I know the member for Hawthorn would have been to once or twice—I hope—is a great school, and I have a lot to do with them. They have a number of their kids that volunteer on the radio program, but there is obviously an opportunity for a pathway as part of that program. So I think there are some great opportunities.
I just want to again shout out to all of the kids in my electorate, all of the parents, all of the families and all of the teachers that have done it really, really tough. Whether it is Glen Eira College, whether it is the secondary schools, whether it is the primary schools or whether it is the Jewish day schools, all of them have done it really tough. I think when we are talking about the practical hands-on programs as we are today—where you cannot do it via Zoom; you have to do it face to face—that is where a lot of those kids have missed out the most. That is why we are desperate to get kids back in the classroom and we are desperate to get kids back working with one another, to learn from one another and to get the skills that will give them options today and a job tomorrow. That is why we support this program. We support this bill, and ultimately we want to give young people every possible skill and every possible opportunity to get a job in the future.
Ms HENNESSY (Altona) (11:40): I am very grateful to have the opportunity to rise and make a brief contribution indicating my support to the Education and Training Reform Amendment (Senior Secondary Pathways Reforms and Other Matters) Bill 2021, and I do so for a number of reasons. This is an incredibly important bill, and at its heart it contains an unwavering commitment to the belief that our government holds in the potential of every single child and every single student. I do just want to reflect that we have heard some really fantastic contributions about people’s individual pathways and experiences at school. We have heard some fantastic contributions about the power and possibility of finding that connection that keeps people engaged in educational settings. I have particularly enjoyed people sharing their personal experiences, and the great divide emerges between the HSC factions and the VCE factions in the Victorian Parliament. Lest there be any doubt, I am in the VCE faction, but I pay my respects to my elders from the HSC faction of the Victorian Parliament as well.
But it is, I think, a great testament to the commitment that Labor governments always have to doing everything we possibly can to keep young people engaged in the education system and to keep very focused on the purpose of education and connection to industries and jobs that are meaningful in the future, but to always have the wherewithal, the commitment and the passion to review and reflect upon how we can do things better.
As many of the speakers have shared with the chamber, the genesis of the change from HSC to VCE and then the inclusion of VCAL in 2002 was under the Bracks government, and I would just like to make a brief tribute to a former member for Altona, the honourable Lynne Kosky, who was the education minister at the time and who at the time of her retirement from the Victorian Parliament cited the creation of VCAL as one of the proudest policy achievements of her time as a politician. That was for a number of reasons and ones that sit behind the policy imperatives that justify, in my view, this reform. It is about making sure that we recognise the contribution of different learning approaches and the power and possibility of keeping people engaged with good education and good industry-based training and ensuring that we are not consigning some cohorts of students and saying, ‘Look, we just can’t make the education system work for you. It’s all too hard’. The education system fails if it does not work for everybody. It has got to meet that very binary threshold test, and that is what has sat behind and beneath these reforms over many, many years.
I do just want to again thank the Minister for Education and also Minister Tierney, who are so personally and passionately motivated by making sure that we have a system that is fit for purpose and that is forward focused and ultimately believe in the potential of every single student and that we need to have an education system that continuously gets better but that is also linked to vocational education and training opportunities and ensures that we are creating pathways for people to not just have fulfilment but to have jobs of the future, where they can earn and be dignified in how they are remunerated and where they feel valued about what they do each and every single day. Those are quite lofty tests and aspirations for any education or training system to have, and I think that as you look at the Firth review you see where there are opportunities to get better. There is a series of recommendations, and recommendations 1 and 10 are what lead us to this bill.
I think one of the important issues is how we better entrench VCAL as an option. I have heard it referred to as the poor cousin, the Clayton’s VCE. All of those things indicate that we have still got a cultural problem around understanding and putting fundamental value on the skills that sit behind those that choose to do a VCAL pathway and then perhaps go off and work in different trades areas or find other skill-based training that then generates a good and dignified pathway for their life. So there is still cultural work that needs to be done, and how we all conceive of value and success and meaning and all those issues I think is very germane to how we structure education and how we celebrate what is meaningful and valuable as well.
One of the great achievements in this bill is that it says that the VCAL option and that pathway is very much part of the VCE option. There is an accountability put on schools around having school-based and industry-based training to make sure that we are also holding schools and the education system accountable and that there is recognition of the inherent value of those students. It might be because of the circumstances and chaos in their home lives that mean that they are not ready for VCE, it might be that they are people that learn differently, but ultimately creating a pathway to keep those young people still engaged in a system gives them a pathway in order to not just have a meaningful year 12 and year 11 experience but also it creates pathways that then connect with jobs and with education and vocational education and training settings that are meaningful in the future.
I heard the member for Burwood, like a peacock putting up its plume, share his wonderful Latin knowledge with the chamber. ‘Pari passu’ of course is Latin for ‘equal footing’. In describing the policy aspiration in those terms I think the member for Burwood was really speaking to some of the value judgements that are still too barnacled on to our perceptions of value in the education system and in actually trying to ensure that this is not seen as a Clayton’s VCE, that it is not seen as the poor cousin but is indeed a very demanding, highly valued pathway. The jobs that those sorts of pathways can lead on to are a great testimony to that. So I do very much welcome these reforms. I think they are incredibly important.
I do also want to thank and acknowledge the work that teachers have done, particularly in the course of lockdown in recent times. As the member for Mount Waverley observed, when you are at home dealing with remote learning it does sharpen your mind about the value of teachers and about the value of school systems. The way in which they have had to continually adapt to the challenges and the demands of remote learning is something that we should not just say ‘thank you’ for. We should remember, and we should remember that forever. We should remember it at budget times. We should remember it at enterprise bargaining agreement times. We should remember it every time we hear that annoying person who likes to tee off on the value of teachers at family or friendship events. We need to make sure that we translate and transform our gratitude and respect for those that work in the teaching professions and administer schools, and we need to make that meaningful. We need to make sure that the impact on us is indelible.
I am absolutely confident, at least on this side of the house, that we will continue in our efforts to make sure that we are funding at levels that have never been seen before and that we continue to engage with our workforce in a way that demonstrates that they are valued—not just around the capital that we build but around how we remunerate them, around how their work is classified and how we ensure that there are meaningful pathways for those that are in those professions to become leaders and to continue to specialise. Ultimately we live in a world that can no longer just be about primary, secondary, tertiary and vocational education that is finished by the time we hit our mid-20s. We need to be lifelong learners. We are all going to have to be able to adjust in the way in which we learn, in the way in which we are trained, in order to make sure that we have an economy, a society and a community that is fit for purpose for the changing nature of work in the future. This is an incredibly important part of that future, and I commend the bill and thank all of those that have worked so hard in order to ensure that the next great wave of education reform serves to benefit the children of the state of Victoria.
Mr T BULL (Gippsland East) (11:50): I rise just to make a few quite short comments on this bill in relation to, I guess, its impact and benefits to those people in the community with special needs. I follow on from some commentary that has been provided by previous speakers in relation to the clarification and additional pathways that will provide benefits to those in our community with disabilities. It is an area where we have certainly as a society come a long way in providing opportunities for those in our communities with special needs. I can remember, well prior to my election, being on the local committee for the establishment of the special school in Bairnsdale and working with the local member of Parliament there at the time to get that up off the ground and running.
On the whole our education system and our teachers and our school environments do a terrific job in dealing with our children with special needs and providing opportunities and the necessary supports that are required. Unfortunately from time to time we have issues that pop up that are often sadly well publicised in the media, where there is that small percentage that can and should do better in relation to the education of our special needs children. So whilst we have come a long way and whilst we generally do things very, very well, there is always room for improvement.
I want to speak for just a few moments on one of our social enterprises in East Gippsland, in Bairnsdale as a matter of fact, that we actually got up and running shortly after my election in 2010 with some support funding from the state government, and that was the Cells Cafe in Bairnsdale. It was basically the transformation of the old police station in Bairnsdale into a social enterprise cafe. It was called the Cells because the old cells at the Bairnsdale police station, which I will put on the record I never saw the inside of in my youth, became a very prominent feature of the Cells Cafe in Bairnsdale. The old bars are there as you walk into this cafe. Now, why I mention the Cells is because it is run by Noweyung, which is our predominant disability support provider in our region, and it provides a great training opportunity for the young people within our community. It is particularly close to me because my own son has recently started doing some work experience there and is one of many with special needs who have gone through that system and obtained skills in the hospitality sector which then give them the opportunity to be able to go out and, I guess, work in cafes, restaurants and other hospitality outlets. Why it is so important in my region is because East Gippsland relies predominantly on tourism and hospitality. We do have very important timber and farming sectors, but to provide that pathway for those in our communities with special needs is very, very important, and it is a very, very successful program that I hope will be further expanded into other areas around the state.
Now, of course we have an increasing number of social enterprises in Victoria that do support the training and that transition of our younger people from the school environment into the workforce. But whilst we have seen significant and major growth in that area, I think it is an area where government has a responsibility to further expand. We do not have to reinvent the wheel. There are a lot of very, very well-run and successful social enterprise ideas that can be duplicated around other areas of the state from the models that currently exist.
Before I finish I also just want to—obviously in this time of the coronavirus—give a quick shout-out to our teaching fraternity and the work that they have been doing over the course of the lockdown period. My household has a very small insight into that. My wife is a teachers aide at a primary school in East Gippsland, and knowing the level of work and preparation and challenge of educating students remotely with often the challenges of poor internet connection and communications has been quite difficult. In my closing remarks I will just give a shout-out to all those workers in our school communities who have gone above and beyond. I think that they will certainly be looking forward just as much as the students to getting back to school, and the sooner that happens the better.
Ms HALFPENNY (Thomastown) (11:56): I rise to make a contribution on the Education and Training Reform Amendment (Senior Secondary Pathways Reforms and Other Matters) Bill 2021. When elected to government almost seven years ago now we made a commitment to establish Victoria as the Education State. That meant a state that would value educational opportunities equally for every Victorian student regardless of their circumstances. It also meant a state that ensures that students are given every possible chance to acquire the skills and knowledge that they need to lead rich and fulfilling lives and make great contributions to our society.
Since that time we have seen record investments made to reform our school system through both buildings and programs, and it is hoped that this will ensure that students are even better prepared to embark on their future lives and careers. In the electorate of Thomastown alone well over $80 million has already been spent building new and redeveloping old schools. This builds on top of the grants and maintenance funds as well as the recurrent spending increases.
This bill provides such an important platform to further reform our secondary school system in a manner that provides opportunities to prospective and current students. In fact it is a critical element of a transformational reform program that will create better education and training pathways for students to get the skills they need for the jobs that they want. The Education and Training Reform Amendment (Senior Secondary Pathways Reforms and Other Matters) Bill 2021 will implement recommendations 1 and 10 of the Firth review. Specifically the bill will deliver two new options to students in their final years of school and will commence from 2023. The bill will provide for the creation of a new category and qualifications by inserting a definition of ‘foundation secondary course’ and ‘foundation secondary qualification’, and it will also facilitate the smooth transition of Victoria’s senior secondary system to a new certificate scheme that comprises both the vocational major within the VCE system and the Victorian pathways certificate.
The Victorian pathways certificate will replace foundation VCAL and is designed to support students to transition either to the VCE or to entry-level employment and VET. This pathway provides an additional option for students that may be at risk of leaving school early and also for students that have additional needs. As many speakers earlier have said, the current system has a VCAL stream and a VCE stream in the later years of the senior years of secondary school. This will put those together so that the VCAL system will be embedded within the VCE system and be given equal standing and equal weight rather than running alongside it as a separate program that often is given less attention.
The new pathway certificate and the vocational major within the VCE will provide an integrated certificate framework. This will include a rigorous and detailed curriculum. The certificate will then build on the best elements of VCAL within the VCE program but also include flexibility to provide some extra opportunities for senior secondary students. Those educational opportunities will be an education that is of course engaging, can be based on real life and also can deliver skills that are required and demanded in a flexible way in the future world of work.
This bill is important for so many reasons, some of which I have discussed, but we do see that it is even more important that it is coming at this time when we have seen such a disproportionate impact on young people across our state due to the COVID-19 pandemic. Students have had to bear the brunt in many ways of the pandemic, with disruptions to their learning, impacts on their mental health and significant social implications and job losses in some of those hospitality areas. I think many people, when they are in their higher years of school, also require a bit more spending money and often have to go and get part-time jobs—many of those around cafes and coffee shops—to get that little bit of money to spend.
So as we emerge from this pandemic, or this crisis, it has never been more important to recognise that young people must be given opportunities to acquire hands-on skills and ensure that those skills are just as valued and respected, in both our education system and society as a whole, as the academic pathways that lead on to university. And with the economy undergoing rapid change, the ability to provide great education and relevant high-quality training for the workforce will be vital to Victoria in leading recovery and future prosperity.
That is why it is essential that our senior secondary system and education system more broadly are very well positioned to help students build the skills and capabilities to thrive in future education and training and later on in life. These new certificates will provide all senior secondary students with access to the best aspects of both VCAL and VCE by delivering high-quality vocational and applied learning opportunities as well as the academic. The intention is really to lift the vocational aspect of years 11 and 12 to ensure they are on an equal footing, because trades and hands-on education and subsequent employment are just as vital and just as important as university qualifications and work, because education is not just about academic results and entrance scores to university. So the opportunities that this reform will make are critical to providing young people with a holistic education experience that encompasses integrated learning elements.
I look back and think about my family and my two sons, both of whom studied VCE and the academic path. When you look back, they really were not given an option or an opportunity to do anything different. The schools that they went to did not really put an emphasis on VCAL or vocational programs, and I feel that they would have significantly benefited if they had been given the choice and the opportunity to experience other forms of learning rather than being really told that there was just one path. Every young person in Victoria deserves and will benefit from opportunities that provide theoretical knowledge as well as practical skills in order for them to continue on with life.
So these reforms are the result of extensive consultation as well as the commissioned Firth review. I think previous speakers have talked—in fact it might have been the Deputy Chair—about a lot of detail around the extensive consultations that have been produced as a result of these reforms and that have shaped the reforms that we are talking about today.
Finally, I would like to really take the opportunity to acknowledge the work, in the most difficult of circumstances, of principals, teachers and school staff during this pandemic. I also acknowledge the pressures, the stress and the disadvantage to students and their families. But we are nearly through it, and we have a path out through vaccination. I want to wish year 12 students the very best for their forthcoming exams. I look forward to rejoicing in the 2021 graduations and to returning to visit the schools and the students, which I very much miss. Although I have kept in contact with a number of schools and principals and some students, it is just not the same as being able to attend the schools and talk in person. I am very much looking forward to going to Lalor East Primary School to celebrate the redevelopment of that school and to see the fantastic buildings—even though it is a primary school and we are talking about secondary education reform here. I guess I am really looking forward to meeting up with the school communities again, seeing how the students are doing and supporting them, as this government will do, in getting back to a normal life.
Ms COUZENS (Geelong) (12:05): I am pleased to rise to contribute to the Education and Training Reform Amendment (Senior Secondary Pathways Reforms and Other Matters) Bill 2021, and I have to say it is great to be here in the chamber debating important reforms such as this. I want to begin by thanking the Minister for Education for his commitment. Without him we would not be looking at this bill today.
The Andrews government has had a huge commitment to education right from the minute we were elected in 2014. We have heard contributions today from members talking about their experience in secondary school, and when I reflect on my experience in secondary school at Corio Tech, there were very limited options. These reforms make a huge difference to our secondary school students. My electorate has received an unprecedented amount of funding to upgrade and rebuild our schools, because we want every student in every school to have access to high-quality vocational and applied learning options, which is why this reform is so important.
Secondary schools in my electorate of Geelong—Geelong High School, Newcomb Secondary College, Matthew Flinders Girls Secondary College, Oberon High and Belmont High—have all been major beneficiaries of an unprecedented amount of funding for infrastructure and resources, all really significant funding boosts for the schools in my electorate. As we come through the COVID global pandemic and our economy undergoes rapid change, the ability to provide for a great education and relevant, high-quality training for our workforce will be critical to Victoria’s economic recovery and our future prosperity.
We know poor education outcomes lead to poverty. Good government policy such as this bill and the unprecedented amount of funding provided actually provides greater opportunities and makes a real difference in young people’s lives. It provides better opportunities to students such as those mentioned earlier in this place with special needs, people with disabilities and Aboriginal students. You know, in Geelong it is incredible the number of Aboriginal students that have come into places like TAFE, for example, with the free TAFE courses. They are unprecedented numbers—we have not seen those numbers before—and that is because we are providing things like free TAFE, and now this reform will make a significant difference for those students facing many, many challenges.
That is why it is vitally important that our senior secondary system is best positioned to help students build the skills and capabilities to thrive in further education and training and move into rewarding careers. Teachers and students have had to deal with the challenges of home learning during the pandemic, and we know how tough that has been. I want to acknowledge our teachers in particular and the amazing job they do and the fact that they stepped up when they needed to to educate the students but also to support them during the global pandemic period.
I was so pleased with the Minister for Education’s announcement to introduce mental health experts in every school in our state so that students that need it can access vital mental health support. I have had the opportunity to speak to many students during this global pandemic and their parents. I heard the challenges that they have had, but I also heard how significant the step-up of their schools has been to ensure that they get through this really difficult time. The feedback from parents, students and teachers on the mental health initiatives has been extremely positive, and overwhelmingly they are so thankful to the government for stepping in and making sure that we have those services in place within the school system.
This bill is a key element of a transformational reform program that will create better education and training pathways for students to get the skills they need for the jobs that they want. It is actually a pathway of choice, and it acknowledges the different pathways for students and how important they are. As I said earlier, Aboriginal students, people with special needs and people with disabilities that rely on those support mechanisms—a pathway that they can work through is just so important.
This bill implements key recommendations from the Review into Vocational and Applied Learning Pathways in Senior Secondary Schooling by former Victorian Curriculum and Assessment Authority CEO John Firth. The successful passage of this bill and implementation of these reforms will help ensure that our young people can receive a great education, learn about the world of work and develop strong life skills so that they can make informed choices about further study, jobs and their future. This will enable young people to contribute to and benefit from the growth in the Victorian economy and prepare them for active and fulfilling lives in the community. And of course, as I mentioned, the free TAFE courses, the opportunities for the future, are far reaching for students. As these free TAFE courses have grown, I have had the pleasure of meeting many students who have taken up these courses, and I am pleased we have provided these opportunities for young students across Victoria, but in particular in my electorate.
The bill implements recommendations 1 and 10 of the Firth review. The bill amends the Education and Training Reform Act 2006 to introduce a new Victorian Pathways Certificate, VPC, and vocational major within the Victorian Certificate of Education, VCE, into Victoria’s senior secondary education system. This new certificate framework will replace VCAL. The bill also amends the Education and Training Reform Act to enable the Victorian Registration and Qualifications Authority to extend the transition period of superseded training products beyond 12 months. This bill introduces new definitions of a foundation secondary course and foundation secondary qualifications to accommodate the VPC. It allows the Victorian Registration and Qualifications Authority to register the VPC on the state register, register providers to deliver the course and register the Victorian Curriculum and Assessment Authority to award the qualification. It enables a supported transition of providers and students to the new certificate scheme in time for its commencement in 2023. It creates offences for providing or offering to provide the new type of course or awarding or offering to award the new type of qualification without registration. It allows the VRQA to extend the transition period of superseded training packages beyond 12 months where it is satisfied that there would be a disadvantage to students if the extension were not granted or where exceptional circumstances exist, thereby aligning Victorian standards with the national VET regulator, the Australian Skills Quality Authority and the Western Australian Training Accreditation Council. It provides the Victorian Civil and Administrative Tribunal with power to review a decision of the VRQA to extend the transition period of superseded training packages beyond 12 months.
From 2023 Victorian students will begin to move to a single integrated senior secondary certificate recognising academic and applied learning opportunities. The new Victorian Pathways Certificate and vocational major within the VCE will provide an integrated certificate framework which includes a more rigorous and detailed curriculum. The certificates will build on the best elements of VCAL, including the flexibility to provide senior secondary students with an education that is engaging and based in real life and that delivers in-demand skills for the future world of work.
This bill for my electorate is really significant, and the reforms that we have made as the Andrews Labor government are so significant. The support for these reforms is very clear in my electorate and I am sure across Victoria, and obviously the opposition are supporting this bill as well. It really will make a difference to the lives of students in my community. I know that, and I have heard from many of them the experiences that they have had. I suppose—as I started with my experience at Corio Tech—growing up in poverty to some degree, you understand the difference that government policy can make to the lives of people. The opportunities that have been afforded to me over time will extend to students going into the future as well. I commend the bill to the house.
Mr McGUIRE (Broadmeadows) (12:15): Many people think better with their hands. That is the reality, that is what we need. These skills are vital and urgent, and that is what this bill delivers. It is really important now more than ever. We are trying to come out of the pandemic, bring back the economy. We have unprecedented investments: the Big Housing Build—$5.3 billion for new affordable and social homes; we have the Big Build strategy itself. These are all major strategic investments in the pipeline, and we need the skilled people to build them.
I want to advocate again that I think we should have a television and marketing campaign to express this. We need to define the importance, we need to celebrate how it works. It is not a choice of one over the other. Of course we need people who are doing STEM courses and we need the best and brightest, but we can bring them together, lift them up together. This is how we create opportunity; this is what Victoria does. I speak as the member for Broadmeadows, because that is where they uniquely come together in one epicentre. You can have CSL manufacturing more than 50 million vaccines, the AstraZeneca vaccines, to save lives in Australia and overseas, and you can also have the investment that the Victorian government put in the last budget—$60 million for new skills, training and jobs. The Minister for Training and Skills, Gayle Tierney in the other house, and I witnessed the agreement that was done in Broadmeadows. You should have seen the kids, they were so excited: ‘This is a better opportunity in life. Here is your chance; here is the opportunity, and this is how we need to bring it together’. So now we are extending that into the school system to provide that opportunity and the pipeline of students who can come through and actually get these jobs. We will have a range of different courses. The high-priority industries are nursing, allied health and healthcare education services, quality aged care, mental health, pathology and disability, to help drive economic recovery and social development post the COVID-19 vaccine. This is in the Broadmeadows Health and Community Centre of Excellence. So we are lifting it up. We are saying, ‘This is what we need, this is why this is important’.
There was another $5.5 million investment before this into a new sustainable plumbing centre on the Broadmeadows campus of Kangan Institute as well. Here is how you actually say to these students: ‘Talent is not defined by demographics, but too often opportunity is. We’re providing the opportunity for you’. And then, through the investment attraction, we have inspired private sector investment to come into the area. The old Ford site has just had the fifth anniversary of the closure. It devastated Broadmeadows. It changed people’s lives. It was about identity for a lot of people. But we have got investment in there, and new industries and jobs will be created with driving technology as well.
Here is how you bring the strategy together and you connect the disconnected. You say to people, ‘You’re part of this community. You are valued. You are part of something bigger, and here’s how you can have a better opportunity in life’. This is the government at its best, when it coordinates in this way. We have got another opportunity. I am trying to say to both the Victorian government and the federal government: after the record investments, make sure you come back to these communities; make sure they do not get left behind. The issue that I have always had is that Australia turns to Broadmeadows in times of existential threat, from wars to disasters, from economic peril to pandemic, and then too often, though, when the catastrophe has passed, it turns its back, abandoning Broadmeadows to worse disadvantage, compounding complexity, like an orphan. We are not going to let that happen. This is the opportunity right here, right now, to change this, and this is part of how this strategy can fit together.
So what are the investments out of the record budgets? And then we have got the forthcoming city deal, where we have put the high-value positions on the table through the comeback strategy, and we will draw it all together. Here is how you can actually change people’s lives, here are the skills that we require and here is how we bring it together for advanced manufacturing—that is CSL and a whole host of other companies that have come in. And what do we crave? We crave independent supply chains and national sovereignty. So it is no use losing the automotive industry and then saying, ‘We’ve got a problem: manufacturing scale’. I want to make this above partisanship but also go to the key issues that we as a nation and a state, and even at the third tier of government, the local municipality, need to come together on to just drive these projects, because this is how you make the advanced manufacturing for life-saving blood products and then vaccines. You have them against the pandemic and soon against influenza. They are all critical. Then you make sure that you take these derelict sites and you turn them around, you reinvest and you see what you can do, and you harness that opportunity. Then you have the circular economy, which we are also driving. You get the connection between the business investment and the social infrastructure, and we have got to make sure of that, because part of the history of Broadmeadows has been that the social infrastructure has lagged behind what was required. But I think that now we are well set up and we need to advance on all of those issues.
If we have a look at what the Victorian government is doing at a whole range of different levels, this affects everybody. I just want to acknowledge the minister at the table, the Minister for Crime Prevention. I work as Parliamentary Secretary for Crime Prevention with the minister. She came out recently to Banksia Gardens, and these are people whose lives have been brutalised in many different ways; they have not had much chance in life. But you should see the response you get when you are saying to them, ‘Here’s a chance’. As I always say, anybody from Broadmeadows only needs half a chance—that will do. They have got the drive. They just want to know that they have got a way, and they can see that somebody has actually said, ‘Here’s a hand up’—they do not want a handout, they just want a hand up—and ‘Here’s your chance to get some training, get your life back together’. A lot of people go through major trauma in life, as we know from the inquiries, many in this house. And I know that you have done them, as I have; I just want to make that acknowledgement, Deputy Speaker. So how do you just say to them, ‘Here’s your way through. Here’s how we can connect you to better opportunity, give you the skills, give you the training and then create the economic environment around you so that you do want to have that opportunity’?
From a place-based proposition, we want to have 20-minute cities. We want people working within their location. So when the airport comes back I want local jobs for local people. I have said to the airport—I have had an agreement with them in the past—to let us know how they are going to stage this rollout and what the skills are, what the certificates are and what we need so we get the pipeline right, and now here is the opportunity to actually get it not just with Kangan TAFE but through secondary education as well, so you see where you can live, where you can work, where you can have a better life and you have got great opportunities—and of course the pay. Now is going to be the right time—the best time—to be coming through, I would argue, probably in Victoria’s history, and to have these skills. I think that is what we need to do. We need to give people some inspiration, give them the chances for all our children and the next generations, and this is why this is such an important bill.
Mr CHEESEMAN (South Barwon) (12:25): It is with some pleasure that I rise this afternoon to speak on the Education and Training Amendment (Senior Secondary Pathways Reform and Other Matters) Bill 2021. I always, when I reflect on bills like this, think about the Labor Party’s DNA and our very long-term agenda of reforming this state to ensure that we are the fairest of states and that every Victorian is provided absolutely with opportunities going forward. In reflecting on this reform I think it is very important to reflect that this reform builds on a succession of reforming Labor governments in this space.
In terms of my own particular story, my family migrated from New Zealand in 1988. It was around about this time in 1988, and I did my last two or three months of primary school in Australia before going on to secondary school at the start of 1989. In that period of time we had Joan Kirner as the Minister for Education in the Cain government, which was implementing a lot of reform to improve the opportunities of people across this state. People would recall that in that period of time we really had a two-geared secondary schooling system: we had the technical high school system, which I was a very proud graduate of, and of course we had the high school system. In reflecting, certainly in the areas that I grew up in we typically found the technical high schools in the more working-class communities and the high schools in more middle-class communities. I am sure that was not uniformly the case, but certainly it was in the areas that I grew up in. I certainly do not want to put words in the former Labor education minister and then Premier Joan Kirner’s mouth, but I suspect what she was seeking to do was to ensure that every student had the opportunity to achieve the maximum educational outcome to suit where they wanted to go with their lives. I think her vision was very much to break down the glass barriers that existed in our education system to provide every student with a similar set of opportunities, and we saw as a consequence of those reforms the technical high schools change. We saw the introduction—or reform, initially—of the high school certificate, the implementation then of the VCE, and then later on we saw the introduction of vocational and VCAL-style education, which provided those pathways for students who wished to go on and become tradies, to become the workers that our economy so desperately needed through that period.
I must say in some ways, despite the vision of Joan Kirner at that point in time, I am not sure that the reforms that were put in place were delivering completely on her outstanding vision for what we want to see in an education system. That is why these reforms that have been introduced by the Minister for Education after a very detailed process of consultation and collaboration with the sector are so very, very important. They will reform the system so that we have effectively one education attainment, which is the certificate that this legislation very much underpins, no matter which stream of education you take, no matter what the ambition is of Mum and Dad or the primary caregiver or indeed the student, so that when you finish your secondary schooling you end up with a recognised certificate that does not provide a disincentive depending on the type of education.
Now, I must say, in reflecting on that journey and indeed in reflecting on the kids that I went to school with, I certainly very much want to recognise the thoughts of the member for Broadmeadows. There has never been a greater time to become a tradie, to of course assist the Andrews Labor government in delivering its massive infrastructure pipeline. Indeed I think the reforms that were put in place over the last 20 years by reforming Labor governments have seen highly skilled jobs created and those workers with the skills to be able to interact with those massive building projects that we have underway.
These reforms are actually really important. From my end it does not particularly matter if kids are great with their hands or great with their minds. The reality is if you want to be great with your hands and ultimately later on want to go on and become a tradesperson and want to own your own business, then absolutely you need to have a set of skills that enable you to successfully run a business, to do the books, to make sure that the workers on the sites that you can control are working in a safe way—that you have the skills to be able to appropriately quote for and win work for your own business and those indeed that work for you. That is why these reforms are so important. We need all of our workers to have the appropriate qualifications to be able to contribute within our economy.
From my end, as I said earlier, if you look at Labor’s DNA, you very much have to consider the reforming work we have put in place over many, many decades. We are a party that wants to break down those glass ceilings that have historically existed within our community, within our state and across this country. We want to have every student that comes out of our secondary schools having the right set of skills to be able to participate successfully, to be able to earn an income, and I think these reforms very much go a long way. I am very proud of being a student that went through our public education system. I am very proud that I went to a tech high school. I know from talking to many of my colleagues in the Andrews Labor government that they had a similar pathway to this place. That is why I am so keen, and I know every single one of my Labor backbench colleagues are so keen, to see that very direct investment being made into our local public schools, because we see very clearly firsthand, every time we visit, the opportunities that are provided to those kids to get a first-class education to enable those kids to later on productively go into the economy as an adult with the set of skills to engage, to be able to work with their hands or their minds or both, as they move through their working lives.
I must say, from my end, from the things that I have witnessed as a member of Parliament I am so committed to and so proud of the investments that the Andrews Labor government has made in my public schools. I look forward to continuing to work with the Minister for Education and my backbench colleagues to deliver a reforming Labor agenda for our public education system, because I know it is so important for breaking down those glass ceilings, for giving every single boy and every single girl the best opportunity to have a well-paid job with the skills they need moving forward. I commend this legislation to the Parliament.
Ms WARD (Eltham) (12:35): It is great to come after the member for South Barwon with his passionate support for public education, as I know all of us on this side have. This government is continuing the good work that we have been doing since we were first elected in 2014 in creating the Education State with this amendment. Now, as has been discussed by a few others, it is easy for Monday’s experts, for those in the gallery, to criticise teachers—you know, coming up with ideas like incentive payments for teachers when their students get high marks, trying to financially incentivise teachers to be better and better. What this does though is it misunderstands, it demeans and it disrespects the role of the teacher. Kids are their incentive—helping them to grow and to learn. That is why they are teachers. And this is not to say that I do not think teachers should be paid extraordinarily well. I think they should. Their role is incredibly important, and they need to be remunerated accordingly. They need to be remunerated based on longevity and based on commitment, but it is no good siphoning off teachers and trying to create a competition around rote learning.
It is only the ignorant who say, ‘Those who can, do; those who can’t, teach’. None of us would be where we are without our teachers. They are instrumental in helping us become the people that we are, helping us reach our potential and helping us see the opportunities that are available to us. In the last 20 or so months it has become incredibly clear just how hard teaching is, how hard our teachers work and how devoted they are. Our teachers over the last two years have been absolutely vital to our kids, their wellbeing and their education, and I thank our teachers for their extraordinary work throughout this pandemic.
I know firsthand how hard they have worked. I live with a teacher, a teacher who is up into the early hours of the morning—he has VCE students—who does an extraordinary amount of work to look after his kids but also to create interesting, entertaining, informative content, which becomes increasingly difficult online. Our teachers have—to use that very well-used word over the last 18 months—pivoted. They have pivoted, and they have pivoted, and they have pivoted. They have done everything they can to keep our kids engaged, and I congratulate them as well as our students on the success that we have seen with our NAPLAN results from last year. They have been leading the country.
Now, as other members here have said, the Labor Party has always led the way when it comes to education reform. We can go back only as far as Joan Kirner and the work that she undertook regarding the VCE. This move was led by the terrific Howard Kelly, a devoted and lifelong educator who continued his work on the VCE throughout the Kennett years despite the numerous and record-breaking amount of schools Premier Kennett closed and then worked under the wonderful Lynne Kosky. He led a ministerial review that led to our magnificent LLENs—and I will pause here to give a shout-out to my local LLEN, the Banyule-Nillumbik LLEN, who are just fantastic. Our local learning and employment network are incredible in the work that they do—their commitment to kids, how they just help scaffold kids through the pathways and come out with fantastic outcomes. I am incredibly grateful for the LLENs that we have, and I congratulate them on their 20th anniversaries this year. Howard’s passion for education continues. He is now the director of TAFE at Parkville College. And this is what educators are. They are people who are committed. They are people who are devoted to our kids, who will do everything they can to ensure that our kids have the pathways they need.
And the Labor Party is the same. We want to make sure that there are opportunities for our kids. We want to create those pathways, and we want to have as many signposts on those pathways as possible. So as a Labor government we do not rest, we keep reforming and we keep improving, as we have seen with the earlier education reforms brought in by past Labor governments and with what we are seeing with this current Andrews Labor government. We brought in the Firth review to look at how we can continue to improve the final years of formal education in this state. Thirty-eight recommendations were made, and these amendments focus on recommendations 1 and 10. Since 2018 we have invested $315 million in senior schooling reforms, including improving careers advice and education, introducing the Head Start program and supporting and investing in VET. We want our kids to stay in formal learning. We do not want kids falling off. We do not want kids disengaging. We do not want them to feel left behind. We do not want them to feel that there is not a role for them in our education and training programs. We want to understand what they need, and we want to offer education and training support to help those kids achieve the best outcomes they can.
Different schools have had different approaches to VCAL, and I am sorry to say that some schools have chosen to just ignore it completely. Some have shoved it up the back of the school—that is where those kids will go. You know, ‘We’re going to really focus on the VCE kids’. And then there are those exceptional schools who have recognised the importance of the subjects and the training and the skills that VCAL offers—those schools who have done things like set up interviews with kids as to why they want to come into VCAL, who have presentation ceremonies at the end of the school year for their VCAL kids, who hold their VCAL kids up as examples of what great students can be. This is what we want to do with this amendment and what we want to do with this reform: to integrate our kids together so that they are all held up; that they are all seen to be fantastic kids; that none of them are demeaned for the subjects that they choose or the manner in which they choose to do those subjects; and that all kids are valued, regardless of their ability, their interests, their type of learning skills or what the career is that they wish to undertake. All of our kids need to be valued.
Because of these different approaches, we have seen—a number of people have mentioned it, and I think you have as well, Deputy Speaker—that some VCAL kids have been demeaned. They have not been valued as highly as they should have been. And what was interesting to me, with the consultation work that we did in my community, leading up to the introduction of the Banyule Nillumbik Tech School, was our discussion with employers and how much employers had noted that so many kids they were seeing were not job ready, that they did not know the ins and out of a job—the requirements that were needed, the dedication that was needed, what you had to do to show that you were an interested member of the workforce and that you wanted to be good at your job. So if our kids are not job ready, there are still things we need to do as a government and there are things that we still need to do as educators to help prepare our kids for this. We have to give them the skills that are valued and needed by employers and that are helpful for our kids. We need an education system that includes vocational learning—learning options that respond to the strengths and interests of our young people.
This amendment allows us to create a vocational specialist stream in VCE, replacing VCAL and moving towards an integrated senior secondary certificate by 2025. This will incorporate the best elements of VCAL. As the member for South Barwon said, this is particularly important not only in bringing our kids together and having them all on the same field when it comes to values, if you like, but also in helping them understand the amazing pathways that are available to them with the huge amount of work that is happening now in this state. Our major projects are creating so many jobs, so many opportunities, so many traineeships and so many apprenticeships for Victorians that our schoolkids need to be aware of and need to be able to grasp with both hands, if that is what they are interested in doing. Having this integrated certificate will really help our kids understand what is there; embrace the subjects, the training and the teaching methodologies that work for them; and give them the opportunities that they deserve, because every kid should be valued and every kid should have opportunities there for them to grasp. Every school should be able to realise the potential of each kid and help tailor and help them understand subjects that suit them the best, that will help them be the best that they can be, that will help them grasp those opportunities that there are waiting for them.
My partner and I have got a daughter who will be going into year 12 in 2023, and I know that she and her friends will embrace the opportunities that will come with the way that we are transforming VCE. They will embrace the opportunities that will be presented to them at Eltham High School, which is a fabulous high school, as are all the schools in my community. They have got dedicated teachers and they have got terrific kids. They are engaged and they want to excel and they want to be the best they can, and it is through creating opportunities in schools for our kids that we will help them embrace those opportunities, that we will help them be the best that they can be and that we will help these kids. It might be a line from—I have forgotten the name of the movie now—‘no kid left behind’, the New Zealand film. Anyway, we do not want kids left behind. No matter how cheesy that might sound, we do not want our kids left behind. We want them to be captured, we want them to be engaged and we want them to achieve their full potential. I support the amendments.
Ms SHEED (Shepparton) (12:45): I rise to make a contribution on the Education and Training Reform Amendment (Senior Secondary Pathways Reforms and Other Matters) Bill 2021—it is a very substantial name with a lot of very significant changes. The bill predominately will expand the powers of the Victorian Registration and Qualifications Authority and the Victorian Curriculum and Assessment Authority in the Education and Training Reform Act 2006 to create these new categories of foundation secondary course and foundation secondary qualifications to accommodate the new Victorian pathways certificate, and that in itself is really quite momentous. It will also facilitate the transition of a new senior secondary education certificate framework, including a new vocational major within the Victorian certificate of education. It also extends other powers within the act to facilitate all of this occurring.
I grew up on a farm. There were five of us in the family, and I think as the children grew up my parents realised very quickly that there was not enough room on the farm for everyone, even the boys. Education was seen as the pathway for all of my parent’s children, all of my brothers and sisters, and so that was the journey we all went on. It was a fantastic opportunity to be given an education at a secondary level and then have access to further education, whether it be university or agricultural colleges or the like. Two of my brothers went to Dookie Agricultural College. What a fantastic institution that is, and it is great to see that Melbourne University are now reinvesting in that campus. When I was elected to Parliament seven years ago we were all very worried as to whether that fabulous institution would continue to be downgraded and not used, and I do congratulate Melbourne University on seeing the value of it and also then offering a range of courses to various levels of students who are wanting to pursue different avenues. There is the agricultural degree of course, where 50 per cent of the graduates, I understand, end up in in some sort of agribusiness, dealing in overseas trading and many different things that are very different from on-the-ground farming. There is still a lot of work in that area for many of the graduates from Dookie Agricultural College, but there is also a 12-month course for young people who want to work on a farm, who want to try it out, have some education and skills and take up the opportunity that is there.
We have seen a significant decline in the number of farm workers over recent years. A lot of that is to do with the loss of water from our region and the reduction in the number of farms—a massive reduction in the number of dairy farms since 2000 across northern Victoria. They were significant employers of young people, of workers across a range of areas. So the reduction in the number of farmers and the mechanisation now in farming have led to less people on farm in many cases, except of course during fruit and vegetable harvesting, when you need those hands on the ground to pick fruit and vegetables—and mechanisation is yet to change that.
In Shepparton we were chosen for the Shepparton Education Plan in 2017. I recall that in this Parliament in 2016 my first grievance debate bemoaned the fact that educational outcomes in our regional communities of Shepparton and Mooroopna were considerably below the state average. We had falling attendances, we had lack of aspiration and we had poor educational outcomes and many young people leaving school at an earlier age before they established those pathways for themselves. The Shepparton Education Plan was initiated, and in those early stages I do not think there was a vision of what it might be. But after a couple of years of hard work and consultation with the community, with the department and with an advisory board working with the government, the ultimate plan that the government came up with and was prepared to fund, and which I supported, was the establishment of the Greater Shepparton Secondary College, which necessitated the bringing together of the four secondary schools: Mooroopna Secondary College, which had declined from about 800 students to 300 students; McGuire College; Wanganui Park Secondary College; and Shepparton High School.
The Shepparton High School site, very close to the middle of town, was chosen for the build of the new school, and never before in our community’s history has there been an investment in education such as we have seen emerge from the ground over the last 18 months—a new secondary college with nine schools within three neighbourhoods, with amazing gym facilities and with an enterprise centre. All of these things are built. The landscaping is being finished off as we speak, and all the teachers are making plans to move into this new school so that in 2022 all students will start there. It is a huge project, with so much work to be done around the logistics of bussing so many children and loading and off-loading children at school times. All these things have resulted in a huge amount of work being undertaken during the course of this year.
It is a beautiful building, but as we all know it is not just about buildings. It has been fantastic to see the excitement within the community about the new school. That is among the teachers who will have access to facilities that they truly deserve and have not had, and I would say the same about students. For the grade 6 students that are getting the opportunity to go through this school and see where they will be next year it has been truly delightful. It is jaw dropping for many of them to consider what they will have. Having that secondary college right on the edge of town, within walking distance of La Trobe University, to our TAFE college in Fryers Street, Shepparton, and of course to the CBD area really creates an education precinct that will be connected in Shepparton, and that is something to really value.
It does toss up the fact that our TAFE college is in need of very significant upgrade and refurbishment, particularly the Fryers Street campus. It highlights also that need for one of the technical colleges that this government has been rolling out in a number of places. Bendigo has one, and we are very keen to see Shepparton have one of these high-tech technical schools accessible to all the schools in the region—all schools. For young people to be able to come in and see the technology and what the future might look like for them really fits in with the notion of this legislation. It is very much about creating pathways, whether they be pathways to university, pathways to apprenticeships, pathways to high-tech areas or pathways into our agricultural and horticultural industries.
I will just say that the Lighthouse Project in Shepparton have been working with year 9 groups and taking groups of them out to Dookie agricultural college to see what that is all about, experience it, spend a week out there on the ground and start to formulate some vision about what their future might hold, given that they are currently living in an area where agriculture and horticulture are such predominant parts of what goes on.
It was interesting to hear the member for Broadmeadows speaking about the importance of place, and I think it does raise the question of being able to be educated in your own area, to continue living in it and to not have to go a long way away to study, and that of course often prevents people from studying in regional areas. So having access to these facilities, to these pathways, right throughout secondary college will, I think, create opportunities that will encourage young people to stay at school for much longer. I am really hoping that we will see the number of young people dropping out before they complete their final year change, and the breadth of subjects that will be available to young people in these sorts of settings with the new pathways certificate as well will really create much greater opportunity.
I have noticed that there is an incredible shortage of nurses in our community at the moment, and that is also something that we provide in Shepparton.
Ms HUTCHINS (Sydenham—Minister for Crime Prevention, Minister for Corrections, Minister for Youth Justice, Minister for Victim Support) (12:55): I rise to speak on the Education and Training Reform Amendment (Senior Secondary Pathways Reforms and Other Matters) Bill 2021. Can I begin by thanking the students, teachers, principals, staff and parents that have delivered at-home learning over the last 20 months on and off. They have done an extraordinary job.
Before going on to talk about the specifics of the bill can I reflect on the importance of education to Victoria. In my ministerial responsibilities I have seen the importance of education for keeping young people away from the justice system. Giving young people the best education and training and keeping them engaged is the best that we can do to help them thrive through the rest of their lives. This was underscored to me recently when I joined an online round table of school principals from across the western suburbs that was convened by my colleague the member for Tarneit. Here I heard about the momentous work that our educators are doing to keep at-risk young people safe, resilient and connected. This is priceless work, and I commend them for everything that they are doing.
This is one of the guiding principles of this government’s Crime Prevention Strategy, which has been investing in multiple projects to keep young people engaged at school. The Crime Prevention Strategy outlines how the government will tackle the drivers of offending before the offence occurs in order to keep Victorians safe at every stage of their lives. It is underpinned with more than $30 million worth of investments. This bill we are debating today complements that investment and focuses the Andrews Labor government on education across the government as a whole. It will create new categories of foundation secondary courses and foundation secondary qualifications to accommodate a new Victorian pathways certificate. It will also facilitate the transition to a new senior secondary education certificate framework so that students will be able to enrol in a vocational major within VCE. This is a great achievement and a great step forward.
The bill also goes on to outline the new Victorian pathways certificate and vocational major within VCE. I know this is an important step for my community. The bill will also allow for the Victorian Registration and Qualifications Authority to conduct the accreditation process for the new certificate framework, facilitating an orderly transition for senior secondary providers into the new system.
Can I commend the Minister for Education, the member for Monbulk, for the extensive consultation that he has undertaken with students, employers, educators and education experts in designing and introducing these new changes. By involving students we know that these new pathways will reflect their aspirations and perspectives.
Can I also give a shout-out to all those students about to sit year 12 exams at schools such as Copperfield College, Springside West, Overnewton Anglican Community College, Taylors Lakes Secondary College, Lakeview Senior College and Keilor Downs. Can I also finally extend my best wishes to my own year 12 student, Xavier, and thank his teachers, who have been absolutely instrumental through his time at St Bernard’s—Mr John Samanna, Ms Glenny, Mr Nunan, Mr Clive Haese and Mr James Toohey—for supporting him in his years. I know he looks forward to finishing up year 12 this Friday, as does my nephew Gus Sykes, who is also doing year 12. I will leave my comments there and support the bill.
Business interrupted under resolution of house of 7 October.