Alert Digest No 11 of 2000
14 November 2000


Summary of Committee Comments

Ministerial Correspondence

Children and Young Persons (Reciprocal Arrangements) Bill
Public Lotteries Bill
Whistleblowers Protection Bill

Appendix 1 – Index of Bills Reported 2000
Appendix 2 – Committee Comments classified by Terms of Reference


Building (Legionella) Bill

Entire Speech.gif (2160 bytes) ltscale[1].gif (2236 bytes) Display Bill Content

 

Introduced: 1 November 2000
Second Reading Speech: 2 November 2000
House: Legislative Assembly
Minister: Hon. J. Thwaites MLA with the Hon. P. Batchelor MLA.

Purpose

The purpose of the Bill is to –

  • amend the Building Act 1993 to –

(i) require the registration of cooling tower systems; and

(ii) require the preparation and regular audit of risk management plans in relation to cooling tower systems.

  • amend the Health Act 1958 to ensure that that Act provides adequate powers to enable the making of regulations dealing with legionellosis and other infectious diseases.

Content and Committee comment

Clause 2 sections 1, 2, 3, 10, 11 and 14 come into operation on the day after Royal Assent. The remaining provisions come into operation on proclamation but not later than by 1 January 2002.

Amendments to the Building Act 1993

Clause 4 inserts an additional object of the Act into as section 4(i) being – ‘to regulate cooling tower systems.’

Clause 5 inserts new Parts 5A, 5B and 5C into the Act.

Part 5A – Registration of Cooling Tower Systems

Part 5A deals with the registration of cooling tower systems. The Part consists on new sections 75A to 75DH.

75A – defines the meaning of ‘cooling tower’ and 75AB defines the meaning of ‘cooling tower system’.

75BA – the owner of any land on which there is a cooling tower system must apply to register the system with the Commission within 6 months after section 5 comes into operation.

75BD – a person applying to renew the registration of a cooling tower system under this Division for the first time must include with the application form a statement as to whether or not a risk management plan has been prepared in respect of the system.

75CA – the owner of any land on which there is a cooling tower system must apply to register the system with the Commission before the system is brought into operation.

A person applying to register a cooling tower system under the Division must include with the application form a statement as to whether or not a risk management plan has been prepared.

75CE – a person applying to renew the registration of a system must include with the application form a statement that a risk management plan has, or has not, been prepared in respect of the system; and if a risk management plan has been prepared a statement that the plan has, or has not, been reviewed in the 12 months before the statement was made; and was, or was not, the subject of a risk management plan audit in the 3 months before the registration was due to expire.

75DE – within 30 days after the date the ownership of the land changes, the new owner of the land must notify the Commission in writing of the change of ownership.

75DG – a person must not make any false statement, or give any false information, in an application for the registration, or the renewal of registration, of a cooling tower system.

Part 5B – Risk Management Plans For Cooling Tower Systems

75E – a risk management plan for a cooling tower system is a document that identifies risks associated with the use of the system and that sets out the steps to be taken to manage the risks; and to ensure compliance with any requirements relating to the system imposed by, or under, the Act or the Health Act 1958.

75EA – the owner of any land on which there is a cooling tower system must take all reasonable steps to ensure that a risk management plan is prepared in respect of the system.

75EB – the owner of any land on which there is a cooling tower system must take all reasonable steps to ensure that the risk management plan prepared in respect of the system is reviewed, and, if necessary, updated, at least once in every registration period.

75EC – the owner of any land on which there is a cooling tower system must take all reasonable steps to ensure that a record is kept of all repair, maintenance and testing work that is carried out on the system; and that the record is kept for at least 7 years after it was created.

75ED – the owner of any land on which there is a cooling tower system must take all reasonable steps to ensure that the risk management plan in respect of the system and any records required by section 75EC in relation to the system are kept at the building in which the system is in or on; or (b) if the system is not in or on a building, at a building on the lot of land on which the system is located.

75FA – the owner of any land on which there is a cooling tower system must take all reasonable steps to ensure that a risk management plan audit is conducted in relation to the risk management plan prepared in respect of the system in the 3 months before the registration of the system is due to expire.

75GA – a person must not conduct a risk management plan audit unless he or she is an approved auditor.

75H - Regulations

The Governor in Council may make regulations for or with respect to –

(a) specifying the matters to be included in risk management plans;

(b) specifying how risk management plans are to be reviewed and updated;

(c) specifying the form and manner, and the matters to be included in, any records that are required to be kept under this Part;

(d) prescribing fees in relation to the certification of approved auditors;

(e) generally providing for any other matter or thing required or permitted by this Part to be prescribed or necessary to be prescribed to give effect to this Part.

The Committee notes the regulation making powers provided in new section 75H and accepts that they are appropriate to give effect to the purposes of the Act.

Part 5C – Enforcement of Parts 5A and 5B

The Part inserts new sections 75J to 75JE dealing with the appointment of inspectors and their powers.

75J provides that ‘inspector’ means any person authorised by the Secretary to the Department of Human Services for the purposes of the Part.

The Committee notes that ‘any person’ may be appointed as an inspector pursuant to new section 75J.

The Committee resolved to seek further advice from the Minister in respect to the category and or the qualifications of persons that may be appointed as inspectors for the purposes of the new provisions introduced by the Bill.

75JC – self-incrimination provision –

(1) It is a reasonable excuse for a natural person to refuse or fail to give information or do any other thing that the person is required to do by or under this Part, if the giving of the information or the doing of that other thing would tend to incriminate the person.

(2) Despite sub-section (1), it is not a reasonable excuse for a natural person to refuse or fail to produce a document that the person is required to produce by or under this Part, if the production of the document would tend to incriminate the person.

The Committee notes the modified self-incrimination provision and accepts that the system of registration of cooling tower systems, risk management plans and audits created by the Bill and the consequent difficulty of effectively prosecuting offenders under the Act without recourse to documents and records presents a reasonable case for the use of such a provision.

75JD – an inspector who obtains information while acting as an inspector may disclose the information to any person carrying out a relevant function if the inspector reasonably believes that the information may assist that person in carrying out that function.

75JE – an inspector may issue a person with an improvement notice requiring the person to take specified action within a specified period to stop the contravention, or failure to comply, from continuing or occurring again.

Clause 6 inserts an additional function ‘to disseminate information on matters relating to the registration of cooling tower systems’, into section 196(ia) of the Act.

Clause 8 makes it clear that the Act applies to the Crown and to public authorities.

Clause 13 amends section 261 to enable regulations which require fees to be paid for the registration or renewal of registration of cooling tower systems, and specifies the purposes for which those fees may be imposed. The new regulation making powers are –

(ka) fees payable for the registration or renewal of registration of cooling tower systems, including application fees;".

(2) Fees imposed by regulations made under section 261(1)(ka) may be imposed for any or all of the following purposes--

(a) to cover the costs of administering and enforcing Parts 5A and 5B; and

(b) to cover the costs incurred by the Commission in carrying out its functions under section 196(ia); and

(c) to cover the costs incurred by the Secretary to the Department of Human Services in carrying out any function conferred on the Secretary by or under any Act in relation to cooling tower systems or the eradication, prevention or control of Legionella; and

(d) to enable education and research activities relating to the eradication, prevention or control of Legionella to be undertaken.

The Committee accepts that the regulation making powers are appropriate to give effect to the purposes of the Act.

Part 3--Amendments to the Health Act 1958

Clause 14 inserts the following additional regulation making powers in sections 146(1) and (2) of the Act –

146(1)(iia) – the use, cleaning, maintenance, examination, testing and decontamination of any place or thing likely to give rise to, harbour, propagate, or contribute to the spread of, any infectious disease.

146(1)(vii) – the preparation, maintenance and availability of records in relation to any thing referred to in this paragraph.

146(1)(i)(D) – the preparation, maintenance and availability of records in relation to the premises or anything at the premises.

146(2)(e) – may provide in a specified case or class of case for the exemption of people or things from any of the provisions of the regulations, whether unconditionally or on specified conditions, and either wholly or to such extent as is specified.

The Committee accepts that the regulation making powers are appropriate to give effect to the purposes of the Act.

The Committee makes no further comment.

Country Fire Authority (Amendment) Bill

Introduced: 25 October 2000
Second Reading Speech: 26 October 2000
House: Legislative Assembly
Minister: Hon. A. Haermeyer MLA with the Hon. P. Batchelor MLA.

Purpose

The Bill amends the Country Fire Authority Act 1958 (the Act) to provide for the appointment of a Chief Executive Officer (CEO) and a separate part-time Chairman; and make provision in relation to conflicts of interest in respect to members of the board of the Authority.

Content and Committee comment

Clause 2 the provisions in the Bill come into operation on proclamation but not later than by 1 July 2001.

Clause 6 amends sections 8, 9 and 9B to provide for the Chairman and Deputy Chairman to be appointed for terms not exceeding 3 years in the same manner as other Authority members.

Clause 7 amends section 8(3) to remove the restriction placed on the Chairman from holding other employment (other than employment under the Authority). The Chairman is to become a part-time position and a full time CEO is appointed by the Bill.

Clause 8 inserts a new section 8A dealing with conflicts of interest of members present at a meeting of the Authority. A member must, before a matter is considered, declare any direct or indirect pecuniary interest that he or she has in the matter. Where there is a conflict of interest the member is not entitled to vote on the matter or be present during any deliberations leading to a direction, or take part in making a direction.

Clause 9 inserts new sections 16A and 16B into the Act establishing the position of CEO to hold office for the period, not exceeding 5 years. New section 16B establishes the position of Acting Chief Executive Officer (ACEO). The ACEO while he or she is acting as the CEO, has all the powers and functions, and may perform the duties of the CEO.

Delegation

New section 16C provides a power of delegation of the Chief Executive Officer –

The Chief Executive Officer may, by instrument, delegate to any person by name or to the holder of an office or position approved by the Authority, any responsibility, power, authority, duty or function conferred on the Chief Executive Officer under this Act or the regulations, except this power of delegation.

The Committee notes the delegation provision allows the Authority to approve any person by name or to the holder of an office or position to be a person to whom the Chief Executive Officer (CEO) may delegate any power, authority, duty of function that the CEO has under the Act or the regulations, other than the power of delegation.

In essence it allows the Authority to authorise the CEO to delegate to ‘any person’ without specifying any class, group or attribute or qualification that would ordinarily define and limit the scope of a delegation power. Without such reasonable limitation in the provision the Committee is of the opinion that the provision may make rights, freedoms or obligations dependent upon insufficiently defined administrative powers within the meaning of section 4D(a)(ii) of the Parliamentary Committees Act 1968.

The Committee will seek further information from the Minister as to why such a delegation provision is thought necessary or desirable in the circumstances.

Clause 10 amends section 40(3) and (13) transferring the power relating to the declaration of total fire bans, from the Chairman to the CEO.

Delegation

Clause 12 inserts the CEO in section 109B, as a person to whom the Authority may delegate. Section 109B is a broad delegation provision and its terms are defined and limited to an officer or employee or class of officers or employees of the Authority.

The Committee is satisfied that the delegation provision is suitably defined and limited and that it is appropriate to include the CEO in the delegation provision.

Clause 13 provides a number of transitional arrangements from the part-time Chairman to the full-time CEO. Certain action of the Chairman will be deemed to be actions of the CEO. The outgoing Chairman is to be replaced with a part-time Chairman.

The Committee makes no further comment.

Crimes (Further Amendment) Bill

Introduced: 25 October 2000
Second Reading Speech: 25 October 2000
House: Legislative Council
Minister: Hon. M. Birrell MLC

Purpose

The purpose of the Bill is to amend the Crimes Act 1958 (the Act) so as to –

  • enable investigating officials to question certain persons in detention in respect of offences; and

  • provide appropriate safeguards to protect the legal rights of a person being so questioned, including his or her right to silence.

Content and Committee comment

Clause 2 the provisions in the Bill come into operation on the day after Royal Assent.

Clause 4 inserts new section 464BA. Sub-section (1) defines ‘person in detention’ (over the age of 18 years) for the purpose of the new section. The relevant sub-sections are –

(2) An investigating official may apply to the Magistrates' Court for an order that he or she be granted access to a person in detention whom the investigating official –

(a) believes on reasonable grounds has information relevant to the investigation of an offence, other than an offence for which the person is being detained; or

(b) suspects on reasonable grounds of having committed an offence referred to in paragraph (a) –

for the purpose of questioning in respect of that offence.

(3) An application under sub-section (2) must –

(a) be in writing; and

(b) state the grounds on which the application is made, including the grounds for the belief or suspicion referred to in that sub-section; and

(c) be served on the person in detention by delivering a true copy of the application--

(i) to the person personally; or

(ii) to the person in charge of the place where the person is being detained.

(6) On an application under sub-section (2), the Magistrates' Court may order that the applicant have access to the person in detention in the place where he or she is being detained for the purpose of questioning for a maximum period of time specified in the order and may include in that order any conditions that it thinks fit to ensure that –

(a) the person in detention is fully informed of his or her right to silence and is given the information required to be given to him or her by sub-section (7)(a) and (b); and

(b) the environment in which the questioning occurs and the way in which the questioning is conducted is fair and reasonable having regard to all the circumstances.

(7) If an order is made under sub-section (6), before any questioning commences, the investigating official must inform the person in detention that he or she –

(a) does not have to say or do anything but that anything he or she does say or do may be given in evidence; and

(b) may communicate with or attempt to communicate with a legal practitioner.

(8) The investigating official must defer the questioning for a time that is reasonable in the circumstances to enable the person in detention to make, or attempt to make, the communication referred to in sub-section (7)(b).

(9) If a person in detention wishes to communicate with a legal practitioner, the investigating official –

(a) must afford the person reasonable facilities as soon as practicable to enable the person to do so; and

(b) must allow the person's legal practitioner or a clerk of the legal practitioner to communicate with the person in circumstances in which, as far as practicable, the communication will not be overheard.

(10) The Magistrates’ Court may on the application of the investigating official, extend a period of questioning ordered under (6) or may make a subsequent order against the same person for the same or a different offence.

(11) Sections 464D and 464F to 464J also apply to any questioning of a person in detention in accordance with an order made under sub-section (6).

(12) An application may be made under section 464B notwithstanding that an application could be made or has been made under section 464BA(2). Section 464B applies where the person in detention consents to the questioning.

(13) For the avoidance of doubt it is declared that, without limiting or affecting section 464J –

nothing in this section affects the application of the rules of evidence to any admission or confession made by a person in detention in the course of questioning in accordance with an order made under sub-section (6); and

an admission or confession referred to in paragraph (a) is not to be regarded as having been made involuntarily only because it was made in the course of questioning in accordance with an order made under sub-section (6).

(14) This section applies to any person in detention at any time on or after the commencement of the provisions in the Bill, irrespective of when the offence to which the questioning relates was committed or alleged to have been committed.

Notes

Sections 464D, 464F to 464J of the Crimes Act 1958 provide statutory rights in respect to police questioning.

Section 464D – Right to an interpreter.

Section 464F – Right of foreign national to communicate with consular office.

Section 464G – Tape recording of certain information that is required to be given to a person in custody prior to the commencement of questioning. The information required is –

1. ‘you do not have to say anything but anything you say or do may be given in evidence’ - s.464A(3)

2. ‘you may communicate with or attempt to communicate with a friend or relative to inform that person where you are, and may communicate with or attempt to communicate with a legal practitioner’ -s.464C(1)

3. ‘communicate with or attempt to communicate with a consular official’- s.464F(1) (if applicable).

In respect to 2 and 3 above, the investigating official must defer the questioning for a time that is reasonable in the circumstances to enable the person to make or attempt to make the relevant communication(s), unless, the investigating official believes on reasonable grounds that the communication would result in the escape of an accomplice, or the fabrication or destruction of evidence; or the questioning or investigation is so urgent, having regard to the safety of other people, that it should not be delayed.

Section 464H – Tape recording of confessions and admissions.

Section 464I – No power to detain person not under arrest. The section provides –

Nothing in sections 464 to 464H confers a power to detain against his or her will a person who is not under arrest.

 

The Committee notes that section 464I does not appear to be relevant for the purposes of the proposed section 464BA.

Section 464J – (1) The right to remain silent,
(2) The onus on the prosecution to prove that an admission or confession by the accused person was voluntary,
(3) The discretion to exclude unfairly obtained evidence or,
(4) the discretion to exclude illegally or improperly obtained evidence.

1. The Committee notes that section 464BA(2)(a) may permit the questioning of a prisoner who is not suspected of having committed an offence but whom may be a witness and have information relevant to the investigation of an offence. The Committee notes the compulsory witness examination procedure established in 1999 by section 56A* of the Magistrates’ Court Act 1989. This procedure applies to committal proceedings where a witnesses may have relevant information required by the prosecution. Under that procedure a witness may be examined in open court, may be represented and may address the court through a legal representative or personally. Under the proposed procedure in 464BA a prisoner who has information about any offence would, if an application is granted, be required to attend a police interview rather than attend at an open court hearing with or without representation. In this respect the Committee notes that a prisoner may be treated differently to that of any other person in respect to an investigation of an offence.

2. The Committee further notes that the proposed section 464BA is not limited to serious indictable offences but applies to any offence. The Committee suggests that the clause may have too wide an application as currently drafted and is of the view that a more limited definition may be more appropriate.

3. The Committee notes that section 464B currently requires that the prisoner’s consent be obtained before questioning may occur. This essentially replicates the situation where a person is arrested and taken into custody and either consents or refuses to give answers to police questions. The Committee is concerned that to seek to question a prisoner who either has information or is a suspect, in the face of a refusal to give consent to such questioning, may constitute an undue trespass to rights and freedoms.

In respect to the proposal to allow questioning of persons already under detention who are suspected of committing other offences (i.e. section 464BA(2)(b)), the Committee refers to it’s final report to the Parliament on the Right to Silence tabled in March 1999. In that report the Committee unanimously recommended that for many reasons enumerated in the report, there be no changes made to the law relating to the pre-trial right to silence.

5. Some members of the Committee expressed the view that the Bill raised difficult issues of competing rights, being the rights and freedoms of individuals and the expectation (right) of the State to effectively investigate and prosecute crimes.

The Committee refers the Bill for further consideration by the Parliament.

Note 1

The Committee received written submissions from the following persons and organisations –

  • The Law Institute of Victoria – David Grace QC

  • Victorian Council of Civil Liberties – Jonathan Clough and Elizabeth Brimer

  • Catholic Commission for Justice Development and Peace – Liz Curran

  • The Public Advocate – Julian Gardner

The Committee thanks these persons and organisations for their valuable contribution in assisting the Committee in its consideration of this Bill.

Note 2

The Committee wishes to record the following paragraph from the submission made by the Victorian Council of Civil Liberties.

‘A prisoner is not subject to the ordinary power of arrest because he or she is already in custody. The police must therefore make an application to the court to have the prisoner removed to their custody for the purpose of questioning. The requirement for consent to the interview is nothing more than the prisoner exercising his or her right to silence. If a prisoner exercises that right, and declines to give consent, there can be no justification for releasing them into police custody. Once this is understood, it becomes clear that prisoners do not have greater rights than other citizens’.

* Section 56A is to be amended by the Magistrates’ Court (Committal Proceedings) Bill (also in this Alert Digest).

The Committee makes no further comment.

Domestic (Feral and Nuisance) Animals (Amendment) Bill

Introduced: 25 October 2000
Second Reading Speech: 26 October 2000
House: Legislative Assembly
Minister: Hon. K. Hamilton MLA with the Hon. L. Kosky MLA.

Purpose

The purpose of the Bill is to improve the administration and effectiveness of the Domestic (Feral and Nuisance) Animals Act 1994 (the Act). The purpose of the Bill is to –

  • simplify the control of dogs and cats on private property without the permission of the owner of that property;

  • enable Councils to declare certain dogs to be menacing dogs;

  • require the owners of menacing dogs to restrain their dogs adequately;

  • regulate domestic animal businesses conducted by Councils;

  • allow authorised officers to search for and seize certain dogs under a search warrant.

Content and Committee comment

Clause 2 the provisions in the Bill (other than sections 4(a) and (b), 9, 19(2), 38 and 39) come into operation on the day after Royal Assent. Sections 4(a) and (b), 9, 19(2), 38 and 39 come into operation on proclamation but not later than by 1 January 2002.

Clause 4 substitutes new definitions in section 4 for ‘dangerous dog’, ‘pet shop’ and ‘menacing dog’.

Maximum fee to be charged for menacing or dangerous dogs

Clause 8 inserts a new section 15(7) to provide that a Council may not reduce the registration fee from the maximum fee in respect to a menacing dog; a dog that is declared to be a dangerous dog.

Dog or cat on private property

Clause 10 substitutes a new section 23 dealing with dogs and cats on private property without permission of the owner or the occupier. The section provides that if a dog or cat has been present on private property on more than one occasion without such permission, the owner or occupier of private property or an authorised officer may seize the dog or cat while it is present on the property.

The owner or occupier of the private property or the authorised officer who has seized a dog or cat must immediately notify the Council in which the property is situated.

If the Council is able to identify the owner of a dog or cat seized, the Council must, within 5 business days after the seizure of the dog or cat, serve on the owner of the dog or cat a notice of objection to the presence of that dog or cat on the private property.

Where a notice has been served, and the dog or cat enters or remains on the private property, the owner of the dog or cat is guilty of an offence and liable upon conviction, to a penalty of not more than 1 penalty unit for a first offence, and 3 penalty units for a second or subsequent offence.

Unrestrained dogs

Clause 11 amends section 24 to increase the penalty in respect of dogs found at large to 3 penalty units for each occasion (first or subsequent).

Clause 14 amends section 29 to provide for a lesser offence in respect of a dog chasing or rushing at a person. The restructured section will then provide–

(1) If a dog attacks or bites any person or animal, the owner is guilty of an offence and liable upon conviction to a penalty of not more than 5 penalty units.

(1A) If a dog rushes at or chases any person or animal, the owner is guilty of an offence and liable upon conviction to a penalty of not more than 4 penalty units.

Clause 15 amends section 34 providing that if a dog is a menacing dog and the owner has received at least two infringement notices in respect of the offence in section 41E (inserted by clause 20) the Council may declare the dog to be a dangerous dog.

Further definition of ‘dangerous dog’

Clause 16 inserts a new section 34A providing that a dog is a dangerous dog if it is kept as a guard dog for the purpose of guarding non-residential premises; or has been trained to attack or bite any person or any thing when attached to or worn by a person.

Owners must notify Council of certain matters

Clause 18 substitutes section 37(1) and inserts new section 37(1A) to (1C) and provides that –

(1) Immediately upon becoming the owner of a dog that has been trained to attack or bite any person or any thing when attached to or worn by a person, the owner of the dog must so notify the Council of the municipal district in which the dog is kept.

(1A) Immediately upon a dog commencing training to attack or bite any person or any thing when attached to or worn by a person, the owner of the dog must notify the Council of the municipal district in which the dog is kept that the dog is being so trained.

(1B) The owner of a dog kept as a guard dog for the purpose of guarding non-residential premises must, within 24 hours of commencing to keep the dog for that purpose, notify the Council of the municipal district in which the dog is kept that the dog is being kept for that purpose.

(1C) If a Council has advised the owner of a dog that the Council is investigating an alleged offence under section 29Œ of the Act in respect of that dog and if the custody or ownership of the dog changes, the owner of the dog must notify the Council which registered the dog of the change within 24 hours after the change taking place. The penalty in each case is 5 penalty units ($500).

Fencing of non-residential premises guarded by dangerous dog

Clause 19 amends section 38(3) to provide that regulations may be made to provide for perimeter fencing where a dangerous dog is used to guard non-residential premises.

Council may declare a dog a ‘menacing dog’

Clause 20 inserts new sections 41A to 41E providing a process for Councils to declare a dog to be a menacing dog.

New section 41A provides that a Council may declare a dog to be a menacing dog if it has rushed at or chased a person; or has been declared a menacing dog by another Council. The Council must not make a declaration if the incident occurred because the dog was being teased, abused or assaulted; or the person was trespassing on the premises on which the dog was kept; or another person known to the dog was being attacked in front of the dog.

New section 41C a Council must give a notice of a menacing dog declaration to the owner.

New section 41D provides that the owner of a menacing dog must notify the Council within 24 hours if the dog rushes at or chases a person; or the dog is missing; or the ownership of the dog changes.

New section 41E provides that a notice that a dog has been declared to be a menacing dog, may require the owner of the dog specified in the notice to cause the dog, when it is outside the premises of its owner, to be muzzled in a manner which is sufficient to prevent it causing injury by biting; under the effective control of some person by means of a chain, cord or leash.

Clause 27 inserts a new section 63A to make it an offence for a person to conduct a domestic animal business that does not comply with the relevant Code of Practice made under section 59.

Identity cards for ‘authorised officers’

Clause 28 substitutes a new section 73 and inserts new sections 73A dealing with identity cards for authorised officers. An identity card must contain a photograph of the authorised officer to whom it is issued. An authorised officer must produce his or her identity card for inspection before exercising a power under Part 7 (enforcement provisions); and at any time during the exercise of a power under this Part, if asked to do so. New section 73A makes it an offence to impersonate an authorised officer.

Clause 30 inserts a new section 76A to provide that an authorised officer may issue a person with a notice to comply if he or she believes on reasonable grounds that the person has committed an offence under the Act.

Warrants for search and seizure

Clause 32 inserts new sections 77A, 77B and 77C.

New section 77A provides for search and seizure warrants on application to a magistrate, if an officer believes on reasonable grounds that a dog is present on the premises which the officer is entitled to seize. The forms, practices and procedures provided in the Magistrates' Court Act 1989 apply to such search and seizure.

New section 77B provides for announcement before entry when executing a search warrant. If the authorised officer has been unable to obtain unforced entry, he or she must give any person at the premises an opportunity to allow entry to the premises. An authorised officer need not comply with the announcement provision if there are reasonable grounds for believing that immediate entry to the premises is required to ensure the safety of any person; or that the effective execution of the search warrant is not frustrated.

New section 77C provides that details of the warrant are to be given to the occupier.

Clause 33 substitutes new section 79 to provide that owners identification and current registration (or application for registration) must be provided on retrieving impounded animals.

Clause 34 a court may order reasonable impounding costs to be paid to a Council by the owner of an animal found guilty of an offence for which the animal was seized.

Clause 35 amends section 85(1) to allow infringement notices to be issued for offences under new section 41E or 63A.

VCAT may review ‘menacing dog’ decision

Clause 37 amends section 98 dealing with reviewable decisions and includes the decision of a Council that a dog is a menacing dog, as a decision that may be reviewed by the Victorian Civil and Administrative Tribunal.

The Committee makes no further comment.

Environment Protection (Liveable Neighbourhoods) Bill

Introduced: 1 November 2000
Second Reading Speech: 2 November 2000
House: Legislative Assembly
Minister: Hon. S. Garbutt MLA with the Hon. M. Delahunty MLA.

Purpose

The purpose of the Bill is to amend the Environment Protection Act 1970 (the Act) to –

  • include principles of environment protection;

  • give the Environment Protection Authority (the Authority) the power to develop economic measures such as tradeable emission schemes;

  • provide for neighbourhood environment improvement plans;

  • make new provision for environmental audits;

  • improve the operation of the Act.

Content and Committee comment

Clause 2 sections 1 and 2, Part 2 and Part 5 (other than section 23) come into operation on the day after Royal Assent. Section 23 is deemed to have come into operation on 1 October 2000. The remaining provisions of the Bill come into operation on proclamation but not later than by 1 July 2001.

Clause 3 inserts new sections 1A to 1L to state the purposes of the Act and introduce principles of environment protection. New section 1A(3) provides that it is the intention of Parliament that in the administration of the Act, regard should be given to the principles of environment protection.

Clause 4 amends section 13(1) and inserts a new sub-paragraph (cc) providing that the Authority may develop economic measures for the purpose of providing an economic incentive to avoid or minimise harm to the environment or any portion or segment of the environment by a particular activity.

Clause 6 inserts new sections 19AA, 19AB and 19AC dealing with economic measures, economic incentives such as tradeable permit schemes, environmental offsets, tradeable emission schemes and provides for offences to exceed permitted entitlement levels.

Clause 7 inserts an additional regulation making power into section 71(1) of the Act to provide –

(ca) regulating the implementation of economic measures, including prescribing conditions to which particular schemes are subject and the circumstances under which the Authority may alter, suspend or terminate the entitlements held under a scheme.

The Committee accepts that the regulation making powers are appropriate to give effect to the purposes of the Act.

Part 3 – Neighbourhood Environment Improvement Plans

Clause 8 inserts a new Division 1B to provide for the development and approval of neighbourhood environment improvement plans. The Division consists of new sections 19AD to 19AJ.

Clause 11 amends section 32 to provide that a person whose interests are affected by a direction by the Authority to submit a proposal to develop a neighbourhood environment improvement plan may seek review of the direction by VCAT.

Clause 12 inserts a new Part IXD (new sections 53S to 53ZE) and deals with environmental audits.

53S provides for the appointment of environmental auditors to conduct environmental audits; to prepare environmental audit reports; and if requested, to issue certificates of environmental audit or statements of environmental audit.

53U provides that a person may engage an environmental auditor to conduct an environmental audit.

53ZC an environmental auditor must not give false or misleading information to the Authority; or issue a certificate of environmental audit or a statement of environmental audit which is false or misleading; or conceal any relevant information or document from the Authority.

53ZD provides that if an environmental auditor is convicted of an offence against section 53ZC, the Authority must revoke his or her appointment as an environmental auditor.

Clause 15 amends section 4(1) of the Act to provides that in the definition of ‘ozone-depleting substance’ after ‘halon’ insert ‘hydrochlorofluorocarbon’.

Clause 20 amends section 55 to clarify the powers of authorised officers to take films and make such audio, video or other recordings of land or premises under investigation.

The Committee makes no further comment.

Fair Employment Bill

Introduced: 25 October 2000
Second Reading Speech: 26 October 2000
House: Legislative Assembly
Minister: Hon. S. Bracks MLA with the Hon. P. Batchelor MLA.

Purpose

The main purpose of the Bill is to provide for a fresh system of employment regulation in Victoria and to establish a Fair Employment Tribunal. The Bill also repeals the Long Service Leave Act 1992.

The Committee notes the following points from the Second Reading Speech –

  • The Fair Employment Bill will provide protection to persons currently not protected by federal awards and agreements.

  • Clothing outworkers and home-based clerical workers will also be covered as employees for the purposes of the Fair Employment Bill.

  • The Fair Employment Tribunal will also be given the jurisdiction to determine whether or not a class of persons working as contractors would be more appropriately regarded as employees.

  • This safety net will only apply to employees covered by federal awards where particular legislated minimum conditions of employment, such as long service leave, are not provided in such federal awards and are intended to have no application to employees covered by federally registered agreements. This is consistent with the way schedule 1A and other state legislation currently interacts with federal awards.

  • Victorian employees will be entitled to minimum standards of annual leave entitlements, personal leave (sick and carer's leave), bereavement leave, parental leave, long service leave, hours of work provisions, public holiday entitlements, clear definitions of employment categories, notice on termination of employment, and a general requirement to consult with employees over workplace changes which will impact on jobs and security of employment.

  • The Fair Employment Bill by setting a minimum standard for employees to work 38 hours per week averaged over a four-week period. Any variations to this, including the determination of appropriate forms of remuneration or compensation for work undertaken in excess of the minimum, are to be set and determined by the Fair Employment Tribunal on either an industry or occupational basis. Employees will be now able to access personal and bereavement leave.

  • The existing 18 industry sector orders which currently regulate minimum wages and work classifications for schedule 1A employees will be maintained on an interim basis and will form the regulatory basis for these conditions. The tribunal will then have the capacity to amend, vary or add to these sectors on an industry or occupational basis.

  • If there is a federal award that substantially governs the employment conditions of particular employees, the tribunal must exclude those persons from the application of the order unless it is satisfied that the exclusion would not be in the public interest.

  • The major functions of the tribunal are to administer the fair employment conditions; to settle workplace grievances and provide mediation for industrial disputes; and to provide a low-cost, efficient small claims jurisdiction.

  • The Fair Employment Bill will also provide for a system of mediation or conciliation for industrial disputes.

  • In addition to resolving workplace grievances, the Fair Employment Tribunal will provide a small claims jurisdiction for the non-provision of wages and conditions of employment and will be able to provide monetary remedies up to a specified limit (currently $20,000). Independent contractors will also have access to this avenue of redress to recover their contractual entitlements. This jurisdiction will provide an alternative mechanism to pursuing actions through the civil courts on these matters. It will be more accessible, low cost and focused on the resolution of the matters at hand.

  • Under the Fair Employment Bill, employees of contractors are able to recover unpaid wages and entitlements directly from the principal contractor where the contractor has not paid entitlements, unless the principal contractor has a written statement from the subcontractor that wages have been paid.

  • An important mechanism included in the Fair Employment Bill is the ability of the tribunal to review a contract for services which is alleged to be unfair. An unfair contract is defined as a contract that is harsh, unconscionable or unfair; is contrary to the public interest; or provides for remuneration less than the person would have been entitled to as an employee under the Act, an industry sector order, or a federal award or agreement.

Content and Committee comment

Clause 2 the Act comes into operation on proclamation but not later than by 1 July 2001.

Clause 5 defines who is an employee for the purposes of the Act and includes an outworker or apprentice or trainee.

Clause 6 provides that a Full Bench may, on application by a recognised organisation, a peak body or the Minister, make an order declaring a class of persons who perform work in an industry under a contract for services to be employees.

Clause 7 defines who is an employer for the purposes of the Act.

Clause 8 defines an outworker as a person engaged, for someone else's industry, in or about a private residence or other premises that are not necessarily business or commercial premises, to pack, process, or work on articles or material; or carry out clerical work.

Clause 10 defines, for the purposes of the Act, a "full-time employee" as an employee (other than a casual) who is engaged to work 38 ordinary hours per week averaged over a 4-week period, or such other maximum number of ordinary hours per week as is fixed by a relevant industry sector order. A "part-time employee" is an employee (other than a casual) who has reasonably predictable hours of work and who is engaged to work a lesser number of ordinary hours per week than a full-time employee performing work of the same or a similar nature in the industry sector. A "casual" is an employee who is engaged on a casual basis.

Clause 11 provides an indexing of wages formula for determining employee eligibilty for covereage under the Act and for monetary compensation limits purposes. An ineligible employee is defined under section 4 as one whose rate of remuneration exceeds $71,200 per year. The jurisdictional limits of the Tribunal are referred to in clauses 107 and 111 and are initially set at $20,000.

Chapter 2 – Fair employment conditions

Divisions 1 to 9 set out the minimum conditions of employment. The Chapter comprises sections 15 to 100.

Clause 15 states that a provision of an industry sector order or contract of employment is of no effect to the extent that it provides a condition of employment that is less favourable to an employee than the minimum applicable under this Part.

Clause 16 provides that unless the Tribunal otherwise determines in accordance with the Act, the minimum conditions apply to part-time employees pro-rata calculated on the basis that full-time employees work 38 ordinary hours per week.

Clauses 17 to 73 set out the minimum employment terms and conditions including –

Unless otherwise provided by an industry sector order, the period for which an employee is required to work must not exceed 38 ordinary hours per week averaged over a 4-week period; or more than 5 hours of continuous work without a minimum of a 30 minute break. An employee is entitled to a rest pause of at least 10 minutes in each 4 consecutive hours of working time, Public Holidays, annual leave entitlements, taking annual leave, payment of leave, payment on termination of employment, leave loading, entitlement to be paid bereavement leave, parental leave, maternity leave, paternity and adoption leave.

Clause 37 deals with the transfer of a pregnant employee to a safe job where, illness or risks arising out of the pregnancy or hazards connected with the work assigned to the employee make it inadvisable for the employee to continue at her present work.

The employee must, if the employer deems it practicable, be transferred to a safe job at the rate and on the conditions attaching to that job until the commencement of maternity leave. If the transfer to a safe job is not practicable, the employee may elect, or the employer may require the employee, to commence parental leave.

Clause 74 provides that a Full Bench may review a minimum condition(s), on an application made by the Minister; or a recognised organisation; or a peak body; or an employee or employer, with the leave of the Tribunal; or if the matter of reviewing the minimum condition(s), is referred to it by the President.

Clauses 77 to 88 deal with industry sector orders. A Full Bench may declare industry sectors and industry conditions including minimum wages and equal remuneration for equal work.

Clause 77 provides that a provision of a contract of employment is of no effect to the extent that it provides a condition of employment that is less favourable to an employee than that applicable under a relevant industry sector order.

Clauses 89 to 95 deal with the payment of remuneration and issues such as the liability of a principal contractor for remuneration payable to employees of a subcontractor.

Clauses 96 to 100 deal with issues related to transfers of business from one employer ti a successor and an employee's continuity of service and employment for the purposes of rights and entitlements under the Act.

Chapter 3 – Workplace grievances and applications to the Tribunal.

The Chapter consists of sections 101 to 114 and deals with workplace grievances and other employment-related matters. The Chapter defines a workplace grievance and who may apply to the Tribunal to resolve a workplace grievance.

A workplace grievance is a grievance or dispute between an employee employed under a contract of service and his or her employer relating to the application to the employee of a minimum condition; or the application to the employee of an industry sector order; or non-payment of remuneration or non-provision of any other entitlements under the contract of service; or any other aspect of the employment relationship; or between a person engaged to perform work under a contract for services and the person for whom, or on whose behalf, the work is performed relating to non-payment of remuneration or non-provision of any other entitlements under the contract for services; or the fairness of the contract for services.

Clause 104 provides for representative proceedings, where a workplace grievance involving a common issue exists between employees and the same employer at the same workplace, one or more of the employees may apply to the Tribunal to conduct a representative proceeding in respect of the workplace grievances.

Clause 105 the Tribunal may refuse to entertain grievances if the parties have not attempted to resolve the issue(s) using the grievance code of practice provided in the rules; or until the rules provide a grievance code of practice, the interim grievance code of practice set out in Schedule 1.

Clause 109 provides that once an application is made to the Tribunal to resolve a workplace grievance by declaring void or otherwise varying an unfair contract, the Victorian Civil and Administrative Tribunal does not have jurisdiction to make an order under section 109 of the Fair Trading Act 1999 in respect of that contract, unless proceedings in respect of the contract were commenced under that Act before the application to the Tribunal was made and those proceedings are still pending; or the application to the Tribunal is withdrawn or struck out for want of jurisdiction.

Clauses 110 to 114 deal with the recovery of amounts owed to former employees.

Chapter 4 – Fair Employment Tribunal

The Chapter consists of sections 115 to 213 and establishes the Fair Employment Tribunal (the Tribunal). The Chapter sets out such matters as the membership, qualifications of members, remuneration, terms of appointment, acting appointments resignation, suspension and removal of members of the Tribunal.

Clause 136 provides the President of the tribunal may delegate any power by instrument to the Vice President under the Act, other than the power of delegation.

Clause 147 provides an immunity of participants (members and party representatives) as if the proceedings were proceedings in the Supreme Court.

Clause 150 provides that the Tribunal may dismiss a proceeding or any part of it or refrain from hearing, further hearing or deciding a proceeding, if the Tribunal considers that the proceeding is frivolous, vexatious, misconceived or lacking in substance or otherwise an abuse of process; or further action by the Tribunal in respect of the proceeding is not necessary or desirable in the public interest.

Power of entry and inspection

Clause 153 provides that in connection with a proceeding in the Tribunal a tribunal official may, during working hours enter a workplace and inspect any work, material, machinery, appliance, article, facility or other thing in or on the workplace; and interview a person in or on the workplace about a matter relevant to the Tribunal's concern with the workplace.

A person must not refuse or unduly delay a tribunal official's entry to a workplace; or fail, without reasonable excuse, to answer a question about a matter specified in the section, or wilfully give false information or make a false statement to a tribunal official.

Clause 153(4) provides that a member of the Tribunal or the registrar may, by instrument, authorise a member of staff of the registry or another person who is not an officer or employee of a recognised organisation to exercise powers under sub-section (1).

"tribunal official" means (a) a member of the Tribunal; (b) the registrar; (c) a person authorised under sub-section (4).

Clause 154 provides that the Tribunal is bound by the rules of natural justice but is not bound by the rules of evidence or any practices or procedures applicable to courts of record, except to the extent that it adopts those rules, practices or procedures and may inform itself on any matter as it sees fit; and must conduct each proceeding with as little formality and technicality, and determine each proceeding with as much speed, as the requirements of this Act and a proper consideration of the matters before it permit.

Clause 175 provides that evidence of anything said or done in the course of conciliation or mediation is not admissible in any hearing before the Tribunal in the proceeding, unless all parties agree to the giving of the evidence.

Clause 188 provides that if the Tribunal gives an oral decision, or a written decision that does not include the reasons for the decision, a party may request the Tribunal to give a written decision including the reasons for the decision.

Clause 198 to 201 provides for appeals. If the Tribunal, constituted by a single member, makes a decision or order in a proceeding, the Minister or a party to the proceeding may appeal against the decision or order to a Full Bench.

The Minister or a party to a proceeding before a Full Bench may appeal to the Supreme Court, on a question of law, from a decision or order of the Full Bench in the proceeding.

Clause 202 provides that the President of the Tribunal may make rules regulating the practice and procedure of the Tribunal, including any rules required or permitted to be made by this Act or necessary to be made to give effect to this Act

Chapter 5 – Compliance

The Chapter consists of clauses 214 to 259

Clause 214 provides that the Minister may, by instrument, appoint as an information services officer for the purposes of this Act a person employed under Part 3 of the Public Sector Management and Employment Act 1998 who, in the Minister's opinion is competent to perform the functions and exercise the powers of an information services officer; and is of good repute, having regard to character, honesty and integrity.

Each information services officer must be issued with an identity card in the form approved by the Minister.

An information services officer may request the assistance of a member of the police force and a member of the police force may assist an information services officer to take any action authorised by this Part.

Power of entry

Clause 218 provides that an information services officer may enter any premises at which the officer has reasonable grounds for believing that work is being or has been performed; or any premises, being a place of business at which the officer has reasonable grounds for believing that there are documents relevant to the purposes set out in section 217(1). Entry under this section may be made during ordinary working hours; or at any other time with the consent of the occupier.

On exercising a power of entry under this Division, an information services officer may inspect any work, material, machinery, appliance, article, facility or other thing; take samples of any goods or substances in accordance with the regulations; interview any employee; require a person having the custody of, or access to, a document relevant to the purposes set out in section 217(1) to produce the document to the information services officer within a reasonable period specified by the information services officer; inspect, and make copies of or take extracts from, a document produced to him or her.

An information services officer, by written notice, may require a person to produce to the information services officer, within a reasonable period specified in the notice, a document relevant to the purposes set out in section 217(1).

Clause 222 deals with search warrants according to the forms, practices and procedures provided in the Magistrates' Court Act 1989.

Before executing a search warrant, the information services officer named in the warrant or a person assisting the information services officer named in the warrant must announce that he or she is authorised by the warrant to enter the premises; and give any person at the premises an opportunity to allow entry to the premises. The information services officer need not make such prior announcement if he or she believes on reasonable grounds that immediate entry to the premises is required to ensure the safety of any person; or that the effective execution of the warrant is not frustrated.

An officer or employee of a recognised organisation may apply to the registrar, in the form approved by the registrar, for an inspection permit and the registrar may issue an inspection permit to the officer or employee.

If a person who holds an inspection permit has reasonable grounds for suspecting that a contravention of this Act or the regulations may have occurred, or is occurring (including a contravention of an industry sector order or another order of the Tribunal).

Clause 227 provides that a person who holds an inspection permit may enter premises in which work is being carried on to which an industry sector order applies; being an industry sector order covering persons who are, or are eligible to become, members of the recognised organisation of which the person is an officer or employee; and employees who are, or are eligible to become, members of that organisation work for the purpose of holding discussions with any of those employees who wish to participate in them.

The person may enter the premises only during working hours and may hold the discussions only during the employees' meal-time or other breaks.

Prohibition against victimisation

Clauses 229 to 232 make provision prohibiting victimisation and set out the powers of the Tribunal to redress victimisation –

(1) An employer or a recognised organisation must not victimise an employee.

(2) An employer or a recognised organisation victimises an employee if the employer or recognised organisation subjects or threatens to subject the employee to any detriment because the employee, or a person associated with the employee, has--

(a) claimed a benefit or exercised a power or right that he or she is entitled to claim or exercise under this Act, an industry sector order or another order of the Tribunal; or

(b) brought, or otherwise participated in, a proceeding under this Act; or

(c) informed any person of an alleged contravention of this Act (including a contravention of an industry sector order or other order of the Tribunal) by any person.

Clauses 233 to 259 provide offence and enforcement provisions such as a failure to produce documents, hindering officers, impersonating officers and giving false information.

Clause 235 is a protection against self-incrimination and provides –

It is a reasonable excuse for a natural person to refuse or fail to produce a document or do any other thing that the person is required to do by or under this Act if the producing of the document or the doing of the other thing would tend to incriminate the person.

Clause 240 provides that –

A person appearing as a witness before the Tribunal must not, without reasonable excuse –
(a) refuse to be sworn in or make an affirmation; or
(b) refuse to answer a question that the person is required by the presiding member to answer.

Penalty: 60 penalty units ($6,000) or 6 months, or both.

Clauses 244 to 252 provides that an enforcement officer may issue an infringement penalty notices (the PERIN system).

Reverse onus of proof

Clause 257 provides that –

In a prosecution against an employer for failing to pay an employee an amount owed to the employee under a contract of employment if–
(a) the employee is dead; and
(b) the employer alleges that the period shown in the charge as being the period of continuous employment of the employee with the employer is wrong–
the employer bears the onus of proving the allegation.

The Committee notes the reverse onus of proof provision in the circumstances of claims made by the representatives of a deceased employee. In the circumstances the Committee considers the reverse onus of proof is acceptable.

Chapter 6 – General

Clause 260 provides that the Tribunal, on application by an organisation that is registered under the Commonwealth Act, may recognise the organisation for the purposes of this Act.

The Chapter also deals with matters such as records to be kept by employers relating to employees, service of documents and the regulation making power.

Clause 266 provides a standard regulation making power.

Clause 267 provides for the repeal of the Long Service Leave Act 1992.

Clause 270 provides that an application may be made to the Tribunal to resolve a workplace grievance whether the events giving rise to the grievance occurred before, on or after the commencement of the Act.

Clause 271 relates to the recovery of entitlements of former employees and provides that an application may be made to the Tribunal under section 110 whether the non-payment of remuneration or non-provision of entitlements allegedly occurred before, on or after the commencement of Division 1 of Part 2 of Chapter 3.

Clause 272 until provision is made under section 80 in respect to declaring industry sectors the clause sets out the industry sectors at the commencement of the Act.

Clause 273 provides that on and from the commencement of section 83 until a minimum wage for an employee is set under that section, the federally-set hourly minimum wage of the employee is to be treated as if it were a minimum wage set by the Tribunal under section 83 for that employee for each hour worked by that employee in a working week, irrespective of the length of that week.

Clause 275 will permit regulations to be made that contain provisions of a savings and transitional nature consequent on the enactment of this Act; or the termination of a reference under a sub-section of section 4 of the Commonwealth Powers (Industrial Relations) Act 1996. The regulations may be retrospective in operation.

The Committee notes that retrospective regulations of a savings and transitional nature may be made under section 275. It is not apparent to the Committee on the material before it to say why this power is necessary and if it is necessary whether the retrospective operation of those regulations may or may not trespass unduly on rights and freedoms.

The Committee will seek further information from the Minister.

Schedule 1

Provides an interim workplace grievance code of practice.

Schedule 2

Provides the subject matters for rules of the Tribunal, for example, the calling of experts, the issue and service of summonses and like matters.

The Committee makes no further comment.

Forestry Rights (Amendment) Bill

Introduced: 1 November 2000
Second Reading Speech: 2 November 2000
House: Legislative Assembly
Minister: Hon. S. Garbutt MLA with the Hon. M. Delahunty MLA.

Purpose

The main purposes of the Bill are to –

  • amend the Forestry Rights Act 1996 (the Act) to provide for rights to the commercial exploitation of carbon sequestered by trees; and

  • provide for consent of holders of registered mortgages or charges to be obtained in relation to certain forest property agreements.

The Committee notes the preamble in the explanatory memorandum –

Article 17 of the Kyoto Protocol allows for developed countries’ participation in emissions trading for the purposes of meeting their assigned targets for reductions in greenhouse gas emissions. Article 3.3 of the Kyoto Protocol recognises sinks as an acceptable way for countries to offset greenhouse gas emissions.

The Government supports the development of carbon trading which can generate significant funds for the planting of new forests paid by industries that emit greenhouse gases. As a first step to enable private sector trading in carbon credits for sink creation, this Bill provides for the right to commercially exploit carbon sequestered by trees.

Content and Committee comment

Clause 2 the provisions in the Bill come into operation on the day after Royal Assent.

Clause 6 inserts new sections 12 to 15 dealing with carbon rights agreements. A forest property owner may grant carbon sequestration rights to another person.

Clause 7 amends section 3 and provides definitions for ‘holder of a registered mortgage or charge’ and ‘registered mortgage or charge’.

Clause 8 inserts new sub-section (2) in both sections 5 and 7 of the Act.

New section 5(2) provides that an owner of land must not enter into a forest property agreement if the agreement relates to land which is subject to a registered mortgage or charge unless the owner of that land has first obtained the written consent of the holder of the registered mortgage or charge to that agreement; or consent has been deemed to have been given in accordance with section 7A(3); or the Supreme Court has granted an Order dispensing with consent under section 7B.

New section 7(2) provides that if the forest property agreement to be amended relates to land which is subject to a registered mortgage or charge, the parties to that agreement must not amend that agreement unless the owner of that land has first obtained the written consent of the holder of the registered mortgage or charge to that amendment; or consent has been deemed to have been given in accordance with section 7A(3); or the Supreme Court has granted an Order dispensing with consent under section 7B.

Clause 9 inserts new sections 7A and 7B in the Act.

New section 7A provides the process and requirements for a land owner to request consent from the holder of a registered mortgage to an amendment of a forest property agreement. Where the holder of the registered mortgage or charge fails to respond to a request by the land owner, consent is deemed to have been given 28 days after the request notice is given.

New section 7B provides that the Supreme Court may dispense with consent, if consent is unreasonably withheld by the holder of a registered mortgage or charge.

The Committee makes no further comment.

Gambling Legislation (Miscellaneous Amendments) Bill

Introduced: 25 October 2000
Second Reading Speech: 26 October 2000
House: Legislative Assembly
Minister: Hon. J. Pandazopoulos MLA with the Hon. P. Batchelor MLA.

Purpose

The main purpose of the Bill is to make amendments to the Gaming Machine Control Act 1991, the Gaming and Betting Act 1994, the Casino Control Act 1991, the Gaming No. 2 Act 1997, and the Interactive Gaming (Player Protection) Act 1999 to –

  • require the Victorian Casino and Gaming Authority (the Authority) to –

(i) hold public hearings on certain matters;

(ii) give reasons for certain decisions;

  • allow the Victorian Casino and Gaming Authority to –

(i) divulge certain information;

(ii) exchange certain information with other enforcement and regulatory agencies;

  • allow for an approval of premises under the Gaming Machine Control Act 1991 to be granted before the applicant has obtained any liquor approvals or other requirements of the Authority.

Content and Committee comment

Clause 2 provides that sections 1 and 2 come into operation on the day after Royal Assent. The remaining provisions, except sections 25 and 55, come into operation on proclamation but not later than by 1 December 2001. Section 25 is deemed to have come into operation on 31 August 1998. Section 55 is deemed to have come into operation on 8 June 1999.

Part 2 – Gaming Machine Control Act 1991

Clause 6 inserts a new paragraph in the definition of ‘disciplinary action’ in section 51(1) to allow the Authority to impose a cancellation of the licence and disqualification from obtaining or applying for a licence or permit under the Act, the Casino Control Act 1991, the Gaming and Betting Act 1994 or the Gaming No. 2 Act 1997 for a specified period not exceeding 4 years.

Clause 10 substitutes sections 142A(4A), (4B) and (5) for the existing 142A(5) providing that if the Authority determines that an associate of a venue operator, a gaming operator or a person listed on the Roll has engaged or is engaging in conduct that, in the Authority's opinion, is unacceptable for a person who is concerned in or associated with the ownership, management or operation of the business of the venue operator, gaming operator or person listed on the Roll, the Authority may issue a written warning to the associate that the conduct is unacceptable; or give written notice to the associate requiring the associate to give a written undertaking to the Authority, within the period specified in the notice, regarding the future conduct of the associate.

If the association is not terminated within 14 days or any longer period agreed with the Authority, the Authority may, by notice in writing, direct the venue operator, gaming operator or person listed on the Roll to take all reasonable steps to terminate the association and the venue operator, gaming operator or person listed on the Roll must comply with the direction within 14 days or any longer period agreed with the Authority.

Clause 21 inserts new sections 113, 114 and 115.

New section 113 will allow the Authority to hold its meetings and inquiries for the purposes of the Act in public or private. However certain hearings may be held in private where the Authority determines that there are special circumstances requiring that the inquiry or meeting or part of the inquiry or meeting should be held in private.

Duty to give reasons

New section 114 requires the Authority to give written statement of reasons after a public hearing or on request of its decision made in relation to any matter required by section 113 to be held in public, within 14 days after the decision. The Authority must give a written statement of reasons for a decision to a person who requested it in accordance with section 115 within 28 days after receiving the request.

New section 115 provides that a person whose interests are affected by a decision of the Authority may request the Authority to give them a written statement of reasons for the decision.

Clause 22 repeals sections 12H(4), 25(4) and 27(4B) being provisions in the Act that provide the Authority a discretion to give reasons for its decision. These are consequential amendments needed to give effect to the provisions in clause 21 (new sections 114 and 115).

The Committee notes the repeal of the provisions that gave a discretion to the Authority to give reasons for its decisions. The Committee also notes that identical repealing provisions are made by clauses 22, 29, 37 and 54 in other gaming Acts covered by this Bill.

The Committee considers that the repeals ensure that rights or obligations are not dependent upon non-reviewable administrative decisions within the meaning of section 4D(a)(iii) of the Parliamentary Committees Act 1968.

Clause 22(2) inserts a new section 107A(2A) and deals with a delegation power providing –

Despite sub-section (1), the Authority may, by instrument under its official seal, delegate to one or more members of the Authority or the Director any power or function under sections 28A or 28B.

Sections 28A and 28B are inserted by clause 5 of the Bill and deal with the duty of venue operators to notify the Authority of certain changes such as an amalgamation of incorporated associations or an application for a liquor licence.

The Committee considers the additional delegation provision is appropriately limited and defined to achieve the purposes of the Act.

Clause 23 makes amendments to section 139 relating to secrecy of information relating to gaming operators and adds information in respect to the affairs of a person acquired in accordance with a memorandum of understanding that must not, except in the course of official duties under the Act, make a record of or be divulged.

The amendments also further clarify the further circumstances in which a person may divulge information acquired under the Act or in accordance with a memorandum of understanding.

Further amendments will require that certain gambling venue expenditure information must be aggregated where there are less than 3 venues operating in a municipal district. This is consistent with Australian Bureau of Statistics conventions.

Information privacy

Clause 24 inserts a new section 140 permitting the Authority to enter into a memorandum of understanding with an enforcement agency that provides for the divulgence to the enforcement agency of information with respect to the affairs of a person acquired by the Authority in the performance of functions under this Act; and the divulgence to the Authority of information with respect to the affairs of a person acquired by the enforcement agency. A memorandum of understanding must specify the kind of information to be divulged and the purposes for which it may be used; and contain an undertaking that each party to the memorandum will use information divulged to it only for the purposes specified in the memorandum; and consents to the taking of injunctive action to restrain the unauthorised use of the information.

Clause 25 amends section 134(7) of the Act to re-insert words that were inadvertently removed from the sub-section when the section was amended by section 13(2) of the Gaming Acts (Further Amendment) Act 1997. To rectify this oversight the amendment is retrospective to 31 August 1998.

The Committee notes the retrospective amendment in clause 25 is in the form of a statute law revision amendment and only seeks to overcome a legislative oversight by reinstating words that should not have been removed by a 1997 amending Act.

Part 3 – Gaming and Betting Act 1994

Clause 30 amends section 127 and makes similar provisions to clause 23.

Clause 31 inserts a new section 127A dealing with memorandum of understanding and is identical to amendments made in clause 24.

Clause 32 inserts new sub-sections (6) and (7) into section 95 allowing the Authority to hold its meetings in public or private. The Authority may direct that a meeting or part of a meeting be held in private if it considers it necessary to do so to prevent the unreasonable divulgence of information relating to the personal affairs of any person, including a deceased person or if it is otherwise in the interests of justice or the public interest to do so.

Clause 33 amends section 92A and inserts a new sub-section (2) to provide –

The Authority may, by instrument in writing, delegate to the Director its powers and functions under section 127A.

Section 127A is inserted by clause 31.

The Committee considers the additional delegation provision is appropriately limited and defined to achieve the purposes of the Act.

Clause 34 inserts new sections 93A and 93B dealing with the duty of the Authority to give a written statement of its decisions and reasons after a public meeting or on the request of a person affected by a decision of the Authority.

Part 4 – Casino Control Act 1991

Clause 41 amends section 28A(5) dealing with the on-going monitoring of associates. The clause substitutes new sub-sections (4A), (4B) and (5).

Clause 44 amends sections 52, 53 and 54 dealing with the cancellation, disqualification and suspension of casino licences.

Clause 48 amends section 143 and deals with public hearings and provides –

that an inquiry or meeting for the purposes of making a finding or a determination relating to the following matters must be conducted in public unless the Authority determines that there are special circumstances requiring that the inquiry or meeting or part of the inquiry or meeting should be held in private--

(a) the grant of a casino licence under section 13;

(b) the amendment of the conditions of a casino licence under section 16;

(c) the definition or redefinition of boundaries of a casino under section 17;

(d) the giving or varying of a direction about the days and times of operation of a casino under section 65.

The Authority may direct that an inquiry or meeting or part of an inquiry or meeting be held in private if it considers it necessary to do so, to prevent the unreasonable divulgence of information relating to the personal affairs of any person including a deceased person; or it is otherwise in the interests of justice or the public interest to do so.

Clause 49 inserts new sections 145 and 146 providing the Authority is to give a written statement after a public hearing or on request. The provisions are identical to the ones provided in clause 21.

Clause 50 inserts new provisions into section 50 of the Act which identical to the provisions in clause 23 dealing with secrecy of information where there is a memorandum of understanding between the Authority and an enforcement agency.

Clause 51 inserts new section 151A in terms identical to clause 24, dealing with a memorandum of understanding with enforcement agencies.

Part 5 – Interactive Gaming (Player Protection) Act 1999

Clause 54 repeals section 24(4) allowing the Authority a discretion to give reasons for its decisions.

Clause 56 inserts new section 43(2) to provide that the Authority may give directions to licensed providers about the conduct of games that the licensed provider is authorised to conduct under this Act; and how licensed providers must foster responsible gambling by players of interactive games in order to minimise harm caused by problem gambling; and accommodate those who gamble without harming themselves or others.

Clause 57 inserts new section 66(3) and (4) to allow the Authority to hold its meetings in public or private. An inquiry or meeting for the purposes of making a finding or a determination relating to the grant of an interactive gaming licence must be conducted in public unless the Authority determines that there are special circumstances requiring that the inquiry or meeting, or part of the inquiry or meeting, should be held in private.

Clause 58 inserts new sections 67A and 67B dealing with the duty of the Authority to give a written statement about certain decisions or on request. The form of the new sections is identical to those inserted by clause 21.

Clause 60 amends section 60 dealing with secrecy (not to divulge certain information) and is similar in scope to the provisions inserted by clause 23.

Clause 61 inserts new section 69A dealing with a memorandum of understanding with enforcement agencies in a form identical to those found in clause 24.

Part 6 – Gaming No. 2 Act 1997

Clause 62 amends section 104(3) dealing with secrecy of information (duty not to divulge) in a form substantially similar to the provisions inserted by clause 23.

Clause 63 inserts new sections 96(3) and (4) relating to public hearings and provides that an inquiry or meeting for the purposes of making a finding or determination relating to the certain matters must be conducted in public unless the Authority determines that there are special circumstances requiring that the inquiry or meeting should be held in private.

The Authority may direct that an inquiry or meeting be held in private if it considers it necessary to do so to prevent the unreasonable divulgence of information relating to the personal affairs of any person including a deceased person; or it is otherwise in the interests of justice or the public interest to do so.

The Committee makes no further comment.

Gaming Acts (Gaming Machine Levy) Bill

Introduced: 25 October 2000
Second Reading Speech: 26 October 2000
House: Legislative Assembly
Minister: Hon. J. Brumby MLA with the Hon. S. Bracks MLA.

Purpose

The purpose of the Bill is to amend the Casino Control Act 1991 and the Gaming Machine Control Act 1991 to impose an annual levy on gaming machines operating in Victoria.

Content and Committee comment

Clause 2 the provisions in the Bill come into operation on the day after Royal Assent.

Clause 3 inserts new sections 114A and 114B in the Casino Control Act 1991.

New section 114A provides that a casino operator must pay to the Director for payment into the Consolidated Fund, each financial year, a levy of $333.33 in respect of each gaming machine operating in the casino on 30 September in that year.

New section 114B provides that in respect of each financial year there is to be paid out of the Consolidated Fund into the Hospitals and Charities Fund under the Health Services Act 1988 an amount equal to the amount paid into the Consolidated Fund under section 114A in that financial year.

Clause 5 inserts new sections 135A and 135B in the Gaming Machine Control Act 1991.

New section 135A provides that a gaming operator must pay to the Director for payment into the Consolidated Fund each financial year a levy of $333.33 in respect of each gaming machine of the gaming operator that is operating at an approved venue on 30 September in that year.

New section 135B provides that in respect of each financial year there is to be paid out of the Consolidated Fund into the Hospitals and Charities Fund under the Health Services Act 1988 an amount equal to the amount paid into the Consolidated Fund under section 135A in that financial year.

The Committee makes no further comment.

Gaming No. 2 (Community Benefit) Bill

Introduced: 25 October 2000
Second Reading Speech: 26 October 2000
House: Legislative Assembly
Minister: Hon. J. Pandazopoulos MLA with the Hon. P. Batchelor MLA.

Purpose

The main purpose of the Bill is to amend the Gaming No. 2 Act 1997 (the Act) to –

  • provide for pooling of funds in bingo centres;

  • make further provision in relation to community and charitable organisations by providing for –

(i) a more transparent application process in relation to declaration of those organisations;

(ii) the conduct of trade promotion lotteries as an adjunct to the community or charitable purposes of those organisations;

(iii) the regulation of expenses charged to those organisations in conducting bingo and selling lucky envelopes;

  • prohibit cash prizes on amusement machines in amusement, tourist and recreational centres;

  • make further provision in the Gaming No. 2 Act 1997 for activities regulated by the Act and administration of that Act.

Content and Committee comment

Clause 2 the provisions in the Bill come into operation on proclamation but not later than by 31 December 2002.

Clause 13 amends section 3 to amend the definition of ‘political party’ to include federally registered parties to be declared as community or charitable organisations.

Clause 15 inserts new sections 12A to 12J dealing with community or charitable organisations and setting out a revised procedure for the declaration of a club or person as a community or charitable organisation. These may include community purpose organisations (as defined by the Act), sporting or recreational clubs or associations of a prescribed kind; or a political party. If the Director refuses an application, the Director may include reasons for that refusal in the written notification. If the Director refuses an application for a declaration, the applicant may appeal against the decision to the Authority. After consideration of an appeal, the Authority may confirm the Director's decision; or order the Director to make a declaration under the Division. The decision of the Authority may include the reasons for its decision.

The Authority may decide to revoke a declaration in respect of a community or charitable organisation, and may give that organisation written notice offering the organisation an opportunity to show cause as to why the declaration should not be revoked on the grounds specified in the notice. A community or charitable organisation which receives a notice may arrange with the Authority for the making of submissions to the Authority as to why the declaration made under this Division in respect of that organisation should not be revoked and the Authority must consider the submission.

A person or organisation which receives written notice of the decision of the Authority under section 12E; or a written notice of the revocation of a declaration under the Division may appeal to the Supreme Court against that decision or revocation.

Clause 19 amends sections 34, 57 and 86 of the Act to extend certain objection or appeal periods from 14 to 28 days.

Clause 23 inserts new section 104A to allow the Authority the power to enter into memorandum of understanding with other enforcement agencies to share information and for the protection of that information.

A memorandum of understanding must specify the kind of information to be divulged and the purposes for which it may be used; and contain an undertaking that each party to the memorandum will use information divulged to it only for the purposes specified in the memorandum; and consents to the taking of injunctive action to restrain the unauthorised use of the information; and contain a provision that applies the law of Victoria to the divulgence of information to the enforcement agency under the memorandum and an acknowledgment that the parties submit to the non-exclusive jurisdiction of the courts of Victoria.

"enforcement agency" means a person or body in Victoria or another jurisdiction (whether in or outside Australia) that is responsible for or engages in the administration of a law with respect to gaming or gambling; or law enforcement generally; or that is approved by the Minister.

Clause 28 inserts a new section 92(5A) providing that if the Authority decides to cancel a bingo employee's licence, the Authority may also disqualify the person whose licence is cancelled from obtaining a licence or permit under the Act, the Gaming Machine Control Act 1991, the Gaming and Betting Act 1994 or the Casino Control Act 1991 for a period not exceeding 4 years.

Clause 29 amends section 92 to allow the Director of Gaming and Betting to suspend an employee’s licence, pending disciplinary action, if the person has been charged with, convicted or found guilty of an offence against the Act or the regulations, the Casino Control Act 1991, the Gaming Machine Control Act 1991, the Club Keno Act 1993, the Gaming and Betting Act 1994 or the Lotteries Gaming and Betting Act 1966 or an offence against regulations made under any of those Acts.

Clause 32 amends section 48 dealing with the monitoring of associates.

The Authority may from time to time investigate an associate of an operator or a person likely to become an associate of an operator.

If the Authority determines that an associate of an operator has engaged or is engaging in conduct that, in the Authority's opinion, is unacceptable for a person who is concerned in or associated with the ownership, administration or management of the operations or business of the operator, the Authority may do either or both of the following –

  • issue a written warning to the associate that the conduct is unacceptable and require the associate to cease that conduct;
  • give written notice to the associate requiring the associate to give a written undertaking to the Authority, within the period specified in the notice, regarding the future conduct of the associate.

Clause 33 inserts a new section 93(1)(aa) to make it an offence for an associate or nominee of a bingo centre to provide false or misleading information.

The Committee makes no further comment.

Gas Industry Acts (Amendment) Bill

Introduced: 1 November 2000
Second Reading Speech: 2 November 2000
House: Legislative Assembly
Minister: Hon. J. Brumby MLA with the Hon. L. Kosky MLA.

Purpose

The main purposes of the Bill are to –

  • amend the Gas Industry Act 1994 to further regulate the gas industry; and

  • amend the Gas Safety Act 1997 to improve the operation of that Act.

Content and Committee comment

Clause 2 Part 1 comes into operation on Royal Assent. Section 4 is deemed to have come into operation on 1 September 2000. The remaining provisions of the Bill come into operation on proclamation but not later than by 31 December 2001.

Part 2 – Amendments to the Gas Industry Act 1994

Clause 5 inserts a new function for VENCORP in section 16C(1)(ia) ‘to facilitate the implementation and operation of, and to provide services in connection with, arrangements for competition in the retail gas market in Victoria’.

Clause 7 inserts a new section 48A of the Gas Industry Act 1994 to provide for the regulation of tariffs for prescribed customers. The section provides –

The Governor in Council may, by Order published in the Government Gazette, regulate, in such manner and in relation to such period as the Governor in Council thinks fit, tariffs for the sale of gas to prescribed customers or a class of prescribed customers.

Part 3 – Amendments to the Gas Safety Act 1997

Clause 17 inserts an additional objective of the Office of Gas Safety (the Office) in the Act as section 10(d) providing –

(d) to promote awareness of energy efficiency through energy efficiency labelling of gas installations, appliances and components and energy efficiency regulation of gas installations, appliances and components.

Clause 22 provides that the Office may, by notice published in the Government Gazette, declare that an appliance or class of appliances is no longer accepted for the purposes of the Act.

Clause 25 inserts new sections 71A to 71C.

71A provides that a person must not knowingly, recklessly or negligently supply or offer to supply or sell or offer to sell an appliance that is unsafe.

71B provides that a person must not, in connection with the supply or possible supply or sale of a Type A appliance, affix a label or compliance plate to the appliance that falsely represents that the appliance has been, and continues to be accepted under an acceptance scheme authorised under this Division; or accepted by the Office under this Division.

71C provides that a person must not knowingly, recklessly or negligently make a modification to a Type A appliance that would make the appliance unsafe to use if the appliance were used for its intended purpose.

Clause 26 substitutes a new section 76 dealing with the prohibition of supply or sale of gas installations, appliances and components. The Office, by notice published in the Government Gazette and in a newspaper circulating generally in the State, may prohibit the supply or sale of a gas installation or gas installations of a specified class; or an appliance or appliances of a specified class; or a component or components of a specified class.

Clause 28 substitutes a new section 78 dealing with the recall of gas installations, appliances or components.

Clause 29 repeals section 79A and inserts new sections 79A to 79D providing for further offences relating to gas safety.

79A a person, other than a gas company, must not knowingly supply or offer to supply or sell or offer to sell any type of liquefied petroleum gas for use in an appliance unless that gas meets the prescribed standards of quality; and the appliance is designed to be operated on that type of gas; and the person complies with the prescribed requirements in relation to the supply or sale of that gas.

79B provides that a person must not carry out any excavation or boring or open any ground so as to uncover or expose any pipeline owned or operated by a gas company unless the person has the authority of that gas company to do so; or if notice of the person's intention to do so is required to be given to that gas company under the regulations, the person gives that notice.

79C provides that a person must not carry out any excavation or boring or open any ground within 3 metres of a transmission pipeline unless the person has the authority of the gas company which owns or operates the transmission pipeline to do so; or if notice of the person's intention to do so is required to be given to that gas company under the regulations, the person gives that notice.

79D provides that a person must not knowingly, recklessly or negligently break, injure, open or tamper with any pipeline, gas installation or meter assembly.

Clause 31 amends section 81 to provide for a right of appeal against a declaration under section 69A that an appliance or class of appliances is no longer accepted.

Clause 32 substitutes a new section 86(4) to provide that an inspector must produce his or her identity card for inspection before performing a function under this Act or the Gas Industry Act 1994; and at any time during the performance of a function under this Act or the Gas Industry Act 1994, if asked to do so.

Clause 33 inserts new provisions in section 87 of the Act relating to powers of entry. New sub-section (1A) provides that inspectors must have prior written consent of the Office before each exercise of a power of entry for the purpose of monitoring the safety of gas installations; or determining compliance with this Act or the regulations.

New sub-section (2A) provides that an inspector may not for a purpose set out in sub-section (1)(c) or (d), enter a residence; or land (other than land that is used for a commercial or industrial purpose) on which a residence is situated.

New section 87(6) provides that if an inspector exercises a power of entry under this section, without the owner or occupier being present, the inspector must on leaving the land or premises, leave a notice setting out the time of entry and certain other details.

Clause 35 inserts a new Part 6A consisting of new sections 117AB to 117AK, to provide for the service of infringement notices for contravention of certain provisions in the Act.

117AC an inspector may serve an infringement notice on any person that he or she has reason to believe has committed a prescribed offence. An infringement notice may be served on a person by delivering it personally to the person; or by sending it by post addressed to the person's last known place of residence or business.

117AJ provides that a charge may be filed in respect of an offence to which an infringement notice relates if the infringement penalty has not been paid within the time for payment stated in the notice.

Clause 36 inserts a number of heads of regulation making power in section 118(1) of the Act relating to energy efficiency for proclaimed gas equipment. The new heads of regulation making power are –

(ya) the standards of energy efficiency and performance required for proclaimed gas equipment;

(yb) prohibiting or regulating the supply or offer of supply of proclaimed gas equipment;

(yc) the registration of proclaimed gas equipment, including--

(i) applications for registration and the renewal, modification or transfer of registration and the information to accompany the applications (including details about tests);

(ii) the granting of registration;

(iii) conditions on registration;

(iv) the transfer of registration;

(v) variation of registration;

(vi) the refusal and cancellation of registration;

(vii) the renewal and duration of registration;

(viii) the keeping of registers of proclaimed gas equipment and registration holders;

(yd) the testing, marking and labelling of proclaimed gas equipment, including the provision of samples of that equipment and labels to the Office for testing and the disposal of those samples;

(ye) reasonable fees and charges to be charged for or for the recovery of reasonable costs for--

(i) the testing, examination, marking or labelling of proclaimed gas equipment;

(ii) the preparation of reports about proclaimed gas equipment;

(iii) the registration, renewal of registration, modification of registration or transfer of registration of proclaimed gas equipment;

(yf) authorising or requiring the giving of public notices in relation to proclaimed gas equipment and the recovery of costs associated with those notices.

The Committee accepts that the additional heads of regulation making powers are appropriate to give effect to the purposes of the Act.

The Committee makes no further comment.

Land (Further Revocation of Reservations) Bill

Introduced: 25 October 2000
Second Reading Speech: 26 October 2000
House: Legislative Assembly
Minister: Hon. S. Garbutt MLA with the Hon. P. Batchelor MLA.

Purpose

The main purpose of the Bill is to provide for the revocation of reservations over several parcels of land and the revocation of a Crown grant affecting one of those parcels.

Content and Committee comment

Clause 2 except for section 5, item 3 of Schedule 1 and Schedule 3, the provisions in the Bill come into operation on the day after Royal Assent. Section 5, item 3 of Schedule 1 and Schedule 3 come into operation on proclamation but not later than by 1 July 2001.

Clause 3 provides for the revocation of the reservation of land at Barwon Heads specified in item 1 of Schedule 1.

Clause 4 provides for the revocation of reservation and Crown grant over land at Ballarat (Old Colonists Association land) as specified in item 2 of Schedule 1, in order to facilitate the disposal of the land.

Clause 5 provides for the revocation of the reservation of a portion of land at South Melbourne set out in item 3 of Schedule 1.

Clause 6 provides that on the revocation of an Order in Council reserving land, that land is deemed to be unalienated land of the Crown, freed and discharged from all trusts, limitations, reservations, restrictions, encumbrances, estates and interests. Further the appointment of any committee of management of that land is revoked to the extent that it relates to that land; and any regulations under section 13 of the Crown Land (Reserves) Act 1978 are revoked to the extent that they apply to that land.

The Committee makes no further comment.

Magistrates’ Court (Committal Proceedings) Bill

Introduced: 25 October 2000
Second Reading Speech: 26 October 2000
House: Legislative Assembly
Minister: Hon. R. Hulls MLA with the Hon. P. Batchelor MLA.

Purpose

The purpose of the Bill is to amend the Magistrates' Court Act 1989 (the Act) so as to make further reforms to the committal process.

Content and Committee comment

Clause 2 the provisions in the Bill come into operation on proclamation, but not laterr than by
1 July 2001.

Clause 5 amends sections 56(7)(a) and (b) of the Act to permit the court to remand in custody or grant bail to a defendant at a date before the trial commences, for example to the date of a pre-trial hearing used in the County or Supreme Courts as part of the trial management process.

Compulsory examination of witnesses

Clause 6 makes amendments to section 56A dealing with the compulsory examination procedure introduced into the Act in 1999 where a person (potential witness) refuses to make a statement to investigators.

The Committee notes the comments in the Second Reading Speech –

Compulsory examination procedure

If a witness refuses to make a statement, the police may apply to the court for an order to examine that witness under oath in open court. This procedure is sometimes necessary in fraud cases where employees of financial institutions are increasingly reluctant to provide statements because doing so may breach a confidentiality agreement with their client. There is a clear public interest in ensuring that investigations are not stopped because of such arrangements. This power was provided by the previous government in its amendments introduced in 1999.

However, when strong powers are provided it is important that appropriate safeguards are also provided. This Bill provides those safeguards. The court will be provided with important information, such as whether the witness is a suspect in the proceedings and whether the witness has received legal advice concerning the proposed examination. Further, the defence will now be able to be present when this examination takes place and may, in exceptional circumstances, address the court concerning this proceeding.

The amendments will provide that a court may only make an order under the section if it is in the interests of justice to do so. In section 56A(1) the words ‘without notice to the defendant’ are to be deleted.

New section 56(1A) clarifies that the procedure may only be used if a charge has been filed against the defendant in relation to the matter to which the proposed examination relates; and may be made with or without notice to the defendant.

In an application, the informant must advise the Court whether the person sought to be examined has been asked by the prosecution to make a statement; and has refused to do so; and whether the informant is aware whether the person sought to be examined has obtained legal advice concerning the proposed examination; and whether the person sought to be examined is or has been a suspect with respect to the matter to which the proposed examination relates; and whether the person sought to be examined has been made aware of the application.

If the person sought to be examined in an application is or has been a suspect with respect to the matter to which the proposed examination relates, the informant must give reasonable notice of the application to that person or a legal practitioner representing that person, whether or not any charge against that person has been filed or determined.

If an order for examination is made the defendant may attend a proceeding and, if the Court determines there are exceptional circumstances, may address the Court on the proceeding personally or through a legal practitioner representing him or her.

A person ordered to attend the Court for examination may be represented by a legal practitioner and may address the Court personally or through a legal practitioner representing him or her.

Committal proceedings

New test for leave to cross-examine

Clause 7(9) introduces a new test to be applied in considering whether defence leave to cross-examine a witness at committal. The current test requires the defence to show the scope and purpose of the proposed questioning and how it has substantial relevance to the facts in issue.

The test as substituted by the Bill will require the defence to show ‘an issue to which the proposed questioning relates, and give a reason as to why the evidence of the witness is relevant to that issue and why cross-examination on that issue is justified’.

If the defence gives notice that it seeks leave to cross-examine a witness, the informant must give reasons if that application is opposed. In determining whether to grant leave to cross-examine a witness, the Court may have regard to whether the informant consents to or opposes leave being granted.

Clause 7(12) amends clause 13 of Schedule 5 in the Act and substitutes new sub-clauses (4) and (5) and inserts a new sub-clause (5A) providing for the matters to be considered by the court in determining whether leave to cross-examine should be granted.

Subject to clause 16 of the Schedule (oppressive, irrelevant or repetitive questioning), a defendant who obtains leave to cross-examine a witness is not limited to cross-examining the witness on the issue with respect to which leave was obtained.

Witnesses under 18 years

New sub-clause (5B) deals with witnesses under 18 years. It provides that if the witness is under 18 years of age the Court must have regard to the need to minimise the trauma that might be experienced by the witness in giving evidence; and any relevant condition or characteristic of the witness, including, age, culture, personality, education and level of understanding; and any mental, intellectual or physical disability to which the witness is or appears to be subject and of which the Court is aware; and the importance of the witness to the case for the prosecution; and the existence, or lack, of evidence that corroborates the proposed evidence of the witness; and the extent of any proposed admissions; and the probative value of the proposed evidence of the witness; and the issues likely to be in dispute; and the weight of the proposed evidence of the witness; and any statements of other witnesses that contradict the proposed evidence of the witness.

Clause 7(13) amends clause 24(1)(b) of Schedule 5 to allow a court to remand in custody or grant bail to a defendant at a date before the trial commences and not just to the day the trial commences. This will enable a court to bail a defendant to appear at a pre-trial hearing.

Clause 8 substitutes a new clause 16 in Schedule 5 of the Act dealing with the circumstances where a court may disallow a question or questioning of a witness.

Clause 9 inserts a new clause 24A in Schedule 5 of the Act and provides that an application may be made to call a witness for examination following the committal of the defendant to stand trial. For example where a witness has made a statement or a supplementary statement, examination or further examination of the witness may be necessary.

Clause 10 makes transitional provisions. Subject to certain exceptions the amendments to committal proceedings apply to a hearing of charges filed on or after the commencement of the Bill.

Amendments to the Crimes Act 1958

Clause 11 amends section 359AA of the Crimes Act 1958. The amendments will enable the Supreme Court and the County Court to sentence a defendant in relation to any outstanding summary offence to which the defendant proposes to plead guilty.

Clause 12 provides that the amendment of section 359AA apply to applications made under that section on or after the commencement of the Bill, irrespective of when the charge for the summary offence was filed under section 26 of the Magistrates' Court Act 1989.

The Committee makes no further comment.

Magistrates’ Court (Infringements) Bill

Introduced: 25 October 2000
Second Reading Speech: 26 October 2000
House: Legislative Assembly
Minister: Hon. R. Hulls MLA with the Hon. P. Batchelor MLA.

Purpose

The main purposes of the Bill are to –

  • amend the Magistrates' Court Act 1989 (the Act) to

(i) give infringement notice defaulters a chance to be heard by a magistrate (the Court) if they are imprisoned for more than 2 days; and

(ii) facilitate the use of instalment arrangements for the payment of infringement penalties; and

(iii) make various changes in relation to enforcement orders; and

(iv) enhance sheriff's officers' powers with respect to the enforcement of infringement penalties; and

  • amend the Sentencing Act 1991 and the Chattel Securities Act 1987.

Content and Committee content

Clause 2 sections 1 and 2 come into operation on Royal Assent. The remaining provisions come into operation on proclamation, but not later than by 1 July 2001.

Clause 3 amends section 82D3 of the Act to give sheriff’s officers a discretion not to break and enter in circumstances when executing a warrant to search for property, where peaceful entry is refused and it is apparent that the person does not have sufficient property to satisfy the sums named in the warrant. The provisions of section 82D already provide for the arrest of a person where the person executing a warrant cannot find sufficient personal property of the person named in the warrant.

Clause 4 inserts new sections 82G, 82H and 82I dealing the Sheriff’s powers in executing a warrant.

New section 82G provides that if the sheriff believes on reasonable grounds that a person may be the defendant named in a warrant being executed by the sheriff, the sheriff may request the person to state his or her name and ordinary place of residence or business. In making the request, the sheriff must inform the person of the grounds for his or her belief in relation to the person's identity.

A person who, in response to the request refuses or fails to comply with the request without a reasonable excuse for not doing so; or states a name that is false in a material particular; or states an address other than the full and correct address of his or her ordinary place of residence or business is guilty of an offence. Penalty: 5 penalty units.

If a person states a name and address in response to a request and the sheriff suspects on reasonable grounds that the stated name or address may be false, the sheriff may request the person to produce evidence of the correctness of the name and address. The person must comply with the request, unless he or she has a reasonable excuse for not doing so.

It is not an offence for a person to fail to comply with a request if the sheriff did not inform the person, at the time the request was made, that it is an offence to fail to comply with the request.

New section 82H permits the sheriff or a person directed by the sheriff to execute a warrant to restrain a person who is hindering the execution of the warrant.

Clause 6 inserts a new section 137A and clarifies the Sheriff’s powers to deal with unsold or sold but uncollected seized property.

Clause 7 amends Schedule 7 of the Act to permit certain Commonwealth offences that are applied laws of Victoria to use the PERIN procedure (Penalty Enforcement by Registration of Infringement Notices).

Clause 8 makes further amendments to Schedule 7 to permit a part paid infringements to be registered with the PERIN system for enforcement.

Clause 9 will permit the registrar on the application of a defaulter to revoke the enforcement order and refer the matter to the Court.

Clause 10 inserts a new clause 10A in Schedule 7 to provide that the registrar may on his or her own initiative, revoke an enforcement order and refer the matter of the alleged offence to the Court for hearing and determination at any time if the registrar is satisfied that the matter would be more appropriately dealt with by the Court. Revocation could, for example, be made where the defaulter has a disability or is unrepresented and the matter be referred to open Court where the defaulters circumstances can be taken into account in the sentencing process.

Clause 11 inserts new clauses 14A to 14B into Schedule 7 to provide that enforcement orders expire after 5 years if the warrant is not executed within 5 years (other than where an installment arrangement exists). The unpaid infringement is then written off for accounting purposes. Expired enforcement orders can be re-instated where a defendant is located after the order has expired.

Clause 13 inserts a Part 4 in Schedule 7 comprising new clauses 21 to 27 of the Act. The amendments provide for a hearing for defaulters who are not assessed as suitable for a community custodial permit under the Corrections Act 1986 in default of payment of the infringement. Currently persons assessed as being unsuitable for such community service are imprisoned.

The hearing provides a mechanism to assess the suitability of a custodial sentence in each case. For example where the defaulter suffers from a mental disorder or other impairment or other exceptional circumstances. In such a case the Court may dismiss the matter in whole or in part or adjourn the matter on conditions as the Court thinks fit. If the person does not appear at the hearing they may be arrested.

Onus of proof

New clause 25 provides that a person brought before the Court under Part 4 of Schedule 7, bears the onus of satisfying the Court with respect to any matter before the Court.

The Committee notes the reverse onus provision in clause 25 and accepts that special or exceptional circumstances would rest within the exclusive knowledge of the infringement defaulter and it is therefore appropriate and necessary for the provision to apply in these circumstances for the court to assess whether imprisonment is the most suitable sentencing option.

Clause 14 is a transitional provision amending Schedule 8 and provides that in order to apply consistent procedures for all warrants the new provisions introduced in the Bill apply to infringement notices issued prior to the commencement of the Bill.

Clause 15 amends section 16 of the Sentencing Act 1991 to clarify that PERIN sentences of imprisonment are served cumulatively.

The Committee makes no further comment.

Marine (Amendment) Bill

Introduced: 1 November 2000
Second Reading Speech: 2 November 2000
House: Legislative Assembly
Minister: Hon. P. Batchelor MLA with the Hon. J. Brumby MLA.

Purpose

The main purposes of the Bill are to amend the Marine Act 1988 (the Act) to –

  • make provision for the licensing of operators of registered recreational vessels; and

  • make other necessary amendments.

The Committee notes the following extract from the Second Reading Speech –

This Bill provides for improved marine safety in Victoria through the introduction of licensing for operators of registered recreational vessels.

Boat operator licensing

Licensing will contribute to improved marine safety by ensuring that operators will have to demonstrate a basic knowledge of water rules and safe boat operation. In addition to improving the competence of operators, licensing will ensure that unsuitable people are not permitted to operate; contribute to improved awareness of safe boat operation; and assist law enforcement and accident investigation.

The majority of Australian jurisdictions, with the exception of Victoria, Northern Territory and Western Australia, already require operators of recreational boats to be licensed. The licensing scheme put forward in this Bill is consistent with principles and competencies adopted by the National Marine Safety Council and will promote the broad objectives of national consistency and mutual recognition of marine qualifications across jurisdictions.

The Bill applies licensing to all operators of registered recreational boats, defined in Victoria as any boat equipped with an engine that is used or is capable of being used for propulsion. This approach is considered the simplest to communicate, enforce and administer and mirrors vehicle driver licensing arrangements under which a licence is required to drive any registered vehicle.

The Bill provides the marine board with the power to grant a licence to a person who has passed an appropriate test, undergone appropriate training or already holds a relevant marine qualification.

Knowledge tests are proposed as the basis for licence testing in Victoria, as they are readily accessible and easily administered, particularly in computer-based forms. The format would be similar to the knowledge test for driver licences and would take about 20 minutes to administer and complete. Applicants would also be encouraged to gain their licences through satisfactory completion of an approved boat training course.

The Bill establishes two categories of licence, a general operator licence, which authorises the licensee to drive any registered recreational boat except a PWC, and a restricted operator licence, which applies restricted conditions to young operators aged more than 12 years and less than 16 years.

In the case of PWCs, the Bill requires that a specific licence endorsement be obtained subject to the applicant satisfying certain additional requirements established by the marine board.

The Bill provides the marine board with adequate powers to properly administer the licensing scheme, including powers to cancel, suspend or vary licences and vary or revoke PWC endorsements. To ensure consistency with the Road Safety Act, the Bill provides for external appeals to be heard through the Magistrates Court.

The Bill establishes an appropriate offence and penalty regime which adopts as far as practicable the framework that exists in the Road Safety Act.

A zero blood alcohol requirement is proposed for all licence-holders under 21 years of age.

The Bill provides for the staged implementation of the licensing scheme with operators of PWCs and young operators aged between 12 and 21 years to be licensed first, followed by other operators. It is proposed that by 1 January 2003 the act will apply to all Victorian operators.

The Bill establishes a transitional period for over 40,000 Victorians who currently hold operator licences issued by other states, primarily New South Wales. These operators will be required to convert to a Victorian licence on expiration of their current licence or after three years of the commencement of licensing in Victoria, whichever is the earlier. No further testing will be required on conversion of an interstate licence. At the end of the three-year period the one licence, one operator principle will apply, consistent with national principles that apply to driver licences.

Content and Committee comment

Clause 2 the provisions of the Bill come into operation on proclamation but not later than by 1 February 2002.

Clause 3 provides new definitions for ‘operator licence’, ‘regulated recreational vessel’ and ‘prescribed concentration of blood alcohol’.

‘prescribed concentration of blood alcohol’ means –

(a) in the case of a person who is under the age of 21 years and who is in charge of a regulated recreational vessel under way, a concentration of alcohol present in the blood of that person of 0·00 grams per 100 millilitres of blood; and

(b) in the case of any other person, a concentration of alcohol present in the blood of that person of 0·05 grams per 100 millilitres of blood;'.

Clause 5 amends section 19(4) to make it an offence to fail to produce an operator licence, certificate or exemption on demand.

Clause 6 substitutes section 22 and inserts new section 22A. The sections create the offences of dangerous operating and careless operation of a vessel. The offences extend to both commercial and recreational vessels.

As with the mirror offences under the Road Safety Act 1986, if on a prosecution for an offence for dangerous operation the court is not satisfied that the defendant is guilty of that offence but is satisfied that the defendant is guilty of careless operating under section 22A, the court may convict the defendant of an offence against section 22A and punish the defendant accordingly.

22A provides that a person must not operate a vessel carelessly.

Clause 8 inserts a new section 28(8) providing that on convicting a person, or finding a person guilty, of an offence involving alcohol or other drugs the court must cause to be entered in the records of the court the level of concentration of alcohol found to be present in that person's blood.

Clause 9 inserts new section 28A to 28D dealing with the matters relating to alcohol offences.

28A makes provisions about cancellation and disqualification on convicting a person, or finding a person guilty, of an offence under section 28(1)(b), (e) or (f) involving a regulated recreational vessel.

28B deals with how previous convictions are to be used for the purposes of the Act.

28C deals with the circumstances where immediate suspension of operator licence apply.

28D deals with an appeal to the Magistrates’ Court against suspension of operator licence under section 28C.

Clause 10 inserts a new section 31A(2A) dealing with the disqualification of a person’s operator licence for conviction for refusal to allow the taking of a blood sample.

Clause 13 inserts a new section 61BA dealing with the suspension of operator licence for drink-operator marine infringements of 6 months or if the person is not the holder of an operator licence, he or she is disqualified from obtaining such a licence for a period of 6 months.

Clause 15 inserts an additional delegation provision to allow the Board to delegate any of its powers (other than the power to delegate) to –

(ba) the Roads Corporation established under Part II of the Transport Act 1983.

The Committee accepts that the delegation provision is appropriate to give effect to the purposes of the Act.

Clause 17 inserts anew section 86A providing that if a person has, within sight of a member of the police force, committed an offence against Part 4 or Part 10A and that person is in charge of a vessel, the member of the police force may take charge of the vessel and may move it to an appropriate place; or direct another person to move the vessel to an appropriate place.[Part 4 deals with alcohol offences and Part 10A is inserted by clause 22 and deal with licensing of operators of recreational vessels.]

Clause 18 inserts a new section 89A dealing with obtaining licences, certificates, notices or other documents by false statements.

Clause 19 inserts new section 101A dealing with the improper disclosure of information and provides that the Board or a relevant person must not disclose information gained by the Board or in the course of the delegation, employment or engagement of the relevant person that is information of a personal nature or that has commercial sensitivity for the person about whom it is kept; or use the person's knowledge of any such information.

Sub-section (2) identifies the circumstances where it is lawful to make appropriate disclosures such as for the purposes of any legal proceedings or where the disclosure or use is necessary to prevent or lessen a serious or imminent threat to the life or health of one or more people.

Clause 21 amends section 109(1) to allow the Governor in Council, by regulation, to fix a fee or other amount to be imposed on licence holders, applicants for licences, persons in whose names vessels are registered or any other class of persons for the provision and maintenance of boating facilities and services for the public; and for the conduct of boating safety, boating education and boating promotion programs for the public.

Clause 22 inserts new Part 10A dealing with the licensing of operators of recreational vessels.

New Part 10A consists of new sections 113 to 135.

113 sets out definitions including for ‘general recreational vessel’, ‘personal watercraft’.

114 sets out the main purposes of the new licensing requirements.

115 makes it an offence to operate certain classes of recreational vessels without a licence.

116 provides that the Board may grant a general operator licence to a person if the person is of or over the age of 16 years; and is eligible to apply for the licence; and the Board is satisfied that the person has satisfactorily completed any requirements of the Board as to testing and qualifications. The Board may grant, renew or vary a general operator licence or may refuse to grant, renew or vary such a licence.

117 the Board may grant a restricted operator licence to a person if the person is of or over the age of 12 years and less than 16 years of age; and the person is eligible to apply for the licence; and the Board is satisfied that the person has satisfactorily completed any requirement of the Board as to testing and qualifications.

118 deals with personal watercraft endorsements where a person has applied for an operator licence; or who is the holder of an operator licence and who satisfies the Board that he or she is qualified to operate a personal watercraft may, on application to the Board, have the licence issued to or held by that person endorsed to allow that person to operate a personal watercraft.

120 the Board may require a person to undergo health or competency testing to determine the fitness of that person to hold a licence for a recreational vehicle.

Section 120(4) and (5) provide –

(4) No action may be taken against a person who carries out a test under this section and who expresses to the Board an opinion formed by that person as a result of the test.

(5) No action may be taken against a person who, in good faith, reports to the Board any information which discloses or suggests that a person is unfit to operate a regulated recreational vessel or that it may be dangerous to allow that person to hold or be granted an operator licence or a variation of such a licence.

[Refer to section 85 of the Constitution Act 1975 report below].

121 a court may cancel, suspend, disqualify or vary licences if a court convicts a person of, or is satisfied that a person is guilty of, an offence against the Act.

122 deals with the effect of suspension of a licence.

123 a disqualified person must not apply for a licence.

125 if the Board decides to refuse an application for an operator licence or an application to renew or vary an operator licence; refuse an application for a personal watercraft endorsement or an application to renew or vary such an endorsement; impose or vary a condition on an operator licence or a personal watercraft endorsement; suspend, cancel or vary an operator licence; revoke a personal watercraft endorsement the affected person may appeal against that decision to the Magistrates' Court.

126 provides for appeals from decisions of the Magistrates' Court to the County Court.

127 the Board must notify any affected person of right to appeal to the Magistrates’ Court under section 125.

129 provides that a person must not operate a general recreational vessel in breach of any condition of the person's operator licence.

130 provides that a person, who is exempted under the regulations from the requirement to comply with section 115 because he or she holds an appropriate licence or certificate issued in another State, Territory or country, must not operate a regulated recreational vessel in breach of any condition of that licence or certificate.

131 creates an offence to operate a regulated recreational vessel while disqualified.

132 a court convicting a person of an offence against section 131(1) may order the cancellation of the registration of the vessel in respect of which the offence was committed, if that vessel is owned by that person, and order the Board not to register that vessel again during such time (if any) as the court specifies.

133 a person who holds an operator licence must have the licence in his or her possession while operating a regulated recreational vessel.

134 the owner of a general recreational vessel must not allow another person to operate that vessel unless that person is the holder of an operator licence which authorises that person to operate a general recreational vessel.

The owner of a personal watercraft must not allow another person to operate that watercraft unless that other person is the holder of an operator licence that is endorsed with a personal watercraft endorsement which authorises that person to operate a personal watercraft.

It is a defence to a charge under this section if the owner reasonably believes that the operator held the appropriate licence which has (where the case so requires) the appropriate endorsement.

The Committee notes that a strict liability offence is created by section 134 and that it is a defence to the charge to establish a reasonable belief that the operator held the appropriate licence. The Committee recognises that by virtue of this defence a reverse onus of proof situation is a consequential result.

Under the circumstances the Committee accepts the need for the provision.

135 provides that Part 10A does not apply to a person who is operating a general recreational vessel; and who is of or over the age of 21 years until 12 months after the commencement of Part 10A.

Clause 23 adds Division 2 of Part 11 and allows a person who is the holder of a licence or authority issued in another State or Territory of the Commonwealth, which is the equivalent of an operator licence; and who is a resident of Victoria; to be ddemed to be the holder of an operator licence for 3 years from the commencement of Part 10A of the Bill.

Clause 24 adds the following regulation making powers to Schedule 5 of the Act –

28A. The carriage and display of certificates of survey or certified copies of such certificates on vessels.

62CA. The persons responsible for the safe-keeping of samples of blood taken under section 31A and the methods of storage to be used by them.

62CB. The delivering of portions of samples of blood taken under section 31A to the people from whom they are taken and to members of the police force.

The Committee accepts that the regulation making powers are appropriate to give effect to the purposes of the Act.

Clause 25 provides that the Act is amended as set out in the Schedule. The Schedule provides that after item 81 in Schedule 5 of the Act inserts items 82 to 107. The items insert the numerous points on the licensing of operators to the existing list of possible subjects for regulation in Schedule 5.

Report to the Parliament pursuant section 4D(b)(i) and (ii) of the Parliamentary Committees Act 1968 concerning a repeal alteration or variation of section 85 of the Constitution Act 1975.

Clause 20 inserts new section 107AA into the Act declaring that it is the intention of section 120 as inserted by clause 22 of the Bill to alter or vary section 85 of the Constitution Act 1975.

The Committee notes the following section 85 of the Constitution Act 1975 statement from the Second Reading Speech –

Clause 20 of the Bill inserts a new section 107AA into the Marine Act 1988 which provides that it is the intention of section 120 of that Act to alter or vary section 85 of the Constitution Act 1975. Section 120 is being inserted into the Marine Act 1988 by clause 22 of this Bill.

The proposed new section 120 reflects section 27 of the Road Safety Act 1986. Section 120 enables the Marine Board to require a licence-holder or an applicant for a licence to undergo certain tests. These tests will enable the board to find out if the person is unfit to operate a powered recreational vessel or if it would be dangerous for them to operate a vessel. Consistent with the Road Safety Act, the section contains two statutory immunities that prevent certain persons who advise the board from being sued, including by an action commenced in the Supreme Court. As a result of these immunities this section is the subject of a statement pursuant to section 85 of the Constitution Act.

These immunities are considered appropriate and necessary in the circumstances. If the Marine Board is going to properly perform its safety function, it needs to be provided with relevant information so that it can prevent persons who are dangerous or unfit to operate powered recreational vessels from doing so. It is essential that persons who have relevant information can make full and frank disclosures to the board. First, sub-section (4) protects persons, such as medical practitioners, who conduct the relevant tests and then advise the board of their opinion. Persons who conduct these tests should be free to advise the board honestly of their opinion without the fear that in doing so they expose themselves to the risk of being sued. Secondly, sub-section (5) protects persons who in good faith report information which discloses or suggests that a person is unfit to operate a powered recreational vessel or that it may be dangerous for that person to hold a licence. This provision will enable persons, such as a concerned family member or friend, to warn the board if they think it is dangerous for someone to continue operating such a vessel.

Those who disclose such information will be protected from being sued providing they have acted in good faith.

The Committee has examined the proposed section 85 of the Constitution Act 1975 clause and notes the Minister’s statement in the Second Reading Speech and accepts that the provision is consistent with the purposes of the Bill.

The Committee makes no further comment.

Melbourne City Link (Miscellaneous Amendments) Bill

Introduced: 25 October 2000
Second Reading Speech: 26 October 2000
House: Legislative Assembly
Minister: Hon. P. Batchelor MLA with the Hon. R. Hulls MLA.

Purpose

The purpose of the Bill is to –

  • repeal certain provisions of the Melbourne City Link Act 1995 (the Act) relating to land and other matters and to make miscellaneous amendments to the Act relating to the tolling provisions and other matters;

  • repeal the Melbourne City Link Authority Act 1994;

  • make amendments to other Acts and other necessary provisions.

Content and Committee comment

Clause 2 Part 1 and section 43 come into operation on the day after Royal Assent. The remaining provisions come into operation on proclamation but not later than by 31 December 2002.

Part 2 – Amendments to the Melbourne City Link Act 1995

Evidentiary provision

Clause 20 inserts a new 72(4) providing that if a vehicle owner nominates another person as the actual driver (and therefore the person liable to pay the toll), that nomination may be used in evidence.

Clause 21 amends section 73C (temporary registration) to enable regulations to be made to extend the time in which a late day pass may be purchased.

Privacy of toll information

Clauses 22, 24 and 25

City Link users may be sent certain information

Clause 22 amends section 77. The amendments clarify the circumstances in which the operator of the toll-way, Transurban, may request the enforcement agency to send* to City Link users either or both the following –

  • A notice about tolling requirements to be sent to vehicle owners (this option expires on 1 July 2001).

  • A request for payment to a person who appears to be liable for a toll (either the vehicle owner or the person nominated by the owner).

*Under privacy laws Transurban does not have direct access to motor registration records.

Tolling information may be disclosed to investigate theft of e-Tags or unlawful use of a toll way to transport dangerous goods or waste.

Clause 24 amends section 90A which provides that tolling information not to be disclosed or used except in specified circumstances. The clause inserts new paragraphs (aa) and (ab) in sub-section (2). Section 90A(2) provides that a person to whom the section applies must not disclose or use restricted tolling information unless the disclosure or use –

(aa) is reasonably necessary –

(i) to investigate whether or not there has been any loss, theft or misuse of prescribed tolling devices; or

(ii) to take any enforcement action in relation to any theft or misuse of a prescribed tolling device; or

(ab) is reasonably necessary, either, to investigate whether or not there has been any breach of, or to enforce –

(i) any provision of the Dangerous Goods Act 1985, or regulations made under that Act; or

(ii) any provision of the Transport Act 1983, or regulations made under that Act; or

(iii) any provision of the Road Transport (Dangerous Goods) Act 1995, or regulations made under that Act or the applied provisions within the meaning of that Act; or

(iv) any provision of Part 9A of the Environment Protection Act 1970, or regulations made under that Act –

which relates to the transport of dangerous goods or waste on the Link road or Extension road.

New section 90A(2)(aa) will allow police to obtain access to restricted information for use in investigating the loss or theft of e-Tags. Police already have powers to investigate serious criminal matters and must keep audits of such information obtained under section 90C. No such audit trails are required under the amended section 90A(2). However police access and handling of such information is subject to the monitoring of the Ombudsman.

New section 90A(2)(ab) will enable restricted tolling information to be used in the enforcement of laws relating to the transport of dangerous goods or waste.

Tolling information may be retained longer than 2 years pending legal proceedings

Clause 25 inserts new section 93(3) providing an exception to the destruction of tolling records after 2 years in circumstances where records are required to be retained for legal proceedings.

Clause 38 repeals the Melbourne City Link Authority Act 1994.

Melbourne City Link Authority abolished

Clause 39 makes transitional arrangements to the repeal in clause 38 and provides (amongst other things) the Melbourne City Link Authority is abolished and its members go out of office. The clause also provides for the usual transfer or all rights and obligations to the State.

Clause 43 repeals sub-sections (2) and (5) of section 18 of the Melbourne City Link (Amendment) Act 1998. The provisions in the 1998 amending Act repealed sections 77(1)(a) and 78(1) of the Act. The repeal of the repealing sections has the effect of retaining in the Act the provisions that enable warning letters to be sent to toll defaulters. Without this clause these provisions would have ceased on 31 December 2000.

Clause 44 amends section 259(2)(c) of the Melbourne and Metropolitan Board of Works Act 1958 to refer to the ‘Bolte Bridge’ by that name.

The Committee makes no further comment.

Nurses (Amendment) Bill

Introduced: 25 October 2000
Second Reading Speech: 26 October 2000
House: Legislative Assembly
Minister: Hon. J. Thwaites MLA with the Hon. P. Batchelor MLA.

Purpose

The main purposes of the Bill are to make miscellaneous amendments to the Nurses Act 1993 (the Act) and to amend the Drugs, Poisons and Controlled Substances Act 1981.

Content and Committee comment

Clause 2 sections 1 and 2 come into operation on the day after Royal Assent. The remaining provisions come into operation on proclamation, but not later than by 1 November 2001.

Clause 3 amends the definition of ‘unprofessional conduct’ in section 3 and inserts a new paragraph (c)(iv) –

(iv) in the case of a nurse practitioner, an offence as a nurse practitioner under any other Act or regulations;

The amendment further defines ‘unprofessional conduct’ and inserts new paragraphs (d) to (h) as follows –

(d) professional conduct which is of a lesser standard than that which might reasonably be expected of a registered nurse by her or his peers; or

(e) providing a person with nursing services of a kind that is excessive, unnecessary or not reasonably required for that person's well-being; or

(f) influencing or attempting to influence the conduct of a nurse's practice in such a way that patient care may be compromised; or

(g) the failure to act as a nurse when required under an Act or regulations to do so; or

(h) the contravention of or failure to comply with a condition, limitation or restriction on the registration or endorsement of registration of the nurse imposed by or under this Act.

Clause 4 amends section 5 to provide that the Board may require evidence of professional indemnity insurance for the purpose of registration.

Clause 5 amends section 7 and will allow the Board the right to refuse registration if not satisfied that the applicant for registration will have adequate professional indemnity insurance. The Board may grant registration conditional on certain minimum insurance terms and conditions.

Clause 6 inserts new section 8B permitting a nurse, after completion of a prescribed course of studies to obtain and supply certain Schedule 2, 3, 4 and 8 poisons within the meaning of the Drugs, Poisons and Controlled Substances Act 1981. The Board may endorse the registration to permit such nurses to use the title ‘nurse practitioner’ to denote the qualification.

Clause 8 amends section 10 to allow a nurse to make submissions to the Board, if the Board intends to refuse to make an endorsement or imposes any limitations or restrictions on the endorsement.

Clause 11 inserts new section 13A dealing with the restoration of nurses names to the register within 2 years from the date of their removal from the register when that removal was a result of a failure to renew the registration.

Clause 12 amends section 14 and provides that where the Board intends not to restore the registration or endorsement of a nurse on the ground that the nurse has not had sufficient experience in the past 5 years the Board must notify the nurse and give the nurse an opportunity to make a submission or to provide written submissions concerning that intended refusal to register.

Clause 14 inserts new section 15(2) providing that for the purposes of the Act and the Drugs, Poisons and Controlled Substances Act 1981, a nurse practitioner whose endorsement of registration is suspended is deemed not to have their registration endorsed for the period of that suspension.

Clause 15 inserts new section 16(5) to provide that if after conducting a hearing, the Board determines that the endorsement of registration of the nurse has been obtained by fraud or misrepresentation or that the qualifications upon which the nurse has relied for endorsement of registration have been withdrawn, the Board must cancel the endorsement of registration of the nurse.

The Committee notes that under the new section 16(5) the Board must cancel the endorsement of registration of the nurse where that registration was obtained by fraud, misrepresentation or qualifications that have subsequently been withdrawn.

The Committee resolved to seek clarification from the Minister that in circumstances where an endorsement is obtained in circumstances referred to in section 16(4) above why the Board should not declare the endorsement null and void (i.e. void ab initio). The Committee was concerned that without such a declaration, a nurse in a hypothetical case, may be able to legally claim, without any recourse being available to the Board, that he or she had been legally registered for a period and thus gain an unfair advantage in registration elsewhere.

Clause 19 inserts new section 19A dealing with the provision of information by nurses to the Board relating to certain court decisions such as if a person has claimed damages or other compensation from a registered nurse, or the employer of a registered nurse, for alleged negligence of the registered nurse in the course of providing nursing care.

This requirement does not apply where the amount is less than the amount fixed by the Board for the purposes of the section; or the court orders that the terms of the order should not be disclosed.

The new section further provides that if a registered nurse has in respect of an indictable offence been committed for trial; or been convicted or found guilty of the offence the nurse must notify the Board within 30 days after that committal for trial, conviction or finding of guilt.

The Board, by notice published in the Government Gazette, may fix an amount of damages or compensation referred to in this section.

Clause 20 inserts new section 20(2) and will allow a person to make complaint about a nurse whose registration has expired provided the conduct occurred while the nurse was registered and the complaint is made within 2 years after the nurse ceased to be registered. The Board may accept a complaint made more than 2 years after a nurse ceased to be registered if the Board considers that it is necessary to do so to protect the public.

Clause 22 substitutes new section 24 dealing with the Board’s powers to conduct investigations and hearings on the its own motion. New sections 24(1) and (2) provide –

The Board, of its own motion, may determine to conduct a preliminary investigation into the professional conduct of a registered nurse.

The Board, of its own motion, may determine to conduct a formal or informal hearing into the professional conduct of a registered nurse with or without conducting a preliminary investigation.

Clause 23 amends section 25 to allow the suspension of the registration of a nurse pending the conduct of an investigation or hearing. It also removes the need for a complaint to be made to the Board before it may determine to conduct a preliminary investigation. That is, the Board may make the suspension on its own motion.

Clause 24 also amends sections 25(1) and (2) to allow for suspension of any endorsement pending a hearing where the Board considers there is a serious risk to health and safety of the public.

Clause 25 makes amendments to sections 26, 27 and 29 to permit persons employed by the Board to conduct preliminary investigations into the health of a nurse.

Clause 30 inserts new section 47(e) to enable a hearing panel to determine that any information that might enable the registered nurse, the subject of the hearing to be identified, not be published or broadcast prior to the making of a final determination.

Clause 33 inserts new section 49B providing that if a person employed by the Board under section 77 makes a complaint under the Act, that person must not conduct a preliminary investigation into the matter and is not eligible to be appointed to a panel to conduct a hearing into the matter but otherwise is subject to the provisions of the Act applying to or in relation to complainants.

Clause 36 inserts new section 56A(c) creating an offence to publish information identifying a nurse until a panel makes a final determination of the matter.

Clause 39 inserts new sections 39(3) and (4) creating an offence for a person to arrange for another person, who is not a nurse practitioner, to work as a nurse practitioner. Or to arrange for a nurse practitioner to work in contravention of the terms of that nurse practitioner's endorsement of registration.

Clause 40 inserts new sections 64A to 64D relating to advertising nursing services, providing for the Governor in Council, on the recommendation of the Board, to issue guidelines, published in the Government Gazette, about the advertising of nursing services. It also allows courts power to require corrective advertising to rectify a contravention of the advertising provisions.

Proceedings for an offence against this section may be commenced within 3 years after the commission of the alleged offence.

Search and seizure powers

Clause 44 substitutes section 88 and inserts new sections 88A to 88D dealing with search and seizure powers.

Substituted section 88 provides that the Board must issue an identification card to each person appointed by the Board to apply for or execute search warrants for the purposes of the Act.

New section 88A provides that a person appointed by the Board, may apply to a magistrate for the issue of a search warrant in relation to particular premises.

The forms, practices and procedures of the Magistrates' Court Act 1989 apply to search warrants issued under the Act.

New section 88B provides that immediately before executing a search warrant, a person named in the warrant must announce that he or she is authorised by the warrant to enter the premises. The person need not comply if they believe on reasonable grounds that immediate entry to the premises is required to ensure the safety of any person or that the effective execution of the search warrant is not frustrated.

New section 88C provides that the occupier, where possible must be given a copy of the warrant.

New section 88D provides a person must be given a copy of any document or tape seized under a warrant. If a person seizes a thing under a warrant and has not provided a copy of the thing or information the person must provide a receipt for that thing as soon as practicable after the seizure.

Clause 46 substitutes section 102 by way of a transitional provision for certain nurse practitioners. It provides that despite section 8B (as inserted by clause 6), the Board may endorse the registration of a nurse who applies, within 10 years after the commencement of section 8B, for endorsement of registration if the Board is satisfied that the registered nurse has sufficient clinical experience in the category of nurse practitioner for which endorsement of registration is applied for, that the Board considers to be adequate for the purposes of endorsement of registration under section 8B.

Amendments to the Drugs, Poisons and Controlled Substances Act 1981

Clause 48 inserts new section 13(1)(ba) declaring that any nurse practitioner is authorised to obtain and have in his or her possession and to use, sell or supply any Schedule 2, 3, 4 or 8 poison prescribed in the regulations in relation to the category of nurse practitioner specified in the endorsement of that nurse practitioner's registration. But will not include selling or supplying such poisons by retail in an open shop unless the nurse practitioner is licensed under the Act to do so.

Clause 49 makes a number of amendments to sections 33 and 34 dealing with the supply or administering Schedule 8 poisons to drug-dependent persons.

Clause 50 inserts new sections 35(1A) and 35(2AA).

New section 35(1A) establishes an offence for a nurse practitioner to administer, supply or prescribe any Schedule 8 poison to or for any person believed to be a drug-dependent person unless the nurse practitioner holds a permit issued by the Secretary pursuant to section 34(1) of the Act.

New section 35(2AA) provides that a nurse practitioner must not at any time administer, supply or prescribe any Schedule 8 poison to or for any person, other than a drug-dependent person, during a continuous period greater than 8 weeks unless the nurse practitioner holds a permit issued by the Secretary.

Clause 51 amends sections 129 and 132 to permit regulations to be made concerning the new category of nurse practitioner created by the provisions in the Bill. This will permit controls to be exercised over nurse practitioners in the same manner that presently applies to other health practitioners such as registered optometrists, medical practitioners authorised under section 13 of the Act.

The Committee notes the inclusion in the regulation making power of the new category of ‘nurse practitioners’ created by the provisions in the Bill.

The Committee considers the provision is appropriate to give effect to the purposes of the Act.

The Committee makes no further comment.

Professional Boxing and Martial Arts (Amendment) Bill

Introduced: 1 November 2000
Second Reading Speech: 2 November 2000
House: Legislative Assembly
Minister: Hon. J. Pandazoploulos MLA with the Hon. M. Delahunty MLA.

Purpose

The main purposes of the Bill are to –

  • rename the Professional Boxing and Martial Arts Act 1985 as the Professional Boxing and Combat Sports Act 1985; and

  • enable a person registering as a contestant under that Act to be able to compete in both boxing and combat sports; and

  • provide statutory immunity to members of the Professional Boxing and Martial Arts Board for acts done in good faith.

Content and Committee comment

Clause 2 the provisions in the Bill come into operation on the day after Royal Assent.

Clause 3 changes the name of the Act from the Professional Boxing and Martial Arts Act 1985, to the Professional Boxing and Combat Sports Act 1985.

Clauses 4 and 5 amends the purpose and definitions sections respectively. Combat sports means – ‘kickboxing, or any sport or activity (other than boxing) in which each contestant in a contest or exhibition of that sport or activity is required to strike, kick, hit, grapple with, throw or punch the other contestant, and that is determined by the Minister to be a combat sport for the purposes of the Act’.

Clause 6 inserts a new section 5A enabling the Minister to recognise any properly constituted amateur association either an amateur boxing association or an amateur combat sport association for certain purposes of the Act.

The Committee will seek further information from the Minister concerning the need for existing associations to seek the recognition proposed by clause 6.

Clause 8 amends section 10A(2) to remove the need to register twice when a contestant competes in both professional boxing and professional combat sports contests. The amendment provides for a single certificate of fitness to be issued for participation in professional contests.

Clause 9 inserts a new section 14A and provides a statutory immunity to Board members against liability for anything done or omitted to be done in good faith in the exercise of a power or the discharge of a duty under the Act; or in the reasonable belief that the act or omission was in the exercise of a power or the discharge of a duty under the Act. Any liability resulting from an act or omission attaches instead to the State.

The Committee makes no further comment.

Racing and Betting Acts (Amendment) Bill

Introduced: 25 October 2000
Second Reading Speech: 26 October 2000
House: Legislative Assembly
Minister: Hon. R. Hulls MLA with the Hon. P. Batchelor MLA.

Purpose

The purpose of the Bill is to amend the Racing Act 1958, the Lotteries Gaming and Betting Act 1966 and the Gaming and Betting Act 1994.

Content and Committee comment

Clause 2 Part 1 comes into operation on Royal Assent. The remaining provisions of the Bill come into operation on proclamation but not later than by 1 July 2001.

Part 2 – Amendments to the Racing Act 1958

Clause 6 amends section 19(1) to remove the restriction on holding mixed sports gatherings within 25 kilometres of the GPO, Melbourne.

Clause 10 amends section 39 by changing the name of the Harness Racing Board to Harness Racing Victoria.

Clause 11 amends section 39(2) to increase the membership of Harness Racing Victoria from 5 to 7.

Clause 14 amends section 69 to effect a change of name from the Greyhound Racing Control Board to Greyhound Racing Victoria.

Clause 15 substitutes section 75(ad) to require that Greyhound Racing Victoria register greyhounds for greyhound racing or for stud or other purposes and to regulate the breeding, kennelling and verification of lineage of greyhounds for greyhound racing or for stud or other purposes.

Clause 23 inserts a new Part IIIC providing for the review of decisions in relation to occupational and bookmaking licences by the Victorian Civil and Administrative Tribunal.

Clause 25 inserts a new section 85 providing an immunity for members of the Bookmakers and Bookmakers Clerks Registration Committee, in respect of anything done or omitted to be done in good faith under the Act or the regulations. Any liability resulting from an act or omission attaches instead to the Committee.

Part 3 – Amendments to the Lotteries Gaming and Betting Act 1966 and the Gaming and Betting Act 1994

Clause 32 inserts new section 66A providing that if a course of conduct is being engaged in of unauthorised betting on any sporting contingency or contingencies, a person must not, knowing such conduct is being engaged in (whether the event or the betting takes place in Victoria) –

  • distribute any document to the public promoting or advertising any such betting (including any document about betting accounts or services);

  • make any transaction relating to any such betting;

  • offer or provide accounting, administrative or other services relating to any such betting.

The Committee makes no further comment.

Statute Law Amendment (Authorised Deposit-taking Institutions) Bill

Introduced: 1 November 2000
Second Reading Speech: 2 November 2000
House: Legislative Assembly
Minister: Hon. J. Brumby MLA with the Hon. L. Kosky MLA.

Purpose

The purpose of the Bill is to amend specified Acts so as to permit non-bank financial institutions to provide banking services to bodies regulated by statute.

Content and Committee comment

Clause 2 the provisions in the Bill come into operation on proclamation but not later than by 1 June 2001.

Clause 3 declares that an Act specified in the heading to an item in the Schedule is amended as set out in that item. The Schedule amends 90 Acts containing references to ‘bank’ and related terms. It removes references to building societies and credit unions which have become redundant following Commonwealth reforms.

As a consequence of the Commonwealth reforms the Bill substitutes new expressions for –

Current Expression New Expression
bank bank authorised deposit-taking institution within the meaning of the Banking Act 1959 (Clth).
bank account bank account an account with an authorised deposit-taking institution
bank cheque bank cheque a cheque drawn on account of an authorised deposit taking institution
bank draft bank draft a draft provided by an authorised deposit taking institution
bank guarantee bank guarantee a guarantee provided by a body permitted to use the expression "bank" under section 66 of the Banking Act 1959 (Clth)
bank overdraft bank overdraft an overdraft with an authorised deposit taking institution

The Committee makes no further comment.

Superannuation Acts (Beneficiary Choice) Bill

Introduced: 1 November 2000
Second Reading Speech: 2 November 2000
House: Legislative Assembly
Minister: Hon. L. Kosky MLA with the Hon. J. Brumby MLA.

Purpose

The Bill amends these Superannuation Acts –

  • State Superannuation Act 1988,

  • Police Regulation Act 1958,

  • State Employees Retirement Benefits Act 1979,

  • Superannuation (Portability) Act 1989,

  • Transport Superannuation Act 1988.

The purpose of the Bill is to provide for greater choice by way of a one-off election and future options to commute pension and deferred benefit entitlements; and to improve the administration of certain superannuation schemes.

The Committee notes the following relevant extracts from the Second Reading Speech –

The primary purpose of this Bill is to introduce legislation to implement a beneficiary choice program that will provide members and beneficiaries of the State Superannuation Fund with additional choice regarding the manner in which their entitlements are paid. The program will provide these individuals with the same options that are currently available to members of public sector schemes in most Australian States.

The Boards of the Government Superannuation Office and the Emergency Services Superannuation Scheme will implement the beneficiary choice program. The program is entirely voluntary, and independent financial advice will be available to members and beneficiaries to assist them consider the offer.

The beneficiary choice program will provide:

  • existing State Superannuation Fund pensioners with a one-off opportunity to commute 50 per cent or 100 per cent of their pensions to a lump sum;

  • current members of the State Superannuation Fund with the option of commuting 100 per cent of their pension entitlements to a lump sum as those benefits become payable, rather than the existing maximum of 50 per cent ;

  • existing and future deferred benefit members with the opportunity to convert their deferred benefit entitlement to a lump sum to be rolled over into a complying fund of their choice; and

  • former State Superannuation Fund pensioners whose pensions are administered by the Emergency Services Superannuation Board with a one-off opportunity to commute 50 per cent or all of their pensions to a lump-sum.

The one-off offer will be made to approximately 54 000 pensioners and 50 000 deferred beneficiaries. The ongoing change in fund rules will apply to approximately 73 000 existing members.

The beneficiary choice program will provide members and beneficiaries with a new level of choice and will place them on a par with their interstate and Commonwealth colleagues. The program should also reduce the State Superannuation Fund's unfunded liability and provide some flexibility in terms of the government's future outlays on superannuation.

There is no enhancement or reduction of benefits; rather, the program provides additional choice in terms of the mechanism by which benefits are paid.

Implementation of the program will require the establishment of a new scheme within the State Superannuation Fund. The new scheme will be established under the State Superannuation Act 1988. The sole purpose of the new scheme will be to facilitate the one-off commutations under the program and it will thus have a limited life span.

The one-off offer is expected to be made to existing pensioners in February 2001 and to existing deferred beneficiaries in April 2001. Individuals will be given three months to consider the offer.

The program will provide these individuals with the same choice that is available for their public sector interstate counterparts. The program is entirely voluntary and provides affected members and beneficiaries with more latitude to manage their own financial affairs. Independent financial advice will be provided to all those who receive an offer to ensure fully informed decision making occurs.

Content and Committee comment

Clause 2 provides the commencement provisions as follows –

  • Sections 3, 6, 10, 16, 18, 19 and 21, comes into operation on the day after Royal Assent.

  • Section 19(1) is deemed to have come into operation on 23 January 1980.

  • Section 19(2) is deemed to have come into operation on 1 January 1987.

  • Section 19(3) is deemed to have come into operation on 1 July 1988.

  • Section 10 is deemed to have come into operation on 1 July 1999.

  • Sections 3, 6, 16, 18 and 21 come into operation on 1 July 2001.

Part 2 – Amendments to the State Superannuation Act 1988

Clause 3 inserts a new Part 3A consisting of new sections 23A to 23G establishing the Beneficiary Choice Scheme within the Superannuation Fund.

Clause 4 inserts a new Part 9 into the Act establishing the Beneficiary Choice Scheme.

Clause 6 makes amendments relating to future commutation entitlements.

Clause 7 inserts new section 77B into the Act dealing with the re-instatement of certain disability pensioners. The section applies if the Board is satisfied that the application of a former disability pensioner to retire on the grounds of ill health and receive a payment under section 77A was materially influenced by an offer, or the prospect of an offer, of employment by the Department of Education, Employment and Training under the New Start Program or any other program which the Board determines to be similar to the New Start Program.

An application must be made within the period of 6 months after the commencement of the section or within such further period of time as the Board may determine.

Part 3 – Amendment to the Emergency Services Superannuation Act 1986

Clause 8 inserts new section 21JA enabling the Board to establish spouse accounts.

The Committee notes the following relevant extracts from the Second Reading Speech –

This Bill also allows the Emergency Services Superannuation Board to establish spouse accounts for its members.

Spouse accounts are attractive to members because a tax rebate exists for superannuation contributions made on behalf of a low income or a non-working spouse.

The Emergency Services Superannuation Scheme is the only superannuation arrangement in the State with an accumulation scheme component that is not able to offer spouse accounts. All former public sector accumulation schemes such as VicSuper and Health Super now offer spouse accounts. Public sector schemes in Queensland and Tasmania also offer spouse accounts.

Spouse accounts are considered to be beneficial in the context of the Emergency Services Superannuation Scheme, as 90 per cent of its membership comprises male members, most of whom have a non-working or low-income-generating spouse. Through its existing accumulation scheme, ESSPLAN, the Emergency Services Superannuation Board will easily accommodate the creation and administration of spouse accounts in a cost-effective manner.

The establishment of spouse accounts at the Emergency Services Superannuation Scheme does not create any risk for the government.

The accounts will be fully funded by the employees themselves. The government sees this initiative as a positive move for the members of the Emergency Services Superannuation Scheme.

Part 4 – Amendment to the Government Superannuation Act 1999

Clause 10 makes a retrospective amendment in respect to the operation of an Order in Council cited as the Specified Standards for the Preservation of Superannuation Benefits. The Order was made on 16 June 1999 and was to have commenced on 1 July 1999 but due to some oversight as it would seem, was not published in the Government Gazette until 20 July 2000.

New section 46A(2) provides that –

(2) Notwithstanding anything to the contrary in any Act under which the Order in Council was made or the failure to publish the Order in Council on or before 1 July 1999, the Order in Council is deemed –

(a) to have come into operation on 1 July 1999 as specified in the Order in Council; and

(b) to have full force and effect from 1 July 1999.

The Committee notes the following relevant extract from the Second Reading Speech –

The Bill also brings into operation an Order in Council relating to ‘Specified Standards for the Preservation of Superannuation Benefits’. This Order, which was due to come into operation on 1 July 1999, did not come into operation until it was gazetted on 20 July 2000.

The Committee notes that the retrospective provision appears to correct an administrative oversight.

Part 5 – Amendments to the Police Regulation Act 1958

Clause 12 inserts a new Division 5 in Part III of the Act to enable certain pensioners to participate in the Beneficiary Choice Program (the Program) and sets out how an eligible pensioner may apply to participate in the Program and the choices available to that pensioner.

Part 6 – Amendments to the State Employees Retirement Benefits Act 1979

Clause 13 inserts Part VI to enable certain pensioners to participate in the Beneficiary Choice Program. An eligible beneficiary or eligible pensioner may during the relevant election period apply in writing to the Board to participate in the beneficiary choice program in the form approved by the Board. The provisions set out the choices that may be made under the Program.

Clause 16 amends section 34AB to permit a member who is entitled to a deferred retirement benefit to elect to convert the entitlement to a present lump sum; and have the lump sum transferred to a complying superannuation fund nominated by the member.

Part 7 – Amendments to the Superannuation (Portability) Act 1989

Clause 17 inserts section 5A and applies the Beneficiary Choice Program to the Act and provides that an eligible beneficiary may during the relevant election period apply in writing to the administrator to participate in the beneficiary choice program in the form approved by the administrator. An eligible beneficiary must elect to commute the whole of his or her deferred retirement benefit entitlement.

Clause 18 amend section 5 and 7 to permit a member who is entitled to a deferred retirement benefit to elect to convert the entitlement to a present lump sum; and have the lump sum transferred to a complying superannuation fund nominated by the member.

Part 8 – Amendment to the Constitution Act Amendment Act 1958

Clause 19(1), (2) and (3) respectively insert new sub-sections 30(2)(bb), (bc) and (bd) in The Constitution Act Amendment Act 1958 that enable certain contributors under the, State Employees Retirement Benefits Act 1979, Emergency Services Superannuation Act 1986 and the Transport Superannuation Act 1988 who become Members of Parliament to be re-admitted to the Fund if they are re-employed in the service after leaving Parliament.

Re-admission is conditional upon the former contributor repaying benefits previously received from the Fund together with contributions that they would have been required to make if they had not ceased to be a contributor.

New section 30(2)(bb) inserts the relevant provision in the State Employees Retirement Benefits Act 1979 and by clause 2(2) the provision is deemed to have come into operation on 23 January 1980.

New section 30(2)(bc) inserts the relevant provisions in the Emergency Services Superannuation Act 1986 and by clause 2(3) the provision is deemed to have come into force on 1 January 1987.

New section 30(2)(bd) inserts the relevant provisions in the Transport Superannuation Act 1988 and by clause 2(4) the provision is deemed to have come into force on 1 July 1988.

The Committee notes the following relevant extracts from the Second Reading Speech –

Amendments are being made to the Constitution Act Amendment Act 1958 to correct an anomaly which has recently come to light, relating to the superannuation entitlements of members of the police force and certain other public servants who become members of Parliament and return to their former employment after leaving Parliament.

The amendments ensure that members of schemes governed by the State Employees Retirement Benefits Act 1979, the Transport Superannuation Act 1988 and the Emergency Services Superannuation Act 1986 who become members of Parliament and subsequently return to public sector employment, are treated no differently from their colleagues in schemes governed by the State Superannuation Act 1988.

The Committee notes that the retrospective provisions seek to correct an anomaly in the operation of these Acts and that the amendments are beneficial in nature.

The Committee accepts that the retrospective amendments are justified in the circumstances.

Part 9 – Amendments to the Transport Superannuation Act 1988

Clause 20 inserts Part 9 into the Act to enable certain pensioners and beneficiaries during a limited election period, to participate in the Beneficiary Choice Program. The provisions set out the options available under the Program.

The Committee makes no further comment.

University of Melbourne Land Bill

Introduced: 1 November 2000
Second Reading Speech: 2 November 2000
House: Legislative Assembly
Minister: Hon. S. Garbutt MLA with the Hon. M. Delahunty MLA.

Purpose

The purpose of the Bill is to make provision for –

  • the revocation of a reservation and a Crown grant relating to land at Parkville; and

  • the re-reservation of that land and the granting of a restricted Crown grant of that land to the University of Melbourne; and

  • leasing and licensing powers over that land.

Content and Committee comment

Clause 2 this Act comes into operation on proclamation but not later than by 31 December 2001.

Clauses 5 and 6 revoke the existing reservation and Crown grant of the land described in the Schedule to the Bill and states the legal consequences of the revocation.

Clause 7 re-reserves the land and provides that on the land specified in the Schedule ceasing to be reserved, that land is deemed to be permanently reserved under section 4 of the Crown Land (Reserves) Act 1978 as a site for science and biotechnology education, research and development purposes.

Clause 8 empowers the Governor in Council to grant the land to the University of Melbourne. The grant must include a condition that the land must not be used for any purpose inconsistent with the reservation of that land under section 7.

Clause 9 provides that the Crown grant may be revoked if the land use is inconsistent with the reservation.

Clause 10 provides that subject to sections 11 to 13, the University of Melbourne or its successor-in-law, must not sell, mortgage or otherwise dispose of its interest in the land granted under section 8.

Clause 11 the University of Melbourne may grant a lease of the land (not exceeding 25 years) granted under section 8 or any part (including a stratum) of that land for any purpose not inconsistent with and not detrimental to the reservation.

Clause 12 the University of Melbourne may grant a licence (not to exceed 25 years) to enter and use any part (including a stratum) of the land, granted under section 8, or any building on that land for any purpose not inconsistent with or detrimental to the reservation.

Clause 15 repeals the Melbourne (Veterinary School) Lands Act 1970.

Clause 16 ensures that existing third party interests in the land are unaffected.

The Committee makes no further comment.

Victorian Curriculum and Assessment Authority Bill

Introduced: 1 November 2000
Second Reading Speech: 2 November 2000
House: Legislative Assembly
Minister: Hon. M. Delahunty MLA with the Hon. L. Kosky MLA.

Purpose

The main purpose of the Bill is to establish the Victorian Curriculum and Assessment Authority. The Bill repeals the Board of Studies Act 1993.

Content and Committee comment

Clause 2 the Act comes into operation on proclamation but not later than by 1 December 2001.

Clause 4 to 7 provides for the establishment of the Authority; the objectives of the Authority; functions and powers. The Authority shall be a body corporate to develop high quality courses and curriculum and assessment products and services.

Clause 8 provides for Ministerial written directions to be given to the Authority in relation to the exercise of its powers and functions under the Act.

Clause 9 sets out the membership of the Authority. The Authority consists of not less than 8 and not more than 15 members.

Clauses 10 to 12 deal with the terms and conditions of appointment of members of the Authority; acting appointments and the establishment of committees.

Clause 13 provides for the staff of the Authority.

Clause 14 deals with meeting requirements and procedures of the Authority.

Clauses 15 and 16 are delegation provisions providing –

  1. The Authority may, by instrument under its common seal, delegate to the members of a committee established under section 12, a member of the Authority, the chief executive officer, or to any other person employed in the Department in the administration or execution of this Act or the Education Act 1958 any power of the Authority, other than this power of delegation.

  2. The Minister may, by instrument, delegate to any person employed in the administration or execution of this Act or the Education Act 1958 any power of the Minister under this Act, other than this power of delegation.

The Committee notes the delegation provisions in clauses 15 and 16 and accepts that they are appropriately limited and defined to achieve the purposes of the Act.

Clause 17 establishes the Victorian Curriculum and Assessment Authority Fund.

Clause 18 provides that the Authority has the investment powers conferred on it by the Borrowing and Investment Powers Act 1987.

Clause 19 repeals the Board of Studies Act 1993.

Clause 20 makes transitional arrangements consequent upon the repeal of the Board of Studies Act 1993. The Board (established by the Act to be repealed) is abolished and its members go out of office. All rights, property and assets (except any intellectual property rights in or in relation to any trade mark relating to the VCE) that, immediately before the commencement of section 19 were vested in the Board are, by force of this sub-section, vested in the Authority.

The Board of Studies Fund (the Board) established under the Board of Studies Act 1993 is abolished and all money standing to the credit of that Fund immediately before the commencement of section 19 is credited to the Victorian Curriculum and Assessment Authority Fund. All debts, liabilities and obligations of the Board existing immediately before the commencement of section 19 become the, debts, liabilities and obligations of the Authority.

Clause 21 provides that on commencement, a person who held office as a member of the Board or as the chairperson of the Board, is deemed to hold office as a member of the Authority or as the chairperson of the Authority subject to the Act, for the balance of his or her term of appointment to the Board and on the same terms and conditions as applied with respect to that appointment.

The Committee makes no further comment.

Victorian Environmental Assessment Council Bill

Introduced: 1 November 2000
Second Reading Speech: 2 November 2000
House: Legislative Assembly
Minister: Hon. S. Garbutt MLA with the Hon. M. Delahunty MLA.

Purpose

The purpose of the Bill is to establish the Victorian Environmental Assessment Council to conduct investigations and make recommendations relating to the protection and ecologically sustainable management of the environment and natural resources of the State of Victoria.

The Bill –

  • establishes the Victorian Environmental Assessment Council (the Council) with 5 members appointed by the Governor in Council;

  • enables the appointment of additional members of the Council for particular investigations;

  • provides for the Council to establish Committees and Community Reference Groups;

  • requires the Council to report on its operations;

  • sets out the process for requesting investigations to be carried out by the Council; sets out the considerations the Council is to have regard to in investigations and recommendations;

  • sets out the process for public submissions;

  • requires reports on investigations to be tabled in Parliament and made publicly available;

  • requires a statement of the response of the Government to recommendations to be tabled in Parliament and made publicly available;

  • requires the Government to implement recommendations to the extent that they are accepted by the Government;

  • repeals the Environment Conservation Act 1997.

Content and Committee comment

Clause 2 sections 1 and 2 come into operation on the day after Royal Assent. The remaining provisions come into operation on proclamation but not later than by 1 July 2001.

Clauses 4 to 7 establishes the Council (VEAC), sets out its objectives, functions and powers.

The objectives of the Council are to provide independent and strategic advice to the Government of Victoria on matters relating to the protection and ecologically sustainable management of the environment and natural resources of the State of Victoria.

The Council consists of 5 members appointed by the Governor in Council on the recommendation of the Minister.

Clauses 9 and 10 set out the terms and conditions of office of the members and provide for the proceedings of the Council.

Clause 12 provides that for the purposes of the Act, the Council may appoint any committees that it considers necessary and may abolish any such committee. The membership of a committee is not restricted to the membership of the Council.

Clause 13 provides that the Council must establish a Community Reference Group in respect of each investigation for the purpose of providing advice to the Council.

Clause 14 the Council must submit a report on its operation to the Minister on or before 31 October in each year.

Clause 15 the Minister may request the Council to carry out an investigation for the purposes of the Act.

Clause 18 the Council, in carrying out an investigation and making recommendations to the Minister must have regard to the matters listed in the clause.

Clause 19 the Council must confer with any Department or public authority which may be affected by the conduct or results of an investigation.

Clause 20 the Council must cause notice of an investigation to be published.

Clause 22 any person or body is entitled to make a submission to the Council on an investigation; a discussion paper; a draft proposals paper.

Clause 23 the Council must submit a written report on the results of its investigation to the Minister within the time specified by the Minister. The report must be laid before each House of the Parliament and be published on the internet.

Clause 25 the Minister must, not later than the first sitting day after the period of 6 months since the sitting day on which the report of the Council was laid before each House of the Parliament, cause a statement of the response of the Government to the report to be laid before each House specifying the action (if any) proposed to be taken by the Government with respect to each recommendation of the Council.

Clause 26 provides that if the statement of the response of the Government specifies that the Government wholly or partly accepts a recommendation of the Council, the Government must ensure that appropriate actions are taken to implement the recommendation to the extent that it has been accepted.

Clause 27 repeals the Environment Conservation Council Act 1997.

Clause 28 provides that the repeal of the Environment Conservation Council Act 1997 does not affect the continuing operation of any recommendation made under that Act; or any act, matter or thing done to give effect to a recommendation made under the Land Conservation Act 1970.

Clause 29 makes a consequential amendment to the Land Conservation (Vehicle Control) Act 1972.

The Committee makes no further comment.

Victorian Qualifications Authority Bill

Introduced: 1 November 2000
Second Reading Speech: 2 November 2000
House: Legislative Assembly
Minister: Hon. L. Kosky MLA with the Hon. M. Delahunty MLA.

Purpose

The main purposes of the Bill are to –

  • establish the Victorian Qualifications Authority (the Authority) and,

  • re-constitute the State Training Board of Victoria as the Victorian Learning and Employment Skills Commission and,

  • make consequential amendments to other Acts to transfer certain accreditation and registration functions of other educational authorities to the new Authority.

Content and Committee comment

Clause 2 the Act comes into operation on proclamation but not later than by 1 December 2001.

Clauses 4 to 6 establishes the Authority as a body corporate and sets out its objectives and functions.

Clauses 7 to 9 set out the powers of the Authority and provides for Ministerial directions to be given to the Authority.

Clauses 10 to 14 make provision for the terms and conditions of appointment of the members; acting members; validity of acts or decisions of the Authority; meetings of the Authority; and the employment of staff.

Clause 15 allows the Authority to establish any committee and appoint members to it including persons not members of the Authority. The Committee may exercise any power or perform any function delegated to it by the Authority.

Delegation

Clause 16 provides –

The Authority may, by instrument under its common seal, delegate any function or power of the Authority, other than this power of delegation to any of the following--

(a) a member of the Authority;

(b) a member or the members of a committee established under section 15;

(c) the Director or any other person employed under section 14;

(d) the Secretary or any other person employed in the Department;

(e) the Commission;

(f) the Adult Community and Further Education Board;

(g) the Victorian Curriculum and Assessment Authority.

(2) The Authority may, by instrument under its common seal, delegate any power of the Authority to award or issue qualifications to any of the persons or bodies referred to in sub-section (1) or a registered education and training organisation.

The Committee notes that the effect of clause 16(1)(b) is that the Authority may delegate to any person(s) appointed to a committee. The Committee further notes that unlike a similar provision relating to the appointment of committees in clause 12 of the Victorian Curriculum Assessment Authority Bill (also in this Alert Digest), no Ministerial approval is required for appointment to a Committee under this Bill and further the delegation provision only permits delegation to the members of a committee and not to a member of a committee.

The Committee also notes that clause 15 provides that ‘a committee may exercise any delegated power’, however clause 16 further amplifies the delegation power to ‘a member of a committee’ established under clause 15.

Given that there is no Ministerial oversight in the appointments the Authority may make to a committee established under clause 15 of the Bill, the Committee will write to the Minister to seek further information concerning the widely defined delegation powers in clause 16(1)(b) and to clarify whether the delegation is intended collectively to the committee or to any member of a committee so established.

Clause 17 establishes the Victorian Qualifications Authority Fund.

Clause 18 provides that the Authority has the investment powers conferred on it by the Borrowing and Investment Powers Act 1987.

Clause 19 requires the Authority to maintain a State Register of Accredited Courses and Recognised Qualifications.

Clause 20 requires the Authority to maintain a register of persons or bodies authorised under clause 23 to provide accredited courses (as assessed by the Authority under section 21) or issue recognised qualifications.

Clause 21 provides that the Authority may investigate any course or part of a course to determine whether it should be registered as accredited.

Clause 23 any person or body that provides or proposes to provide an accredited course may apply to the Authority for registration of that person or body with respect to that course under section 20.

Clause 24 provides that the Authority may recognise the completion of an accredited course or part of an accredited course or the award or issue of a recognised qualification by the issue of a written statement or otherwise.

Clause 25 provides for an offence for a person or body to use the name or title of ‘registered provider’ or any other name, title, letters or description implying or that may reasonably be understood to imply that the person or body is registered to provide a course or part of a course unless the person or body is registered under section 20.

Clause 26 provides that a person or body must not in relation to a course or part of a course provided by the person or body use the name or title of "government accredited" or any other name, title, letters or description implying or that may reasonably be understood to imply that the course or part of a course is registered as accredited under section 19 unless the person or body is registered under section 20.

Clause 27 provides that the Authority may approve a person or body to provide any course to students from overseas.

Clause 28 provides that the Director may appoint a person employed under section 14 as an authorised officer for the purposes of this Act.

Clause 29 provides that the Director must furnish an authorised officer with an identification card bearing a recent photograph of the officer.

Powers of authorised officers

Clause 30 provides that an authorised officer with any necessary help, may enter, at any time during ordinary working hours on any day, any premises where a person or body registered under section 20 or 27 is providing a course or part of a course or where the officer has reasonable cause to believe that a person or body is providing a course or part of a course; and may make any inquiries or inspect and examine any documents and take copies or extracts from those documents; and, may make any inquiries or inspect and examine any documents and take copies or extracts from those documents.

Clause 34 allows for regulations to be made and provides –

(1) The Governor in Council may make regulations for or with respect to –

(a) fixing fees to be charged by the Authority for any services provided by it; or

(b) any other matter or thing required or permitted to be prescribed or necessary to be prescribed to give effect to this Act.

(2) The regulations –

(a) may be of general or limited application; and

(b) may differ according to differences in time, place or circumstance.

The Committee accepts that the regulation making powers are appropriate to give effect to the purposes of the Act.

Clause 36 provides for transitional arrangements for the new Authority.

Amendments to the Vocational Education and Training Act 1990

Clause 38 amends the name and functions of the State Training Board. The clause amends section 8(1) and provides that there is established a Commission to be called the Victorian Learning and Employment Skills Commission and amends section 9(1) inserting new functions for the Commission.

Clause 39 amends section 13 to provide for the membership of a Commission of up to 9 members.

Clause 40 inserts new section 99 to provide transitional arrangements for the Commission deeming the Victorian Learning and Employment Skills Commission to be the same body as the State Training Board of Victoria despite the changes to the name and structure of the Board by sections 38 and 39 of the Bill, and no act matter or thing is to be affected because of those changes of name and structure.

The members of the State Training Board of Victoria who held office immediately before the commencement of section 39 of the Bill, go out of office on that commencement.

The Committee makes no further comment.


Footnotes
Œ

Section 29 deals with an owners liability for a dogs that bites, attacks, worries or chases any person or an animal.