Tuesday, 12 October 2021


Questions without notice and ministers statements

Independent Broad-based Anti-corruption Commission


Mr T SMITH, Mr ANDREWS

Independent Broad-based Anti-corruption Commission

 Mr T SMITH (Kew) (13:04): My question is to the Premier. Noting the member for Narre Warren North has resigned from the ministry after being adversely named in anti-corruption hearings, will the Premier stand down other ministers who are also adversely named in these anti-corruption hearings?

 Mr ANDREWS (Mulgrave—Premier) (13:05): I will not thank the member for Kew for that because it is simply wrong. The minister was not stood down. As a clear examination of the facts: he rang me, he resigned and that, I think, puts an end to the rather—well, I do not know what you would call that. It is simply wrong. It is simply factually wrong, as is so much from the honourable member for Kew.

 Mr T SMITH (Kew) (13:05): My question is to the Premier. Have staff from the Premier’s electorate, former ministerial or current Premier’s office ever been used for branch-stacking operations?

The SPEAKER: Order! The supplementary question needs to relate to both the substantive question and the answer provided, so I offer the opportunity for the member for Kew to rephrase his question so that it relates to the answer and the question.

Mr T SMITH: Noting the Premier’s previous answer, have staff in the Premier’s office ever been used for branch-stacking operations?

The SPEAKER: Order! I rule the question out of order. It does not relate to the substantive question.

Ms Staley: On the ruling you have just made, Speaker, the point of order that I raise is that these questions are clearly to do with the anti-corruption hearings that are going on right now, and I would—

Members interjecting.

The SPEAKER: Order! The member for Ripon has the call.

Ms Staley: There is currently a ministerial staff member on the stand at IBAC, so clearly there is an issue that staff and ministers are related here, and I just would argue that it is a legitimate question.

Members interjecting.

The SPEAKER: Order! I will rule on this point of order. I am happy to take the member for Kew’s point of order in a moment. So that the house is aware, supplementary questions are able to be asked:

At the conclusion of each answer to an oral question without notice, the questioning member may ask the responding minister a supplementary question to elucidate or clarify the answer.

Supplementary questions must actually and accurately relate to the original question, must relate to or arise from the answer and must not be a separate question on the same topic.

There are some key tests there for a supplementary question to meet for it to be in order, and I offered the opportunity for the member for Kew to rephrase his question.

Mr Guy: On a further point of order, Speaker, the primary question that was asked of the Premier related to the current anti-corruption hearings which are being conducted over branch stacking. The supplementary question which was asked of the Premier was in direct relation to the current inquiry, which related to the primary question over branch stacking. It even mentioned it. One is in direct correlation to the other.

The SPEAKER: Order! The Leader of the Opposition I think is correct in that the subject matter of the substantive question was the same, but as I have just read out, a supplementary question ‘must not be a separate question on the same topic’. And that is what I have ruled.