Parliament of Victoria

FEDERAL-STATE RELATIONS COMMITTEE

Report on

FEDERALISM AND THE ROLE OF THE STATES:
COMPARISONS AND RECOMMENDATIONS

ButtonHome

ButtonE-mail the Committee


Appendix 5: Meetings and witnesses to date

    Victorian meetings

      August 6th 1996
      • Ms Judy Tyers, Assistant Secretary; Mr John Sullivan, Senior Policy Officer; Mr Tim Barta, Policy Officer, Intergovernmental Relations Branch, Department of Premier and Cabinet.

      November 7th 1996
      • Mr Douglas Brown, Visiting Doctoral Candidate, Centre for Public Policy, University of Melbourne, former Executive Director, Institute of Intergovernmental Relations, Queen’s University, Canada.

      November 26th 1996
      • Mr Howard Ronaldson, Director of Housing; Mr Bruce Prosser, Acting Assistant Director, Business Planning and Analysis Branch, Department of Human Services.

      December 17th 1996
      • Mr Warren McCann, Secretary; Mr Bruce Prosser, Acting Assistant Director - Business Planning and Analysis Branch; Ms Sharon Willcox, Manager - Intergovernmental Relations and Acute Health Division; Ms Rosemary Calder, Aged Care Services Redevelopment, Department of Human Services.

      February 24th 1997
      • Dr John Paterson, Secretary, Department of Infrastructure; Professor Jeff Richardson, Director, Centre for Health Evaluation, Monash University; Mr Francis Sullivan, Executive Director, Australian Catholic Health Care Association.

      March 4th 1997
      • Dr Phyllis Rosendale, Director; Mr Dean Yates, Senior Policy Analyst, Intergovernmental Financial Relations Branch, Department of Treasury and Finance.

      April 7th 1997
      • Ms Fiona Hanlon, Acting Head, Cabinet Office; Mr Tony Thomas, Senior Adviser, Government Branch, Department of Premier and Cabinet.

      April 15th 1997
      • Professor Brian Galligan, Director, Centre for Public Policy, University of Melbourne; Professor Cheryl Saunders, Director, Centre for Comparative Constitutional Studies, University of Melbourne; Associate Professor Mark Considine, Visiting Lecturer, Political Science Department, Deakin University; Mr Doug Brown, Visiting Doctoral Candidate, Centre for Public Policy, University of Melbourne, former Executive Director, Institute of Intergovernmental Relations, Queen’s University, Canada.

      April 21st 1997
      • Mr Ken Baxter, Director, Management Consulting, KPMG.

      May 19th 1997
      • Mr Bill Scales, Chairman; Mr Robert Kerr, Head of Staff; Mr A Dolling, Industry Commission.

      June 2nd 1997
      • Professor Iva Deutchman, Visiting Lecturer, Department of Political Science, University of Melbourne.

      June 30th 1997
      • Professor Cheryl Saunders, Director, Centre for Comparative Constitutional Studies, University of Melbourne; Ms Kris Walker, Lecturer, Faculty of Law, University of Melbourne; Professor Brian Galligan, Director, Centre for Public Policy, University of Melbourne; Mr Bill Campbell, First Assistant Secretary, Office of International Law, Commonwealth Attorney-General’s Department; Senator Vicki Bourne, Senator for New South Wales; Dr David Kinley, Legal Specialist, Australian Law Reform Commission.

      August 12th 1997
      • Mr John Waugh, Lecturer, Faculty of Law, University of Melbourne.

      September 2nd 1997
      • The Hon Brian Howe, Professorial Associate, Centre for Public Policy, University of Melbourne, former Deputy Prime Minister of Australia.

      September 11th 1997
      • Mr Gary Sturgess, Principal, Sturgess Australia.

      November 5th 1997
      • Associate Professor Neville Norman, Department of Economics, University of Melbourne; Ms Claire Thomas, Director, Taxation and Revenue Policy Branch; Mr Brett Rowse, Director, Intergovernmental Financial Relations Branch, Department of Treasury and Finance; Mr Nick Economou, Lecturer, Department of Politics, Monash University; Associate Professor Martin Painter, Department of Government and Public Administration, University of Sydney; Mr Dick Rye, Chairman, Commonwealth Grants Commission; Ms Bronwyn Pike, Executive Officer, Evatt Victoria Centre.

      February 23rd 1998
      • Mr Mark Paterson, Chief Executive, Australian Chamber of Commerce and Industry; Professor John Freebairn, Melbourne Institute of Applied Economic and Social Research, University of Melbourne; Ms Alison McLelland, Director, Social Action and Research, Brotherhood of St Laurence; Ms Ann Sherry, General Manager, Human Resources, Westpac Bank.

      April 16th 1998
      • Senator Helen Coonan; The Hon Dick Adams MP; Mr Gary Hardgrave, Joint Standing Committee on Treaties

      June 2nd 1998
      • Professor Leslie Holmes, Department of Political Science, University of Melbourne.

      June 9th 1998
      • Dr Ray Nicholls, Head, Department of Politics, Monash University.

      September 21st 1998
      • The Hon Stephen Hatton, Chairman; Mr Rick Gray, Executive Officer, NT Legal and Constitutional Committee.

      October 29th 1998
      • The Hon Bill Hartley MLA, Deputy Speaker, Legislative Assembly of British Columbia.

      November 5th 1998
      • The Hon Kevin Minson MLA, Chairman, Mrs Monica Holmes MLA; Mr Peter Frantom, Clerk of the Committee; Ms Melina Newnan, Legal/Research Officer, Western Australian Standing Committee on Uniform Legislation and Intergovernmental Agreements.

      November 16th 1998
      • Mr Ralph Lysyshyn, Executive Director, International Forum of Federations.

      December 3rd 1998
      • Dr Hans Otto Braeutigam, Chairman of the Permanent Advisory Council and Plenipotentiary of the State of Brandenburg to the Federal Government and for Europe; State Secretary Heide Doerrhoefer-Tucholski, Plenipotentiary of the State of North-Rhine Westphalia to the Federal Government; State Secretary Norbert Schueren, Plenipotentiary of the State of Hesse to the Federal Government; State Secretary Dr Karl-Heinz Klaer, Plenipotentiary for Federal and European Affairs of the Rhineland Palatinate State Government; State Councillor Mr Erik Bettermann, Plenipotentiary of the Free Hanseatic City of Bremen to the Federal Government; State Minister (retired) Professor Ursula Maennle; Ms Ute Müller, Head of the Bundesrat Presidial Office; Dr Christian Daestner, Deputy Director of the Bundesrat.

      February 22nd 1999
      • The Hon John Bannon, former Premier of South Australia; Dr Nick Economou, Lecturer, Department of Politics, Monash University; His Execellency Ambassador Aneurin Hughes, Delegation of the European Commission to Australia and New Zealand; Professor Cheryl Saunders, Director, Centre for Comparative Constitutional Studies, University of Melbourne; The Hon Angus Redford MLC, Presiding Member, South Australian Legislative Review Committee; Professor David Collins, Division of Economic and Financial Studies, Macquarie University; Professor Bhajan Grewal, Centre for Strategic Economic Studies, Victoria University of Technology; Dr John Nieuwenhuysen, Chief Executive, Committee for Economic Development of Australia; Dr Michael Keating, Visiting Fellow, Economics Program, Research School of Social Sciences, Australian National University; Mr Mike Reynolds AM MLA, Parliamentary Secretary to the Premier of Queensland; The Hon Brian Howe, Professorial Associate, Centre for Public Policy, University of Melbourne, former Deputy Prime Minister of Australia; Professor Brian Galligan, Director, Centre for Public Policy, University of Melbourne; Dr Christine Fletcher, Director, North Australia Research Unit, The Australian National University; The Hon Andrew Thomson MP, Chairman, Joint Standing Committee on Treaties, Commonwealth Parliament

      Interstate meetings

        Canberra

          February 26th 1997
          • Mr Ian Biggs, Executive Director; Ms Kate Sumner, Executive Officer, Treaties Secretariat, Department of Foreign Affairs and Trade; Ms Colleen McBrien, Commonwealth-State Relations Secretariat, Department of the Prime Minister and Cabinet.

          • Mr Bill Taylor MP, Chairman, Joint Standing Committee on Treaties.

          February 27th 1997
          • Ms Jenny Macklin MP, Shadow Minister for the Aged, Family and Community Services.

          • Dr John Uhr, Senior Fellow, Reshaping Australian Institutions Project, Australian National University.
          • Mr Rod Nockles, Senior Adviser to Senator Newman, Minister for Social Security; Mr J Jordan, Acting Assistant Secretary, Housing Programs Branch, Department of Social Security.
          • His Execellency Ambassador Aneurin Hughes, Delegation of the European Commission to Australia and New Zealand.
          • Dr Richard Madden, Director; Mr Geoff Sims, Head of Division; Mr N Mercer, Database Management Group, Australian Institute of Health and Welfare.

          May 28th 1998
          • Mr Bill Taylor MP, Chairman, Joint Standing Committee on Treaties.

          • Senator The Hon Brian Gibson, Chairman, Tax Consultative Task Force.

          Sydney
            February 28th 1997
            • Mr Peter Hendy, Policy Manager; Mr Mark Duckworth, Policy Adviser; Intergovernmental Relations Unit, New South Wales Cabinet Office.

            • Mr Alan Rose, President, Australian Law Reform Commission.
            • Dr Kerrie Bigsworth, Acting Director, New South Wales Office of Housing Policy.
            • The Hon Nick Greiner, former Premier of New South Wales.
            • The Hon Patricia Forsythe MLC, Shadow Minister for Community Services, Disability Services and on Ageing, Shadow Minister for Housing and Shadow Minister for Women’s Affairs; Ms Jillian Skinner MP, Shadow Minister for Health and Youth Affairs.

            May 29th 1998
            • The Hon Bob Hawke, former Prime Minister of Australia.

            • Associate Professor David Collins, Division of Economics & Financial Studies, Macquarie University.

            Brisbane
              June 26th 1997
              • Associate Professor Glyn Davis, Centre for Australian Public Sector Management, Griffith University.

              • The Hon Mike Horan MLA, Minister for Health; Ms Geri Taylor, Director, Health Systems Strategic Branch, Queensland Health.
              • The Hon Wayne Goss MP, Member for Logan, former Premier of Queensland.
              • The Hon Dr David Watson MLA, Minister for Public Works and Housing; Mr Mal Grierson, Deputy Director-General; Mr Eric Carfoot, Executive Director, Department of Public Works and Housing.
              • Professor Kenneth Wiltshire, Department of Government, University of Queensland.

              June 27th 1997
              • Mr Chris Goodreid, Director; Mr Denzil Scrivens, Senior Adviser, Intergovernmental Relations Branch, Department of Premier and Cabinet.

              • Ms Wendy Edmond MLA, Shadow Minister for Health, Queensland.
              • The Hon Terry Mackenroth MLA, Shadow Minister for Housing, Local Government and Planning, Communication and Information.
              • Mr Robert Harper MP, Parliamentary Secretary to the Deputy Premier, Treasurer and Minister for the Arts; Mr Walter Ivessa, Assistant Under-Secretary for Social Services, Queensland.

              Adelaide
                July 3rd 1997
                • Professor Cliff Walsh, Director, South Australian Centre for Economic Studies, University of Adelaide.

                • Professor Peter Howell, Department of History, Flinders University, Chair, South Australian Constitutional Advisory Council.
                • Ms Christine Charles, Deputy Chief Executive, Strategic Policy and Cabinet, Department of the Premier and Cabinet; Dr David Philby, Executive Director, Policy and Budget, South Australian Health Commission.

                July 4th 1997
                • The Hon John Bannon, former Premier of South Australia.

                • Mr Bob Solly, Chief Executive Officer; Mr Peter Mylius-Clark, Manager of Housing Policy, Department of Housing and Urban Development; Mr Rob Schwartz, Assistant Under-Treasurer; Mr John Henderson, Manager, Commonwealth-State Relations, South Australian Treasury.
                • Mr Ian Dickson, Chief Executive Officer; Ms Caroline Procter, Officer of Local Government; Ms Caroline Cranwell, Adviser to the Minister for Local Government.

                Darwin
                  August 21st 1997
                  • Dr Christine Fletcher, Director, North Australia Research Unit, The Australian National University.

                  • Mr Peter Carew, President; Ms Carole Frost, General Manager, Northern Territory Chamber of Commerce and Industry.
                  • Mr Rick Gray, Executive Officer; Mr Graham Nicholson, Legal Adviser, Sessional Committee on Constitutional Development.
                  • Mr Lyal Macintosh, Chief Executive; Mr Neil Almond; Mr Nathan Sammy, Department of Asian Relations, Trade and Industry.

                  August 22nd 1997
                  • Professor Marcia Langton, Centre for Indigenous and Natural and Cultural Resource Management, Northern Territory University.

                  • Mr Peter Blake, Secretary; Dr Eric Nunn, Department of Mines and Energy.
                  • Mr Phil Luck, Director of Administration, Trade Development Zone Authority.

                  Overseas meetings

                    Canada

                      Victoria, British Columbia

                        June 15th - 16th 1998
                        • The Hon Glen Clark, Premier of British Columbia.

                        • Mr David Harris, Chief of Protocol, Parliament of British Columbia.
                        • Mr Anthony Humphreys, Sergeant-at-Arms, Parliament of British Columbia.
                        • Mr Craig James, Clerk of Committees; Mr Geoff Plant MLA, Member of Parliament of British Columbia.
                        • The Hon Gretchen Mann Brewin, Speaker; Mr E George MacMinn QC, Clerk, Legislative Assembly, Parliament of British Columbia.
                        • Mr Chris Johnson, Policy Advisor; Mr Paul Flanagan, Policy Analyst, Ministry of Finance and Corporate Relations.
                        • Mr Bill Hartley MLA, Deputy Speaker, Parliament of British Columbia.
                        • The Hon Andrew Petter, Minister of Intergovernmental Relations, British Columbia.
                        • Dr Norman Ruff, Associate Professor, Department of Political Science, University of Victoria.
                        • Mr Bruce Morgan, Manager, Corporate Policy Branch, Ministry of Environment and Lands.

                        Ottawa
                          June 18th - 19th 1998
                          • The Hon Stephane Dion, Minister for Intergovernmental Relations; His Excellency Mr Greg Wood, High Commissioner for Australia.

                          • The Hon Don Boudria PC MP, Leader of the Government, House of Commons.
                          • The Hon Herb Dhaliwal PC MP, Minister for National Revenue.
                          • Professor Ron Watts, Fellow, Institute for Intergovernmental Relations; Associate Professor Douglas Brown, Policy Studies, Queen’s University.
                          • Mr Peter Gusen, Director, Federal-Provincial Relations Division; Ms Shauneen Furlong, Chief, Federal-Provincial Relations Division; Mr Geoff Hughes, Tax Policy Branch, Department of Finance.
                          • Mr Denis Meunier, Director; Ms Marilyn Viger, Federal-Provincial Division; Mr Stan Farber, Goods and Services Tax Amendments, Revenue Canada.
                          • Mr George Anderson, Deputy Minister for Intergovernmental Affairs, Privy Council Office.
                          • Mr James Lahey, Deputy Secretary, Integovernmental Policy and Communications; Mr Philip Ventura, Director-General, Coordination and Advisory Service, Privy Council.

                          United States of America

                            New York
                              June 22nd 1998
                              • Mr Leonard Guttman, Assistant Vice President, Intergovernmental Affairs; Mr Peter Klemperer, Assistant Vice President, New York City Health and Hospitals Corporation.

                              • Ms Sakiko Fukuda-Parr, Director, Human Development Report Office, United Nations.
                              • Mr Hermann Habermann, Director, Statistics Division, Department of Economic and Social Affairs, United Nations.
                              • Mr Sabbir Cheema, Director; Mr Thord Palmlund, Special Advisor, Management Development and Governance Divisions, United Nations Development Program.

                              Annapolis, Maryland
                                June 23rd 1998
                                • The Hon Henry Heller, House Chairman, Joint Committee on Federal Relations, House of Delegates of Maryland.

                                • Ms Frances May, Policy Analyst and Legal Adviser, Department of Legislative Services, Government of Maryland.
                                • Ms Karen Morgan, Principal Analyst and Counsel, Joint Committee on Federal Relations, Department of Legislative Services.
                                • Ms Jenny Lazarus, Visits Coordinator, Maryland Parliament.

                                Washington DC
                                  June 24th - 26th
                                  • Ms Kristine Simmons, Professional Staff Member, Senate Committee on Governmental Affairs.

                                  • Father Robert Drinan, Professor of Law, Georgetown University Law Center.
                                  • Mr Dennis Bartlett, Director of External Affairs, American Legislative Exchange Council.
                                  • Mr Michael Messinger, National Partnership for Reinventing Government.
                                  • Mr Ed Ferguson, Deputy Director, National Association of Counties.
                                  • Mr Charles Griffiths, Executive Director; Ms Donna Schwartz, Research Coordinator, Advisory Commission on Intergovernmental Relations; Ms Winifred Lyday, National Association of Counties.
                                  • Mr Bob Silvanik, Director, Policy and Program Development Branch, Council of State Governments; Ms Jennifer Lakins Mellow, Senior Staff Assistant, National Governors’ Association.
                                  • Mr Peter Cleveland, Professional Staff Member, Committee on Foreign Relations, United States Senate.
                                  • His Excellency The Hon Andrew Peacock, Ambassador for Australia.
                                  • Senator Jim Lack, State of New York; Mr Carl Tubbesing, Deputy Executive Director, National Conference of State Legislatures.
                                  • Mr Edward Meese, Ronald Reagan Distinguished Fellow, The Heritage Foundation.

                                  Germany

                                    Mainz
                                      June 30th 1998
                                      • Mr Siegfreid Herrman and Members of Parliament, Parliament of Rhineland Palatinate.

                                      Bonn
                                        July 1st 1998
                                        • Mr Uwe Leonardy, Office of the State of Lower Saxony.

                                        • Professor Ursula Maennle, Bavarian Minister for Federal Affairs.
                                        • Dr Christian Daestner, Vice-Director of the Bundesrat; Mr Josef Hoffmann, Assistant to the Vice-Director of the Bundesrat.

                                        Belgium

                                          Brussels
                                            July 2nd - 3rd 1998
                                            • Mr Francis Vermeiren, Senior Vice President; Mr Marc Olivier, Senior Vice President; Mr Kris Van Esbroeck, Director, External Relations; Mr Frank Swaelen MP, President of the Senate, Vlams Parliament.

                                            • Mr Yves Quitin, Principle Administrator, Interparliamentary Delegations Secretariat, European Parliament.
                                            • Mr James Nicholson MEP, Chairman, Delegation for Relations with Australia and New Zealand, European Parliament.
                                            • Mr Ricardo Gosalbo Bono, Legal Advisor, European Commission Legal Service.
                                            • Mr Dietrich Pause, Secretary-General, Committee of the Regions.
                                            • Ms Nathalie De T’Serclaes MP, President, Standing Committee for Revision of the Constitution, Belgian Parliament.
                                            • Mr Robert Delathouwer MP, Belgian Parliament

                                            United Kingdom

                                              London
                                                July 6th 1998
                                                • Rt Hon Dafydd Wigley MP; Mr Robert Corbett MP, House of Commons.

                                                • Mr Arthur Donahoe QC, Secretary-General, Commonwealth Parliamentary Association.
                                                • Mr Paul Jackson, Assistant Secretary, Commonwealth Parliamentary Association United Kingdom Branch, House of Commons.
                                                • Mr Mark Batho, Assistant Director of Finance, Scottish Office.








                                                RETURN TO TOP

                                                GO TO APPENDIX 6

                                                RETURN TO TABLE OF CONTENTS