Tuesday, 12 October 2021
Bills
Children, Youth and Families Amendment (Child Protection) Bill 2021
-
Commencement
-
Announcements
-
Bills
-
Business of the house
-
Petitions
-
Documents
-
Bills
-
Motions
-
Bills
-
Questions without notice and ministers statements
-
Business of the house
-
Members statements
-
Constituency questions
-
Adjournment
Bills
Children, Youth and Families Amendment (Child Protection) Bill 2021
Second reading
Debate resumed on motion of Mr PEARSON:
That this bill be now read a second time.
Ms KEALY (Lowan) (13:36): I rise today to speak on the Children, Youth and Families Amendment (Child Protection) Bill 2021. This is important legislation which will help to support our vulnerable children, particularly those who have fallen through the gaps for far too long. This bill will rest upon three pillars, which are to modernise the legislative framework by decreasing over-representation of Aboriginal children and young people in care, implement the Home Stretch program and shift, in some small way, from a crisis management response to one of early intervention. I think for not just members of this chamber but also the wider community we certainly see this as something that absolutely should be happening and perhaps is too late, if anything.
We know that there have been enormous issues within child protection that are just escalating over time. There has been a 150 per cent rise in children dying while in state care or being known to authorities. In fact, last year there were 65 children who died who were known to authorities. This is an absolute tragedy and a travesty for these vulnerable people, where people have gone out of their way to report that these children are at risk and where we expect that government agencies will do all that they can to support these vulnerable children, to intervene when necessary but most importantly to provide support to those families so that everybody within that family community is best equipped to make sure that they have a positive, loving and supportive household. We need to make sure that they do have a roof over their head and that they are not exposed to negative things that we see so often that translate from generation to generation in vulnerable households, whether it is about homelessness or whether it is family violence—which we know has been of enormous prevalence in the community and escalating during the coronavirus pandemic, particularly under the restrictions where kids have not been able to go to school, where workers have not been able to go to work, where some of them have lost their jobs and where people are being put under incredible mental health pressure and they cannot connect with their friends and family members, where they may not be able to get that external support to look after their child or help through homeschooling. These are the kids that are falling through the gaps, and if nothing else our biggest priority as parliamentarians should be to make sure that every single child gets given the best possible start to life.
That comes under an enormous range of responsibilities, and I think all too often we think about it in terms of the privileges that we have been given in our own lives. I have been very, very fortunate to grow up in a loving and lovely household, to be given good role models and to be guided when I am not making good decisions in how I can make a better decision. I have been supported through my education, I have been supported to get into the workforce and I have been supported when I have been sick so that I have been able to get the medical support that I need. I have also been protected in so many ways from other things that happen in the community.
I think I am very fortunate that I was raised in the country in a rural community, where you cannot discriminate and you do not discriminate around who you engage with. The kids you go to school with are not all from that same clique of the same socio-economic bubble that you belong to. You certainly have to cut across age divides as well as ethnicity, different religions—all of those barriers are broken down and you learn to treat people with respect, to give them the respect that they deserve and to treat everybody like a human being. In some way I wish that everybody was able to be given the gift of the opportunity of being raised in a small community. That is the most important thing. Growing up in a town of 1000 people in Edenhope has certainly helped to mould me into the person that I am today.
We do need to make sure that we do have appropriate early interventions for children who are most at risk of some of the negative outcomes that happen in their life. We know that a lot of these matters can be intergenerational, and it is very, very difficult to break that cycle, and it is a challenge that governments across Australia and across the world are doing their best to try and tackle. That is why this legislation and supporting the Home Stretch program and also the recommendations of the Our Youth, Our Way report by the Commission for Children and Young People will help to make sure that no child is left behind and every child is given the best possible start to life.
There are a number of amendments and changes that this bill will bring into place. It will seek to incorporate further Aboriginal child placement principles in the Children, Youth and Families Act 2005; to extend the secretary’s powers to provide advice and assistance if there are significant concerns for the wellbeing of an unborn child; to make amendments relating to the use of seclusion and secure welfare services; to make amendments relating to childcare agreements; to expand the information disclosure provisions in the Children, Youth and Families Act 2005; to create an offence for reprisal actions against persons who make good-faith reports or referrals; to extend time for the hearing of an application for an interim accommodation order after a child is placed in emergency care; to remove bail justice powers in relation to child protection; to amend provisions requiring certain applications and notices to be served on a child of or above 12 years of age so the application or notice must instead be served on a child of 10 years or above; to clarify the paramount considerations in case management of child protection proceedings in the family division; to prevent personal cross-examination in child protection proceedings in the family division of a witness by an unrepresented party where there is family violence or alleged family violence between that party and the witness; to amend the provisions relating to the provision of medical treatments to children who are subject to the Children, Youth and Families Act 2005; to provide for the secretary to authorise a person in charge of a community care agency to act in relation to a child; to limit the circumstances in which the secretary may direct a parent to resume parental responsibility of a child under a family reunification order or a care or secretary order; to change certain terminology used in the Children, Youth and Families Act 2005; to make provision for the support of young people making a transition to adulthood; and consequently to amend the Victoria Police Act 2013 and other acts.
It is quite complex. It is quite technical in nature, what this bill covers; however, the intention is to provide a stronger framework, particularly around how we can best support our Aboriginal youth, who all too often end up in a little bit of trouble at school—that early intervention is not provided to them and then the next thing they know, they are in court. That is certainly something that is highlighted very comprehensively in the Our Youth, Our Way report by the Commission for Children and Young People, and I commend all members of the house to give this a read, because it does give an impressive oversight into what is happening at the moment and how so often particularly Aboriginal children are disenfranchised from the decision-making around their care, their support and how they often enter the justice system when they should have been supported and things could have been done better to avert them from that position in their life.
I note that there are elements of this report that refer to the importance of experiences of different Aboriginal children and the positive influence that it had on them when they were reunified with their elders and they were given access to some of the traditional supports and activities of their traditional family group. And that is something that for me is great to see—that there is that linkage to some of those cultural and heritage activities of the past that otherwise might be forgotten.
I had the great privilege to work in Alice Springs for a number of years, and Darwin as well, and so have been fortunate in spending a lot of time in Aboriginal communities. I recall there was a fantastic program in one of the Aboriginal communities where they did a lot of early interventional work with kids who were really at risk of taking either that left or right pathway in life. They could go down the pathway where they were just starting to perhaps not attend school; they might have been doing some minor crimes; they might have started drinking or sniffing petrol and some of those activities that could end up with them winding up on a very negative pathway in life. The local community would identify these kids who were at risk, and they would take them out bush for a couple of weeks. They would teach them traditional tracking techniques. They would also live off the land—they would be hunting kangaroos and other wildlife, living on bush tucker for that period of time—and it really helped to reconnect those youths with their traditional culture. The results were profound in that community in that not only did it help to ensure that those youths, the future elders in that community, were strongly connected with their culture and to their land, but they were also then given that pathway of mentorship with senior people in the community, the elders, around the importance of their culture and why they need it to be preserved and they need it to be remembered and celebrated and passed on from generation to generation. So not only did it help get these kids on the right track but it also helped to preserve the culture in that community and strengthen the culture in that community.
There are certainly elements of this report from the Commission for Children and Young People which emphasise that importance of connection to culture and to community and to their land. So it is positive to see in many ways the evidence and what we know works in other areas, not just of this state but of other areas where there are Indigenous populations, and that strong culture and heritage that remain. Perhaps we can use that knowledge in Victoria to re-establish connection to culture and traditions where it otherwise may have been lost. So that is very positive, and if we can help to empower, particularly, Aboriginal children to connect to their culture, connect to the community and find value and pride in what they do and what they can contribute to their own family group, to their own Indigenous community but also the wider Victorian community, then Victoria will end up a far, far better place.
This legislation will also work towards putting into legislation the Home Stretch program. This is a really important program that provides government support for the transition to adulthood for kids that would otherwise be seen as vulnerable people who then hit that critical age group where they have gone from being in home care until 18 and all of the government supports are cut off from them. It is just like, ‘Oh, well, you’re at age now. Good luck. I hope we’ve given you enough support’. Too often that is just too early to cut loose the support that is provided from government, and too often we end up with those children becoming homeless in the years that follow. I believe that there is a really high rate particularly in the two years that follow that coming into adulthood—that the rate of homelessness really is at very, very high levels. So it is clear that we need to do more around providing that early intervention and support.
The Home Stretch program provides an accommodation allowance, casework support and flexible funding to facilitate the young person’s access to education, employment and health and wellbeing support through to the age of 21. Now, I would like to think that if that requirement needed to be continued after they turned 21, again, we would not see that as a drop-off-the-cliff point where we were not going to ever provide any financial support to that person, because there will be some people who absolutely will be well equipped to find their pathway through life and be able to do that themselves and with their own networks that they have, but there will be some that will not—and we cannot simply turn our backs on those kids and say, ‘We’re not willing to provide support to you anymore’. We need to make sure we can support as many people as we can, to stop people falling through the cracks, to stop them falling into the justice system and the endless cycle of that and some of the negative influences that can have on people’s lives, which then influences the next generation and the next generation. So this is about breaking that cycle as much as anything else. Home Stretch is available to young people on a family reunification order, a care by secretary order or a long-term care order leaving care services from 16 years of age. So it really is making sure they have got that support from just before they turn 16—15 years and nine months—right up to their 18th birthday and then making sure that from their 18th to their 21st birthday they do have that very, very important support.
I am very proud that the Liberal and National parties were very strong on providing a framework for this reform when we were in government. We know we have not been in government a lot of the last 20 years—in fact I think we have been in government for just four of the past 21 years—so I am proud that in that time we were in government we made significant changes around this and put a framework in place to provide better support to young people. And that was particularly through the protecting vulnerable children inquiry of 2011. I will pay great credit to the then Minister for Mental Health, Mary Wooldridge, who did an amazing amount of work in this space to help protect vulnerable children. We know that stakeholders have been calling for significant legislative changes to improve that transition for young people leaving out-of-home care into adulthood and making sure they have got a roof over their head and other supports.
We have been calling for this for a very long time, as I said—that shift from providing late-stage care to early intervention to stop people from needing that later-on support, which does so much more harm to our community. From the government’s perspective it costs a lot more money as well, so there is no good reason not to be moving on this as quickly as we possibly can. I refer to that number I referred to before: new reporting shows that 54 per cent of young care leavers in Victoria experience homelessness within four years—54 per cent within four years. We need to have Home Stretch, we need to have it legislated and we need to make sure it is supported so that we can support those that are most vulnerable and most prone to becoming homeless in our community.
In addition, we have got over-representation of Aboriginal children in the child protection system, which has been a longstanding issue that has only grown under the Victorian Labor government. In fact one in 10 Indigenous Victorian children is in care—one in 10 Indigenous kids in Victoria is in care. That is a higher proportion than in any other Australian jurisdiction, and it shows that we need to do so much more in that space. We need to be doing a lot to close the gap and actually make a difference, for Indigenous kids in particular but the entire Indigenous population, around closing the gap in education and closing the gap in health outcomes, to make sure that people are not homeless and, most importantly, to make sure that kids are not more likely—in fact one in 10 of them—to be in care. That is a terrible statistic and a terrible measurement of how this government is going in terms of caring for our Aboriginal children.
This government recently entered into an Aboriginal children and families agreement. I will interpret this in my best Alice Springs interpretation of Indigenous language, and I apologise to the language owner group that this relates to: Wungurilwil Gapgapduir. Part of this agreement entails facilitating autonomy and self-determination among Aboriginal groups. As part of this the bill seeks to endow Aboriginal organisations with greater power to enable Aboriginal children to be reunited with their family. This is in keeping with longstanding calls from the coalition for greater power to be handed to community agencies at the expense of the government. This is something that we wholly endorse.
In summary, this bill will seek to make a number of changes to the legislative framework which supports our children in out-of-home care, but particularly Aboriginal children. We have been calling for these changes for a very, very long time, and while we have waited a long time to see those changes, I am hopeful that with these changes in place we will reduce that horrible statistic of one in 10 Aboriginal children being in care and that we will reverse those horrible numbers of 65 children dying while they have been known by Victorian government authorities to be vulnerable. When we look at the increasing rate of children who are reported to child protection authorities, we are now up to about 120 000 children every year in Victoria. These are horrific rates, and it is clear that more needs to be done to support our children, particularly through the coronavirus pandemic, where we have seen a significant increase in the number of children who have been victims of sexual abuse and victims of family violence falling through the cracks—when they cannot go to school, when they have not got those family connections, when they cannot talk to their mates. We have even got reduced access to face-to-face supports where they feel safe, which can happen through school; it can happen through counsellors. All the counsellors in my region are currently doing things virtually, which does not work for kids who do not have access to that sort of technology.
We need to make sure we do all we can to reopen, recover and rebuild Victoria, because it is not just about getting business up and running; it is also about making sure that kids are not unnecessarily put in more harm than if they had gotten coronavirus in the first place. The statistics are showing us that the coronavirus restrictions have been incredibly damaging to a generation of children. We need to make sure that these kids are supported well into the future to make sure the mental health harms and the other violence I have spoken of can be dealt with as soon as possible, because we know that the longer that that is not dealt with, the more likelihood there is that there will be lifelong harms and lifelong support required and of course there is a far greater chance of these kids being reported to authorities, it being seen that they are vulnerable, and adding to the statistics, which are much more than just a terrible set of numbers; there is actually a child at the end of every single one of them. The Liberal-National parties support this bill, and I commend the bill to the house.
Ms BLANDTHORN (Pascoe Vale) (13:57): I also appreciate an opportunity, albeit a very brief one because I understand, Speaker, you are required to adjourn the chamber in just a few minutes, to contribute to the debate on this extremely important bill, the Children, Youth and Families Amendment (Child Protection) Bill 2021. When I was first elected to this place, in my inaugural speech I talked about how the thing that motivates me the most is being able to make a contribution, in all the work I have done over many decades but particularly in this place. As my grandmother once said, ‘Who will speak if I don’t for those who can’t speak for themselves?’. Children indeed are at the very core of this, and indeed children in particular who are in difficult circumstances, vulnerable children, need all of us in this place to speak in favour of their rights and in favour of their needs and their concerns. I appreciate the comments of the member for Lowan and the indication that those opposite will also support this bill.
This bill is vitally important in ensuring the utmost level of care, connection and support in our system to protect vulnerable children in the Victorian community. The bill will progress the Victorian government’s Roadmap for Reform: Strong Families, Safe Children, a road map that establishes a blueprint for transforming the child and family system in our state from one that is about crisis response to earlier interventions and prevention. This road map is part of our continuous effort to protect young people, to reduce vulnerability and to work to ensure that all children can reach their full potential, no matter what their postcode is, no matter what their background is and no matter what their start in life is. Our child protection system, alongside the education and health systems, needs to be equipped with the appropriate legislation, the appropriate resources, the workforce, the services and the tailored supports that will keep our children safe and that will strengthen families and strengthen communities. Every Victorian needs to be supported to live a healthy, fulfilled childhood, adolescence and young adulthood, backed by an excellent education—a journey that is one of hope and a journey that is one of opportunity.
This system needs consistent review, reform and modernisation to lift children and families up and to ensure that no-one is at risk of falling behind, and the system must also continuously work to respond to all communities, especially those that are most at risk. We must work to reduce the over-representation of Aboriginal children in care, prioritise self-determination and facilitate Aboriginal models of care delivered by Aboriginal community controlled organisations. We all can attest to the positive impact of diversity in Victoria and that it is our cultural differences that make us stronger.
Business interrupted under resolution of house of 7 October.
The SPEAKER: Order! I might interrupt the member at that point because I am required to interrupt business under the resolution of the house. The house is now adjourned.
House adjourned 2.00 pm.