Tuesday, 12 October 2021


Questions without notice and ministers statements

Independent Broad-based Anti-corruption Commission


Mr T SMITH, Mr ANDREWS

Independent Broad-based Anti-corruption Commission

 Mr T SMITH (Kew) (13:26): My question is to the Premier. Have staff in the Premier’s office ever been used for branch-stacking operations?

 Mr ANDREWS (Mulgrave—Premier) (13:26): I thank the member for Kew for his question. Not that I am aware of. Staff in my office and staff across the government—

A member interjected.

Mr ANDREWS: Staff in my office work extremely hard every day of the week to support the people of this great state in the delivery of our policy agenda, whether that be removing more level crossings; not only saving TAFE from others but making it better than it has ever been, and free for so many; building literally hundreds and hundreds of new schools and upgraded schools across our community; making kinder free and accessible, and 15 hours for the vast majority of three-year-olds; or supporting our nurses and doctors and ambos and everyone across the health system—not just with record funding, record capital works investment, but also responding in the midst of a one-in-100-year event with that surge capacity allowance announced today by my honourable friend who is doing an outstanding job as Minister for Health. I can go on and on.

That is exactly what my staff do. I am not sure what the member for Kew’s staff get up to, but what my staff are about is working hard every single day to deliver our commitments for the Victorian community. I am happy to go on because there are many, many more of them: suburban roads, regional roads, mental health—the biggest reform agenda in mental health in the history of this nation. You can add up pretty much every new dollar in mental health across the country and you will not get to the investment that the Treasurer put down in the budget delivered early this year. Family violence—my honourable friend the Minister for Prevention of Family Violence is here in the chamber today—not only Australia’s first and only royal commission, but the full commitment to deliver every single one of those recommendations. Better attitudes towards women for better outcomes for women, safety for women and children, more support: three and a half thousand million dollars more than every other government across this country combined.

As I said, there are too many of these things to refer to, but they are all part of the precious gift given to us by the Victorian community—their trust and their mandate to get on and get things done—and that is exactly what my team and I and my staff do every day, every week, every year that we have the honour of governing and leading this state.

 Mr T SMITH (Kew) (13:29): Currently former state government staffer Ellen Schreiber is giving evidence at IBAC about her participation in branch-stacking activity. Is her legal representation being paid for by the taxpayer?

Ms Allan: On a point of order, Speaker, again, the house would appreciate your guidance on how that supplementary question is relevant to the substantive question. You ruled earlier today and made very clear to the member for Kew the requirements needed to be met for supplementary questions to be in order. I suggest you rule this question out of order because it does not relate to the substantive question in an adequate way, as you have ruled just a few—probably 20—minutes earlier today in question time.

Ms Staley: On the point of order, Speaker, the original question by the member for Kew asked about ministerial staff of the Premier. All ministerial staff are employed by the Premier, so this is clearly a staff member of the Premier. It clearly relates to the original question. It also, I have got to say, talks about both the substantive and the supplementary and relates specifically to the corruption hearings that are going on.

The SPEAKER: Order! I do not uphold the point of order. The supplementary question I believe was relevant to the answer and the question that was asked as a substantial question.

 Mr ANDREWS (Mulgrave—Premier) (13:30): I thank the member for Kew for his question. I am uncertain as to the exact status of the person that the member for Kew references. I understand she was performing executive assistant functions to a then minister. I am not sure whether she was a departmental secondee, a member of administrative staff or a member of ministerial staff. However, regardless of those matters I am just making it clear I am not certain about her status. Further to the point that the member for Ripon made in relation to all ministerial staff being essentially employed by my chief of staff, right, just to that point, I am not certain about what her staffing status is.

In relation to her legal representation, the first that I was aware that she would be appearing at IBAC—I do not know that I have necessarily met her, I may have—was when I saw press reports of that happening. I am uncertain if she has legal representation in the first instance—I do not even know whether she has counsel. If she does, I am equally uncertain who is paying for them. If I could add anything to that answer, I would. (Time expired)