Tuesday, 12 October 2021


Business of the house

Program


Ms ALLAN, Ms STALEY, Mr FOWLES, Ms KEALY

Business of the house

Program

 Ms ALLAN (Bendigo East—Leader of the House, Minister for Transport Infrastructure, Minister for the Suburban Rail Loop) (09:19): I move:

That, under standing order 94(2), the orders of the day, government business, relating to the following bills be considered and completed by 2.00 pm on Thursday, 14 October 2021:

Children, Youth and Families Amendment (Child Protection) Bill 2021

Education and Training Reform Amendment (Senior Secondary Pathways Reforms and Other Matters) Bill 2021

Health Legislation Amendment (Information Sharing) Bill 2021

Terrorism (Community Protection) Amendment Bill 2021.

I only intend to make a few brief comments on the government business program that the government has moved this morning for the house’s endorsement. I am hopeful that this will be a government business program that will be strongly supported because it is a strong government business program. It is further evidence that the government each and every week is bringing forward a suite of legislative reform that is designed to implement policy work, to implement election commitments and to build a stronger Victorian community. If you look at the policy areas that are canvassed in the government business program this week, from education and health information to important work in child protection and also in community protection around terrorism, there is a lot to debate and a lot to consider over the course of this parliamentary week by members in this chamber. As I say, it is with optimism each and every week that I look forward to the house’s support for and endorsement of the government business program.

For completeness, the government will move after the government business motion to the Assisted Reproductive Treatment Amendment Bill 2021 to deal with the amendments that have returned from the Legislative Council, which are reasonably straightforward. Then finally, as I have indicated to members across the chamber privately, on the COVID-19 vaccination requirements motion that I have just given notice of for debate later this week, it is the government’s intention that this motion be debated on Thursday. It was decided it was an appropriate opportunity for members to have time to review the motion. I will not go into too much of the detail of the motion—that will be more for Thursday—other than to acknowledge there has been already a lot of discussion and work both across the chamber. I particularly acknowledge the Manager of Opposition Business for the work we have done over the past week and also across the Parliament with colleagues in the Legislative Council, and I would also like to acknowledge the support of the clerks.

Again, I do not want to stray too much into the detail of the motion other than to say I felt it was appropriate that members had a good couple of days to review the motion and to reflect on their own personal circumstances and how they may or may not comply with the requirements in the motion, because this is one of the more challenging motions, I think, that has come before the Parliament, because obviously, as the motion states, non-compliance results in suspension. That is not something that any chamber should take lightly, and that is why there is the opportunity over the next two days for colleagues to review it. And I would really encourage colleagues who do have any questions or issues to please seek out advice from the clerks, because this has been very carefully put together, carefully crafted, in order to address a number of issues but also to make it very clear that this is not to be precedent setting and that it is confined to the circumstances related to the COVID-19 pandemic, which obviously is continuing to affect our community as it is communities right around the world.

So that is the plan for Thursday. As I have said, the rest of the government business program is a strong one. I look forward to the strong debate and participation of colleagues on the agenda before the house, but right now I most look forward to this government business motion being supported. I commend the motion to the house.

 Ms STALEY (Ripon) (09:23): On this occasion the opposition will not be opposing the government business program. We understand that there are four bills on the program, as the Leader of the House has just explained. We also note that the house will be debating the motion that the Leader of the House has just given notice for. The Leader of the House has indicated that will be on Thursday, and I join in saying that this is a serious matter that we will be debating on Thursday. It is a difficult matter, not so much, could I say, in relation to supporting vaccination; I think there is strong support across the house for that. However, the consequences of this motion are significant. They are important, and it is of the utmost importance that we, to the greatest extent possible, corral what we are doing here to this specific instance of why we would take this action. And this does have consequences for how we look at the privileges of the house, how we look at the various constitutional mechanisms that are available to both the houses individually but also to external bodies. There are many deep issues in relation to the motion that will be moved on Thursday. I think it is appropriate that we take a couple of days from the time that members have first seen this motion to give everybody the opportunity to think and to ask the clerks—and I agree with the Leader of the House that the clerks have been of immense help and assistance in advising me as Manager of Opposition Business as to how various things can be done or not done, and I thank them for that specifically. They are always marvellous, but in relation to this they have been very, very helpful indeed. As I said, we will not be opposing the government business program, and we look forward to getting on with it.

 Mr FOWLES (Burwood) (09:25): I thank the member for Ripon, the Manager of Opposition Business, for her support of the government business program.

Ms Staley interjected.

Mr FOWLES: But it is such good fun, the government business program. Look, it is a very important government business program that the chamber is considering this week, and I did just want to make a couple of brief comments, particularly about the matter to which the Manager of Opposition Business refers. I concur: this is a very serious matter. It is a very, very substantial thing for any parliament to contemplate suspension of members from the chamber, and I am very pleased that we are having that debate this week. It is an important debate. It is a debate that I hope will be conducted with due deference to the science and the health advice and the very serious health circumstances we find ourselves in. So I am very pleased that that motion will form part of the debate this week. In addition to that of course we have four bills. We are getting on with the business of governing, as indeed we should, and I look forward to the week unfolding.

 Ms KEALY (Lowan) (09:27): As flagged by the Manager of Opposition Business, we will not be opposing the government business program today. There are of course the significant matters that we will be debating this week. The motion around mandatory vaccination is of great significance in potentially setting a precedent for how we as parliamentarians suspend members within this place. I certainly know that within my own electorate there has been a lot of discussion around mandatory vaccination as opposed to people who are anti-vaccination, but also there are people who can see that there may be other options that need to be investigated around mandatory vax. I do not think there are many people in the community or within this place who are opposed to vaccination. I think in fact many are fully vaxxed at this point in time. Many people have made that decision that they wish to equip their body in the best possible way to minimise the way that COVID will impact on them. And as parliamentarians we have a different job: we work within our communities, often with people who are immunocompromised or elderly, and therefore we have different responsibilities apart from just what we do and how we operate within this chamber. So I look forward to the motion that will be debated on Thursday. I am appreciative of the comments by the manager of government business around giving all members a couple of days notice to be able to get their thoughts together or get vaccinated if they choose to but also to be able to completely weigh up and do their research and talk to others around what their position should be on that very important motion for this chamber.

It is a disappointment that we did not see that same suitable length of time for the Health Legislation Amendment (Information Sharing) Bill 2021, which is also set down for this week. This is a significant bill, and there really was not a lot of information given during the bill briefing. We would have liked to be able to take this bill into consideration in detail. I would like to refer this bill to a committee, and I will give notice of such tomorrow—to the Legal and Social Issues Committee—to delve down into how this will actually operate and how it will work with other federal requirements around the My Health Record and also around mandated consent to release your health information to every single public health service in the state and for that information to be shared without an opt-in or opt-out opportunity. I would love for those matters to be discussed through a committee and for an inquiry to take place; however, we have not had that opportunity at this stage. So while the government business program is supported, we see some interesting issues that will come up during the week, and we look forward particularly to be able to debate the motion around mandatory vaccination.

Motion agreed to.